Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

POLITICS: Main Men

MAIN MEN

Lt. Gov. John Wilder, the 82-year-old dean of the Tennessee General Assembly and the longtime Speaker of the state Senate, was dishing through a plate of salmon and stir-fried vegetables at the Cumberland Club last Thursday, sitting at a window seat overlooking the state Capitol building and reflecting on some things, both hither and thither, that concern him these days.

They included (in no particular order) his forthcoming race for reelection against Republican opponent Ron Stallings, his relations with other state leaders (notably House Speaker Jimmy Naifeh and Governor Phil Bredesen), the fate of some significant last-minute legislation, the fuss he has kicked up of late concerning his views on such subjects as abortion and affirmative action (“My constituents aren’t going to be bothered,” he said cagily), and the nature of the universe.

On the latter subject, he proclaimed that “the cosmos is eternal,” and dilated on such aspects of it as the oxidation/carbonation process that, paradoxically, underlies both life (as in the act of breathing) and death (as in the corrosion of surfaces). He inveighed against the excesses of environmentalists, pronouncing, “The solution to pollution is dilution,” and ridiculed attempts at creating synthetic fuels when, as he said, “all the fuel we need is already there, and it’s in the ground.”

Wilder is, somewhat famously, a nominal Democrat who prides himself on his bipartisanship (his perennial elections to head the Senate depends on reliable backing from senators in both parties, and he appoints both Democrats and Republicans to head committees). He is distressed therefore to find himself once again, as in 2002, the target of a Republican opponent..

Of course, Wilder will probably be supported, this year as four years ago, by most members of the senate, Republicans as well as Democrats. His problem so far has been the current Number one Democrat, Governor Bredesen. As Wilder observed, the governor has acquired an admirable level of public support by enacting Republican policy objectives (serious budget cuts coupled with reforms in such areas as workers’ comp, TennCare, and driver’s licenses) while performing fund-raising favors for Democrats.

“He’s got his favorites,” said Wilder about recipients of Bredesen’s fund-raising favors. “So far,” he added pontedly, “they haven’t included Senator [Steve] Cohen, and they haven’t included me.” He has hopes that the latter fact, at least, will change.

n One Senate Democrat who can almost certainly call on the governor for help is Memphis’ Roscoe Dixon, now a candidate for General Sessions Court clerk. Dixon received a thank-you call from the governor last Thursday, shortly after changing his mind (after abundant lobbying) and casting the decisive votes that allowed the governor’s workers’ comp legislation (opposed by organized labor, trial lawyers, and some key Democrats) to pass its final committee hurdle in the Senate.

  • Doubt that Bredesen is the political man of the hour? Benny Lendermon, president of ther Riverfront Development Corporation, last week cited the governor as a character reference of sorts for the RDC’s agenda, which is due for a crucial hearing this week at city council.

    According to Lendermon (who told the story on the night the RDC played cohost at the barbecue festival tent of Mayor Willie Herenton) the governor, while on a visit to the city last year, fell to wondering where might be a good place to each lunch with a good view of the river. Told that the number of restaurant venues was limited, the governor reportedly said, “What! You have an asset like this [the river], and you leave it undeveloped! Unbelievable!”(Or words to that effect.)

    The RDC would, in any case, probably have difficulty getting Bredesen to publicly endorse the riverfront project. With politics of his own to deal with, the governor has so far proved loath to get involved in local controversies of any sort.

  • Shelby County Mayor A C Wharton, who proved no political slouch in winning his own 2002 race with ease, is frequently asked to apply his skills to other people’s efforts Ð having served as campaign manager for two of Memphis Mayor Herenton ‘s reelection efforts and as Shelby County director for such statewide races as that of Democrat Jim Cooper for the U.S. Senate in 1994.

    Wharton, a native of Lebanon in middle Tennessee, was tapped this week to serve as keynote speaker at a West Tennessee Kerry-for-President rally in Jackson.

    Watch Out, Willie!

    Two prominent Memphians who are meditating on a city mayor’s race for 2007 are entrepreneur/activist Carol Coletta and city council member Carol Chumney. Both, either directly or through surrogates, have begun to take soundings of possible support.

    Through each has other potential sources of support, each is clearly also counting on the gender factor which has propelled so many women, especially judicial candidates, to success in recent years.

    Chumney, who has experienced a good deal of difficulty with her council colleagues since taking office, last week revisited the state Capitol in Nashville, scene of her 13 years’ service in the state legislature. Members of the city’s African-American clergy report approaches from her about a potential mayor’s race.

  • Rematch? Another well-known political figure is planning a race in the near future. Ready?: Joe Cooper.

    The former county squire, veteran political operative, and frequent candidate says he wants to make another run at the District 5 count commission seat now held by Republican Bruce Thompson, who beat Cooper, then running as a Democrat, in 2002.

  • Categories
    News The Fly-By

    No Protection

    When U.S. Army soldier Allison DeVant reported that she’d been raped by another member of the military, she says she didn’t receive counseling. Instead, she was harassed, interrogated, and intimidated by her commanders. She began standing up to them, and in October of last year, she was discharged. She’d had dreams of becoming an officer.

