Last year, Flyer film writers Chris Herrington and Greg Akers had a back-and-forth exchange leading up to the Academy Awards broadcast. This not only let us geek-out on a cultural event we both tend to obsess over, but also gave us one last chance to sing the praises of some lesser-known films the Oscars may have overlooked.
- We predicit Quention Tarantino will leave the red carpet happy, with a Best Original Screenplay Oscar.
This year, we’re back at it, and will divide our conversation into five parts, one each morning this week, leading up to Sunday’s Oscar broadcast. We start today with the screenplay categories.
Best Original Screenplay
Nominees: The Hurt Locker, Inglourious Basterds, The Messenger, A Serious Man, Up
CHRIS HERRINGTON: The Messenger seems to be the only selection here incapable of actually winning. Of the rest, my guess is that The Hurt Locker is — correctly — perceived as more of a director’s movie and the Coens’ star-free, low-box-office A Serious Man simply too obscure. So I’m betting that this comes down to Up and Inglourious Basterds. Given all those long, talky scenes, the inventiveness of re-writing WWII, and the film’s success both at the box-office and with Oscar noms, I think this is where Quentin Tarantino gets recognized. Will Win — Inglourious Basterds.
Should Win — I actually like all of these movies, but do think Inglourious Basterds was too disjointed, The Messenger perhaps a little too schematic, and wish Up hadn’t devolved into standard-issue cartoon action down the stretch. I think The Hurt Locker is the best movie of the bunch, but I think the best screenplay here comes from my old nemeses, Joel and Ethan Coen. A Serious Man might be the first Coen movie more concerned with real life than with some kind of cinematic or literary source material, and I found it to be a very serious, very personal, fascinatingly prickly, and darkly comic look at religious belief and culture (which just happens to be Jewish because they are) from the perspective of an alienated insider.