    Now she’s taking to the streets with a message for all women who may be considering joining the military: Rape is common, and if it happens don’t let anyone intimidate you into thinking you’ve lost your civil rights.

    Donning a black beret and camouflaged military garb, DeVant and a friend hold weekly protests outside the Air Force Recruitment Office at the corner of Danny Thomas Boulevard and Beale Street. DeVant’s sign reads, “In the U.S. military, female soldiers have no protection against rape.”

    “I love my military and I’m as patriotic as the next person, but I’m speaking out against those few who do the damage and make the cover-up,” said DeVant. “I’m not going to say that women shouldn’t join, but they need to be aware that if they are raped or assaulted, they still have rights. And if they report, they could be harassed, intimidated, or blamed.”

    DeVant said many women do not report rape in the military for fear of harassment, and even when they do, the rapist rarely receives more than a slap on the wrist. According to Army statistics from 1996, out of 440 rapes in that year, only 33 resulted in convictions.

    She said she still hasn’t received counseling, and is hoping to find a lawyer to represent her in a civil suit against the military. She said she’s talked to several lawyers but most are “afraid to take on the government.”

    “I’ll continue the protests until someone steps forward and helps me,” she says. “And even after that, I’ll be an advocate to young women in this situation. If they continue to let this happen, they’re going to undermine the very foundation of the military. They’re going to hurt America.” n

    E-mail: bphillips@memphisflyer.com

    Categories
    News The Fly-By

    The Real Thing?

    Maybe art is an abstract painting with a $1,000 price tag. Maybe art is a quilt made from fabric scraps. The debate, however, discussed briefly in the past month via e-mails, could help spawn some new partnerships.

    After the South Main Arts Festival last month, South Main Association president Katrina Shelton sent out a press release about the historic district’s first trolley tour since the legislature granted them the right to serve alcohol at their events. In it, she mentioned how “many attendees said that it felt like the first ‘real’ arts festival they’d seen in Memphis.”

    Wendy Sumner Winter, director of the Midtown Artist Market, said she saw in the release a good opportunity to start a dialogue. “It had that word ‘real’: the first real arts festival with ‘real’ in quotes. I know quite a few artists who have had encounters with people who say craft isn’t art. There’s an attitude if it’s utilitarian, it isn’t art,” she said. “The art that is traditionally made by women and minorities is called ‘craft.’ I’m fine with it being called ‘craft.’ I’m not fine with it not being art.”

    In her own e-mail, Winter said she thought the South Main Festival was a wonderful and valuable part of the Memphis arts community, but said, “While South Main’s focus on ‘real’ art may seem to them to be legitimate, I have seen it often to be far too limiting, alienating and somewhat arrogant.”

    What followed were a few e-mails lobbed back and forth, with people discussing both the merits of the complaint and the person who complained.

    Shelton said she never thought her press release would generate so much discussion but understands why it did. “I think because it’s such a sensitive subject. What’s art? What’s not art? What’s a historic art district? It became emotional.”

    Both Shelton and Winter are hoping more action will come from the discussion. Shelton said that South Main was already thinking about partnering with other art entities in the city, such as the UrbanArt Commission, and the e-mails have spurred them on.

    And Winter said she would love to see some sort of gallery association come out of the discussion. “In Memphis, you have to work together to get people interested in art. This balkanization is not in anyone’s best interest,” she said. “The restaurant association [is] a successful group. There’s in-fighting, but they make it work. I think we could do it.” n

    E-mail: cashiola@memphisflyer.com

    Categories
    Editorial Opinion

    The Bottle Broken

    “Hope begets disappointment, and we are now in a moment of disappointment when it comes to Iraq. During these shakeout moments, the naysayers get to gloat while the rest of us despair, lacerate ourselves, second-guess those in charge, and look at things anew. But this very process of self-criticism is the precondition for the second wind, the grubbier, less illusioned effort that often enough leads to some acceptable outcome.”

    So wrote David Brooks, the conservative op-ed columnist, this week in The New York Times, further arguing, “the weeks until June 30 are bound to be awful, but we may be at the start of a new beginning.”

    The “naysayers” to whom Brooks refers no doubt includes editors of newspapers like this one. Indeed, we at the Flyer stand guilty as charged, having been “nattering nabobs of negativism” (as Spiro Agnew so famously characterized his enemies in 1970) ever since the mad idea of a unilateral American invasion of Iraq first began making the rounds in the summer of 2002. That October, we urged Congressman Harold Ford Jr. to vote against the War Powers Act (he didn’t), and the following winter pleaded with the Bush administration to allow Hans Blix’s UN weapons inspections to be concluded before contemplating war against Saddam Hussein (he didn’t either). And in March 2003, as the president ordered an invasion of Iraq over what amounted to a de facto UN Security Council veto of his actions, we cried foul: “With its radical concept of preventive war,” we wrote, “the Bush administration is about to let a potentially dangerous genie out of the bottle.”

    Yes, we were naysayers, early and often. But all that doesn’t give us now the slightest sense of satisfaction. One cannot gloat while men, women and children are dying. We take no pleasure from predicting that the unleashing of what Senator Robert Byrd early on called “the dogs of war” would get us into a mess of such monumental proportions.

    No, and even negativity nabobs like ourselves never imagined that events would unfold in the truly diabolical fashion that they have: with the President’s WMD causus belli proving to be total fabrication, with a military “liberation” strategy so thoroughly inept that tyranny in Iraq has been replaced by anarchy, with the regime of a historic Iraqi war criminal being replaced by an occupation force guilty of war crimes of its own.

    And yet Brooks, poignantly, still sees the bottle as somehow half-full. “There’s something about our venture into Iraq,” he writes, “that is inspiringly, painfully, embarrassingly, and quintessentially American.”

    Really? Is it “quintessentially American” to launch an invasion of another sovereign state without proof of genuine threat to our national interests? Is it “quintessentially American” to kill thousands of innocent Iraqi civilians and not even bother to keep an accurate body count? Is it “quintessentially American” to ask our soldiers to die for a war built upon a lie?

    Perhaps Brooks failed to read the gripping interview published earlier this week in The Sacramento Bee (www.sacbee.com), in which Marine Sgt. Jimmy Massey, an Iraq veteran, detailed numerous instances of random violence against Iraqi civilians during the actual invasion last spring. Today, Massey has no doubts why our troops are facing a nationalist insurgency (“We killed a lot of innocent people”), and deeply regrets his own role in the slaughter. “I killed innocent people for our government,” he admits. “For what? Where is the good coming out of it? I feel like I’ve had a hand in some sort of evil lie at the hands of our government.”

    So have we all, Sgt. Massey. The bottle is neither half-full nor half-empty, but well and truly broken. And the genie has come roaring out. n

    Categories
    Film Features Film/TV

    The Boys of Troy

    I was dragged to a Chicago suburb Saturday night to watch an abysmal set of stand-up comics in the basement of a bowling alley. One performer began his set with this: .Anyone see the ads for Troy? Is it just me or does this look like the most expensive gay porno ever made? Or at least like a birthday party an eccentric gay billionaire would throw for himself.. His Troy gag was helpful to me in that it highlighted a challenge of the film and its marketing: its appeal to men. Will Joe Average and Hank Beer want to see a movie about Brad Pitt and Orlando Bloom and 50,000 sweaty, muscled, tunic-wearing men . even with a war as its centerpiece? The answer will be seen over the next few weeks when word of mouth reveals Troy to be either an omni-gendered affair or an expensive, almost all-male chick flick.

    For those not familiar with the oldest and most enduring story ever told (older than the Bible), or for those who only know Homer as a bumbling, animated family patriarch, Troy goes like this: Trojan princes Hector (Eric Bana) and Paris (Bloom) are on a peace-keeping errand in Sparta. Paris falls for kingly host Menelaus. lovely young bride Helen (Diane Kruger), and he whisks her back to Troy for his own. This starts a war between Troy and most of Greece, and only a great, big, wooden horse and the might of warrior Achilles (Pitt) can infiltrate the impenetrable walls of Troy and avenge the .theft..

    Pitt worked out ferociously for months, with four hours a day of intensive body-building and four hours of fight training. Physically, he is everything that Achilles should be: beautiful, god-like, a fighting machine. But the script and direction betray him. Achilles is not a brooding, James Dean, introspective Hamlet-type, which is how he is played by Pitt. Achilles is a hero with a tragic flaw (almost always hubris). The Iliad, like the writings of the ancient Greeks, is not about language or character development. It.s about larger-than-life themes: gods, goddesses, vengeance and might, and fury and fate. With fate behind all decisions, there is almost no need for character because there is no inner struggle. The Greek myths are painted in the broadest of strokes to create the largest of pictures. Twenty-first century audiences require nuance and detail (not that Troy has much of either), and so this story is saddled with a mortality and humanity that saps it of what makes it great in the first place: infinity.

    Unfortunately, the disappointment lands on Pitt, who must straddle immortality and death in a role that asks little more of him than pouting . especially when his .cousin. Patroclus is killed, mistaken for Achilles. This would have made more sense if the script acknowledged Patroclus as Achilles. lover. But since that could be a turn-off, we will just have to wonder why Achilles gets so mad when Patroclus dies . just like in the 1958 film version of Cat on a Hot Tin Roof with the threat of homosexuality confusingly excised for mainstream audiences.

    Troy has much to prove. Pitt, a superstar and a member of Hollywood.s $20-million club, has only carried a blockbuster once: Seven, and that was nine years ago. Likewise, Troy.s success will have much to say about the leading-man future of Eric Bana, whose supporting performance was the best thing about Ridley Scott.s 2001 Black Hawk Down but who languished as Ang Lee.s 2003 titular Hulk. Pitt will do fine because he.s buff and fights well, and we all know he can act from Seven and Twelve Monkeys, and he should have hits long through Ocean.s Twenty. And it will be some time yet before a romantic comedy or courtroom drama will test Bloom.s mettle. But so long as he.s shooting arrows and buckling swashes in the company of $200 million-grossing Hobbits and pirates, he.s safe. It.s Bana who is the revelation as Hector. His warrior physique and huge, vulnerable eyes mix perfectly for a romantic hero. Hulk, Shmulk. He will survive.

    Fortunately, Troy follows the model of all great and not-so-great Hollywood epics by having a multi-national cast with British accents for characters who wouldn.t have spoken English, anchored by the last surviving British theatrical aristocracy. That.s why we get Peter O.Toole as King Priam, who, dusted off, is still the best actor in any scene he is in, despite squandering his legend for a quarter century with poop like Club Paradise and Supergirl.

    My advice: Come for the Brad, savor the Bloom, and stay for the Bana. And never, under any circumstances, underestimate O.Toole. n

    Categories
    Music Music Features

    Labors of Love

    You may not know his name, but you know Harlan T. Bobo. You’ve seen him anyway. He’s a perennial sideman, best known as the bass player for Nick D. Ray’s Viva L’American Deathray Music. Now, after too many years of riding shotgun, he’s moved into the driver’s seat with Too Much Love, a beautiful collection songs about one man’s magnificent obsession.

    If you’ve ever driven through Midtown, you’ve probably noticed Bobo walking down the sidewalk or riding some ramshackle bike. You’ve probably said to a traveling companion, “I wonder what that guy’s story is.” He’s a lean one, skinny to the point of being sunken with long arms dangling out of a grubby T-shirt, like Stanley Kowalski. He wore a cowboy hat so broken-down even Bob Dylan wouldn’t adopt it and a pencil-thin moustache that looked like he mugged John Waters and made off with the director’s personal grooming habits. If you’ve seen him traveling west, guitar in tow, you may have felt compelled to stop and offer a little advice: “Nashville’s the other way, buddy.”

    Of course, Bobo, who began his musical career as a West Coast pedal-steel player, knows exactly where Nashville is, and he knows he doesn’t want to live there.

    “I lived in Waynesboro for a while when Yvonne [Bobo] was doing an internship with these master woodworkers who live there in a place called Hippie Hollow. And we would go into Nashville, or we would come to Memphis for work. I worked at a steakhouse in Lawrenceburg back then for this guy named Beefy. He’d put his arm around me and call me ‘Little Buddy.’ He’d have me drive him around so he could shoot at mailboxes on the way to the private club to get drunk. I was fresh out of San Francisco and that was some kind of foreign to me. But we were looking for a city to move to, and Nashville is too much like a little L.A.”

    Yvonne Bobo, a sculptor and installation artist, isn’t Harlan’s wife. She’s not his sister either. Right now, she is his boss. And there can be no denying she’s the muse fueling Too Much Love. Every hand-made cover (each one unique) bears a dada-inspired dedication, and the nine-song cycle tells the story of a difficult love affair. Difficult to describe anyway. It’s a personal yarn but never self-absorbed: revealing but never voyeuristic.

    Harlan took Yvonne’s name as a “kind of unofficial wedding vow” after he met her in California. Everything that followed was, to hear him tell it, unofficial. It was also impossible to avoid.

    “Her name is Bobo, how could I resist?” he says. “What a great name. When I met her I was living in a halfway house in San Francisco. They let me go out at night because playing music was my job. It was kind of weird for everybody else they kept there, because I’d come home smelling like booze and perfume.”

    The San Francisco band Bobo played in was called Minnie Pearl Necklace, a punked up country-western burlesque extravaganza fronted by a drag queen.

    “But not your every day drag queen,” Harlan points out.

    Then along came Yvonne and an adventure that took Harlan from California to Brazil, from Brazil to Waynesboro, and from Waynesboro to Memphis.

    “I can’t imagine a better place musically. I was able to go up to all of these guys like Greg Cartwright [of the Reigning Sound] and [Matador recording artist] Tim Prudhomme and ask them if they would help me record. To my surprise, they all said yes, and that’s where [Too Much Love] came from. All these guys would say, let’s try this, or let’s do that, and it worked out. I guess.”

    Too Much Love is a folk-rock concept album cut from the same fabric as the Reigning Sound’s debut, Break Up, Break Down. As one might expect given the stellar cast of local talents (Prudhomme, Geoff Soule, Elizabeth Venable, Doug Easley, and Cartwright), it’s quality stuff. Musical content ranges from gentle Spanish guitar on the seductive Tom Waits-inspired opener “It’s Only Love” to the angular guitars riffs and manic ranting on “Too Much Love,” which call to mind “Psycho Street”-era Richard Thompson. The peculiar Billy Swan-ish vocals of “Left Your Door Unlocked,” perhaps the album’s finest cut, wrap themselves around the story of a reluctant stalker passing an ex’s house and knowing it’s temporarily unoccupied. He takes a look around just to see if things have changed and to pretend that nothing’s changed. The song is beautiful, heartbreaking, and maybe even a little creepy.

    “I didn’t even know it was about a stalker,” Harlan says, laughing. “Really, I was totally welcome in that house. My presence was almost required.”

    Harlan wasn’t born Harlan any more than he was born Bobo, but that’s who he is today. Actually, he’s not entirely sure who he is today let alone what he’s becoming.

    “When my mom writes me she writes ‘Dear Harlan,” he says. “She paid $125 to get my birth certificate legally changed to Harlan.” But what’s in a name, right? Gone these days are the crumpled cowboy hat, the pencil-thin mustache, the grubby T-shirt, and the ragged paint-spattered boots. All the visual tropes that made Harlan T. Bobo stand out in a crowd the way his name stands out on a page have been discarded like last year’s next big thing.

    “I saw a picture of myself,” he explains with a shrug. “I guess I’ve been trying to market myself lately. I’ve been making all these one-sheets and taking pictures, stamping my name on every single cover: Harlan T. Bobo, Harlan T. Bobo. After a while it’s like, who is that guy Harlan T. Bobo? Tim Prudhomme says I have to imagine myself like a character on the stage. I used to try to write songs like that character in the cowboy hat. They just weren’t true. They just weren’t honest. They just weren’t me.” n

    Harlan T. Bobo

    Too Much Love record-release party

    The Hi-Tone CafÇ

    Saturday, May 22

    Categories
    Letters To The Editor Opinion

    postscript

    Crunk

    To the Editor:

    Regarding the articles on Criminal Manne (“Straight Gangster”) and Hickory Hill (“Hickory Hill or Hickory ‘Hood?”) in the May 13th issue: The fact that “Nobody wants to listen to ‘Stop The Violence’ anymore. Everybody wants to get crunk! They want to hear ‘I’m gonna bust your m–f–king head!,” is the exact reason why rap music has become stagnant, mundane, and boring, and part of the reason why Hickory Hill is now known as Hickory ‘Hood.

    Joel Murphy

    Memphis


    To the Editor:

    Your article on Criminal Manne was disappointing. I realize your publication tries to encourage a pluralistic interest in music, but the people who listen to that type of music don’t generally read periodicals. Manne’s interview was nothing more than his base way of displaying naked avarice: “They’ve already got their plates. They’re burping, gaining weight, everything. Now I need to get mine.”

    When Manne “gets his” is he going to put any of it in savings? Is he going to try and give something back to his community? Is he going to try and help young people stay out of jail? Probably not.

    Manne said, “It’s hard to stay out of jail.” Actually it isn’t. I’ve been a police officer for 10 years, and I know that if someone goes to work, pays their bills, and abides by the law, the chances are fairly slim they’ll be our guest at 201 Poplar. Manne wears his violence and his jail time like a badge of honor. Somewhere along the line, going to jail got glorified instead of being disgraceful. Until people with influence try to dispel the “Criminal Mannes” of this city, the glorification of violence will persist, and young people, even children, will continue to die horribly.

    Everyone must do their part to educate. I’m doing mine the best way I know how because, like Manne, I was raised in South Memphis.

    Officer Patrick C. Twele

    Memphis Police Department

    Bob James

    To the Editor:

    I am writing to thank you for your recent outstanding editorial (May 6th issue) depicting the accomplishments of our founder, Bob James. I had the good fortune of getting to know him over the last year of his life and admired his genuine interest in doing good for our community.

    Your description of him as being “ever keen of mind and generous of spirit” is a perfect depiction of this dedicated public servant. The phenomenal success of Crime Stoppers is his lasting legacy for us all. We’ll miss Bob James.

    Walter Crews, Executive Director

    Crime Stoppers

    Memphis

    To the Editor:

    In the mid-1960s, I was a teenager with a drinking problem. After several arrests for public drunkenness, the Juvenile Court decided to yank me out of high school and either incarcerate me or force me to join the Army. Those were my choices, because in those days counseling and therapy were not readily available.

    It was a lot for a 17-year-old to deal with, but fortunately Bob James, who was then working with Juvenile Court authorities, heard about my plight and came to my home to talk to my family and me. Mr. James was a gracious, kind, and empathetic man who saw something worthwhile in me and decided to help. Based solely upon his recommendation to the judge, I was allowed to finish high school and go on with my life.

    I will always remember the kindness and compassion Bob James showed to a confused, scared teenager who desperately needed a helping hand.

    Randy Norwood

    Memphis

    A Racist Ruling?

    To the Editor:

    Regarding the case of Jerry and Louise Baker’s quest for the oldest daughter of Jack and Casey He: The judge’s racist ruling discredits the concept of family and insults Chinese-Americans and the Chinese people. Extending the judge’s logic, we should immediately get all the kids out of China to be raised by good Christian white people. How condescending!

    The Bakers should have relinquished the child when she was two. Their agenda was apparent when they chose to prevent the parents from picking her up for a photo. When this child finds out who her real parents are, the suffering will begin for everyone. How sad it is for the child.

    Scott Chalgren

    Aptos, California

    Categories
    Music Music Features

    Bubba and the Beast

    Look around. There’s doctors down on Wall Street sharpenin’ their scalpels and tryin’ to cut a deal. Meanwhile, back at the hospital we got accountants playin’ God and countin’ out the pills

    Yeah, I know, that sucks — that your HMO ain’t doin’ what you thought it would do

    But everybody’s gotta die sometime and we can’t save everybody. It’s the best that we can do. — “Amerika v. 6.0 (The Best We Can Do)” by Steve Earle

    “It is never, ever unpatriotic or un-American to question anything in a democracy, no matter what anybody else says what an insult it is,” the ever controversial Steve Earle recently told a New Zealand reporter.

    Earle had made the list: The New York Post‘s now-infamous list of traitors who dare to disagree with our infallible president.

    “I just wasn’t raised as an artist to believe that you censor yourself because of being afraid of offending someone,” he says.

    Earle is nothing if not an artist. But the descriptions author, activist, poet, actor, and troubadour also fit. As a musician, he’s always been impossible to categorize by trend or genre. Is he the proud papa of alt-country or the last of the real Texas Outlaws? When Earle and Randy Travis made the Nashville scene in the mid-1980s, the industry coined the term new country just for them.

    Earle’s earliest recordings flirt with classic rockabilly, but his earliest releases drew comparisons to Springsteen. Over the years since his 1986 debut Guitar Town alerted critics (if not the public) to a new light shining in the forest of American roots music, Earle has recorded classic rock, country, Celtic, folk, and bluegrass. He’s harmonized with Emmylou Harris and Sheryl Crowe. He’s gotten down in the gutter with the Pogues. He’s become a genuine workingman’s hero with serious academic appeal.

    At age 49 Earle’s name is still occasionally linked to Springsteen or John Mellencamp. When he sang “Shadowlands” on the politically charged album Jerusalem, he fomented his ties to Hank Williams and the heart of Honky Tonk.

    Way out yonder, where the wild wind blows

    There’s a place where lonely fools can go

    Where if you hold your money, it’ll burn your hand

    So you buy you a ticket to the shadowland.

    More and more frequently, however, Earle’s name is paired with cultural icons and cult heroes like Bob Dylan, Merle Haggard, and Townes Van Zandt, Earle’s wayward mentor.

    “Good teacher, bad role model.” That’s Earle’s standard description of “Pancho and Lefty” songwriter Van Zandt. He was an incorrigible drunk who Earle, while still in his teens, once tied to a tree to keep him sober. Of course, we’re going “behind the music” here, and naturally Earle follows in Van Zandt’s footsteps. While writers at Rolling Stone penned a glowing “Country Album of the Year” review for Guitar Town, Earle was cruising the streets of south Nashville looking for a fix. He’s blamed a few of his many failed marriages on “mutual interest in drug abuse,” and he did a few months jail time in the early 1990s. But that was then.

    If there is an artist who Earle may be rightly compared, it’s the Man in Black: Johnny Cash. He’s been a mean-eyed cat, sampled all the best sins, and come through all the better. His tireless campaign to end the death penalty has made him a hero of the left while his redneck anthems have made him the darling of gun-rights-Republicans. For almost 20 years his songs have redefined traditions and defied trends. Through it all Earle has never been a man to beg for mercy. Justice has been his chief concern.

    Bubba and the Beast are the two fictional personas Earle assumes when he writes his songs. Bubba’s a redneck. He’s the guy wailing, “I learned a thing or two from Charlie don’t you know. You better stay away from Copperhead Road.” The Beast is a malevolent spirit that draws down depression like lightning. It’s the voice of “Shadowlands,” and “John Walker’s Blues,” a sympathetic look at the young American Taliban fighter John Walker Lindh.

    I don’t like Kid Rock, and I’m not trying to impress Charlie Daniels and Hank Williams Jr. or any of those people,” Earle told the New Zealand press. “[I have] some friends I think are really politically aware and are scared, but I wouldn’t name any names. But they are terrified about the effect [that speaking out against the government] would have on their careers And the government has capitalized on that.”

    Bubba, the Beast, rebel rocker, country torchbearer, political shack-shaker, social activist, uncompromising artist not to be missed, ladies and gentlemen, Steve Earle. n

    Steve Earle headlines Artrageous, a fund-raiser for the Greater Memphis Arts Council on Friday, May 21st at United Warehouse, 138 St. Paul Ave. (one block east of S. Main’sCentral Train Station). In addition to Earle, Artrageous will showcase a variety of visual and performing artists. Tickets are available through Ticketmaster.

    Categories
    Music Record Reviews

    Short Cuts

    When the Sun Goes Down

    Kenny Chesney

    (BMG)

    Question: What do you call a modern country singer whose music owes more to James Taylor, Jimmy Buffett, and John Mellencamp than to George Jones, Johnny Cash, and Merle Haggard? Answer: Honest.

    The lead single from Kenny Chesney’s current multi-platinum platter, “There Goes My Life” is a tale about babies making babies that is so skillfully manipulative that it could crack all but the hardest of hearts (although it might well be a subtle anti-abortion jingle). The second single, “When the Sun Goes Down,” is a beach-bum, blue-eyed-soul duet with Uncle Kracker (?!) that you might desperately want to hate, but the song’s stolen tip-of-your-tongue melody (Sam Cooke’s “Good Times”?) and fully realized it’s-five-o’clock-somewhere vibe are so undeniable that resistance is impossible. You wanna know why Chesney has become the biggest male country star since Garth Brooks? This CMT-dominating double-shot tells you: He may be utterly insidious and more than a little creepy, but he’s absolutely great at what he does.

    He’s also tapped fully into a young, modern, suburban, Sun Belt demographic that has become country music’s new core audience over the past decade or so. If Brooks’ background as a college marketing major came through a little too much, Chesney is a regular guy to the core. He romanticizes his college days like no other country star, but it’s not clear if he ever actually went to class.

    “I Go Back” is about how songs can sing you back home, but what sets him off is “Jack and Diane” and “Only the Good Die Young.” The memories he cherishes are of drinking cheap hooch after a high-school football game and hitting the Carolina coast after graduation. Chesney’s vision of paradise can be summed up by an easy shorthand: “A blanket, a girl, some raspberry wine.”

    Drinking is the one time-honored country theme Chesney has down, perhaps too well for his own liver. But his hard-drinking doesn’t take place in honky-tonks. It takes place at frat parties blaring the Steve Miller Band, at college bars where he’s trying to pick up a “really cute Kappa Delta,” at tropical locales on binge-drinking spring breaks, and back at the Lambda Chi Alpha fraternity house at East Tennessee State University, where there was a keg in the closet, pizza boxes on the floor, and a “dog named Bocephus” sleeping in the front yard.

    Chesney’s betting that contemporary country-music fans identify with these subjects more than life down on the farm or cheatin’ situations and that they’d rather hoist their Coronas to a Nashville version of the classic rock they grew up on than to a Nashville version of the mall-pop and adult-contemporary found elsewhere on the FM dial. And he’s hit the jackpot.

    But the real treat (or trick?) of When the Sun Goes Down is that, even if you don’t identify with this background (and I don’t), you can still get cultural kicks from taking a guided tour of a culture that isn’t your own –sort of like watching a good non-Western foreign film! It helps that the backbeats and riffs go down easier than anything you can hear on commercial rock radio.

    Even though Chesney seems pretty proud of not having much on his mind beyond his next drink or the last coed to cross his path, When the Sun Goes Down is spiked with a gem of an inspirational anthem called “Some People Change.” The song is as manipulative as “There Goes My Life,” but working clearly for the forces of good. In the first verse, the son of a “rebel yeller” breaks free of his received racism, realizing that even though he was “raised to think like his dad,” that doesn’t mean he has to. I imagine (hope?) a lot of Chesney’s fans identify pretty strongly with that idea as well.

    Simply put, in a country scene riven by culture wars, Chesney is a uniter, not a divider. (The chorus to “Some People Change” borrows the rhetoric of patriotism for a purpose most country-music flag-wavers wouldn’t envision.) Toby Keith and the Dixie Chicks may be at odds, just like the pure-country traditionalists and pop-lite careerists perpetually fighting over the soul of music city. But Chesney knows that when the sun goes down, they’d all be happy to just grab a margarita and kick back for a while. — Chris Herrington

    Grade: B+

    Kenny Chesney performs Friday, May 21st, at The Pyramid, with Dierks Bentley and Keith Urban.

    Kick Up the Fire, And Let the Flames Break Loose

    The Cooper Temple Clause

    (RCA)

    Few musical genres are as disturbingly bipolar as contemporary British rock: It can hit astounding highs (Verve, Radiohead, some mid-period Blur) and unbelievable lows (Starsailor, late-period Travis). We’ve already had one relative high this year with the fop-pop of Franz Ferdinand, and now we have the corrective low: Kick Up the Fire, And Let the Flames Break Loose, the stunningly disappointing major-label debut of the Cooper Temple Clause.

    The album title comes from a Philip Larkin poem, which probably says a lot more about the band’s pretensions to art than they intended. Notorious in England for their rambunctious live shows, the Clause trade that rock fury for a fatally wrongheaded notion of artistic maturity.

    The 10 songs trudge along slowly, digressing into unconnected codas and shifting styles with no real purpose. “Into My Arms,” for example, begins as a blandly romantic lament (“One night, one night is never enough/With you”) before jumping abruptly to Nine Inch Nails-style industrial beats in the outro. And the self-absorbed “Music Box” shifts clumsily between Kid A sound effects and Brand X heavy metal riffs. Unfortunately, the ADHD song structures feel forced and self-conscious.

    As a result, Kick Up the Fire sounds fatally pompous and plodding, lacking personality and devoid of any spark suggested by its title. —Stephen Deusner

    Grade: C

    Murs 3:16: The 9th Edition

    Murs

    (Definitive Jux)

    There are some people who seem mysteriously, indefinably likable even if you never spend a moment with them. Call it charm, call it charisma, call it generosity of spirit, call it pheromones, call it Johnny Depp disease, but it’s an old gift that plenty of pop-culture heroes were endowed with at birth. In the interest of balancing the universe, however, there are –there must be — some would-be pop figures who are plenty talented and smart but just not likable. And while this bland curse doesn’t explain why he doesn’t sell as many records as Eminem, Los Angeles indie rapper Murs falls into the latter category.

    Maybe it’s his tone of voice. Although flickers of anger (mostly at his dumb friends and dumber bitches) sometimes illuminate his compressed vignettes, most of Murs’ vocals exude mercenary professionalism and smarts without heart; the guy can make sex in a doorway sound dull. Maybe it’s the vignettes themselves. He raps without shame about hustling for cans and grocery money, and he’s relatively honest about his first few couple of sexual encounters, but he’s also the first one to warn the fellas that they shouldn’t leave him alone with their girls. Or maybe he’s just trying too hard to appear sensitive. The album’s most provocative and uncompromising track, “And This is For,” is a sharp, straightforward critique of hubcaps and white-culture imperialism that is discomfiting enough to provoke debate rather than white guilt or outrage. It’s the one time where Murs’ level-headed, pedantic KRS-ONE flow clarifies his message. It’s kind of a drag as music — which is a rarity considering producer 9th Edition‘s skillful production elsewhere — but it works well as a fishbone in the album’s throat. n —Addison Engelking

    Grade: B+

    Categories
    News News Feature

    CITY BEAT

    LEADING LIBERAL

    At a time when Memphis is afflicted with watery ideas and partisan political in-fighting, if you only buy one book this summer, you could do worse than Lucius: Writings of Lucius Burch.

    Burch was a Memphis attorney and adventurer who died in 1996. An outspoken liberal, he fought against Boss Crump, defended Martin Luther King Jr., and befriended the NAACP. The “neophytes” who collected his writings and put out this book with publish-on-demand Cold Tree Press in Nashville Ñ Cissy Caldwell Akers, Shirley Caldwell-Patterson, Bill Coble, and John Noel Ñ did Burch and Memphis a service. At 425 pages, it may be a little too long, and the quality is uneven. But Burch had something to say. He led an incredibly full life. And he kept good notes and put his first-class education and wide reading to good use. His travel writings alone are worthy of Paul Theroux or Tim Cahill.

    As a lawyer, Burch made good money, but he didn’t spend it on box seats, fancy clothes, or a Destin condo. Practicing law, he wrote, “permits more freedom and is most conducive to living an expansive personal life.” To him that meant a private plane, a castle in Ireland, hunting and fishing and scuba diving anywhere he wanted to go, and backpacking by himself for weeks at a time. He reasoned that all human motion by whatever means involved risk, and it was just a matter of calculating the odds.

    There is a great story in this collection by Tom BeVier, a former reporter for The Commercial Appeal. It’s called “The Most of the Buffalo Snort,” the reference being to the Indian practice of getting everything out of the buffalo but the snort. When Burch crashed his private plane in a thunderstorm in Memphis in 1972, the city desk got a report that he was dead. BeVier was assigned to write his obituary. Burch survived, despite severe injuries, and he allowed BeVier to accompany him on a hike on the Appalachian Trail two years later. At the age of 62, Burch walked “the obituary writer” nearly to exhaustion and regaled him with stories. It’s a kind of local journalism that is nearly extinct.

    We can only hope that Burch’s type of man and civic leadership is not extinct, but you have to wonder. He was a self-described secular humanist who made no secret of his reliance on reason over religious doctrine. Today’s politicians and columnists who wear their Christianity like a badge would have no use for him, nor he for them.

    Burch never strayed from liberalism, but some of his best friends were conservatives. No “red staters” versus “blue staters” for him. He delighted in telling the story of a legal adversary who called him a “super-serviceable son-of-a-bitch” because “if you ordered a carload of sons of bitches and the railroad parked the boxcar at your factory and you opened the door and only he stepped out, you wouldn’t make a claim against the railroad for shortage.”

    A hardcore conservationist and namesake of the Wolf River nature preserve in Shelby Farms, he shot eagles for a bounty in Alaska as a young man. He did it not for sport but at the behest of the U.S. Biological Survey and the Territory of Alaska, which were being prodded by ranchers and fishermen who saw the eagle as a predator. What a shocker that would be to some of the less tolerant members of the Sierra Club. But Burch made no apology for it, and this book makes it clear that the range and depth of his youthful experience made him a better and wiser man.

    There is not a word about organized sports in this volume, but Burch was a world-class sportsman in a different sense. He dove on shipwrecks in dangerous waters, rode horses on mountain trails above the timber line, and fly-fished for his dinner on solitary hikes in Switzerland. Our local society set grins from the covers of glamour magazines in their tuxedos and black dresses. Burch peers out from the cover of Lucius beneath a slouch hat and wearing an old coat.

    In interviews with newspaper reporters, he often said that Memphis had fallen behind Atlanta and Nashville largely because of a failure of leadership, by which he meant not only politicians but leading citizens such as Nashville’s “big mules.” He was as fallible as anyone, of course. In “Why I Am a Liberal,” he defended busing for school desegregation. Integrated schools, he believed, were essential if blacks and whites were to understand each other. “Few people now argue with the correctness of this concept,” he said in 1970. Four years later 34,000 white Memphians begged to differ.

    What a complicated, fascinating, vigorous man, and how lucky Memphis was to have him for so many years.