Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

KUSTOFF, NORRIS, TAYLOR IN 7TH RACE; LANGSDON OUT

Three out of four of Shelby County’s major Republican hopefuls in the 7th District congressional race now have their hats in the ring — lawyer David Kustoff, businessman/city councilman Brent Taylor, and lawyer/legislator Mark Norris.

On the very eve of Thursday’s filing deadline, one other prospect, plastic surgeon Phil Langsdon, the former chairman of the Shelby County Republican Party, decided Wednesday — albeit reluctantly — not to add his hat to the max.

Taylor, who conducted a two-day bus tour of the district last week, had been the first to announce. He was followed by the others in rapid succession. Kustoff’s announcement said in part: “President Bush needs a congressman from the seventh district he can

count on to support his efforts to fight terrorism, reduce the tax burden on

working families, create jobs and improve the quality of public education.”

As the Memphis lawyer’s release noted, Kustoff headed up the 2000 Bush campaign in Tennessee and is largely credited for the current president’s victory here — one which propelled him into office.

Norris’ announcement said in part: “I believe my experience in state and local government, as a community volunteer, and the fact that my family and I actively farm in Shelby County, equips me to represent the people of the 7th District well. Congressman [Ed] Bryant‘s successor must be able to represent our President and the people of Tennessee in a meaningful way. It would be my honor to do so.”

Norris, a former Shelby County Commissioner, has been a member of the state Senate from outer Shelby County (and portions of Lauderdale, Tipton, and Fayette counties) since his election in 2000.

Langson, who chaired the local party during its years of greatest dominance in the late 90s, said in part: “After a careful review of my support, fundraising commitments, and recent

poll results it appears that I am well positioned to win the 7th District US

House of Representative seat. However, because of my young family, my wife and I don1t believe this is the

time for me to leave home to serve in elective office.”

Each of the Shelby Countians must reckon with candidates from elsewhere in the newly configured 7th district, notably state Sen. Marsha Blackburn of Williamson County in Nashville’s environs.

At least one Shelby County Democrat, Drew Pritt, has said he will file to run for the seat which incumbent Bryant is vacating to run for the U.S. Senate. Pritt has worked in several local campaigns and recently was part of a winning effort in a lieutenant governor’s race in Illinois.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

FIELDS TO TAKE ON JOHN FORD

“It’ll be the most interesting political race of the season,” says lawyer Richard Fields, and he may have something there. There are some bigtime races going on both locally and statewide, but the principals are, for the most part, conventional sorts.

There’s nothing conventional, though, about Fields, a prominent civil rights attorney for several decades, and there’s certainly nothing conventional about his chosen quarry in this year’s Democratic primary, State Senator John Ford.

Fields has other reasons for challenging the powerful state senator in District 29 than to generate interest, of course. He regards Ford as “an embarrassment to Memphis and the state of Tennessee.”

Says Fields, “The thing that really did it was his vote on the Senate Finance committee against the tobacco tax a couple of weeks ago. That killed a bill that would have raised $160 million, strictly for education. How could you vote for tobacco and against education?”

Fields cites also Ford’s controversial role as a Day Care proprietor and as a figure in the industry scandals that brought about corrective legislation (legislation that faces various ex post facto perils and obstructions even now). “He was just horrendous, he was right in the middle of it [the scandal], and in my estimation was the cause of it,” Fields says.

There are other issues Fields intends to raise against Ford, including the way in which he believes the senator pulled strings and twisted arms to get himself appointed to the Public Building Authority, but one case he’ll make has to do with the simple fact of residence.

“He doesn’t live n the district, and he doesn’t know what’s going on in his district,” Fields says. “As far as we know, he lives in Collierville.” Fields himself lives downtown, “square in the middle of the 29th District.” And he thinks his familiarity with the district’s concerns, as well as his record of civil rights litigation, will stand him in good stead with the district’s majority-black population.

The California native, whose treasurer is Sidney Chism, won’t be the only opponent for Ford, who, like Fields, filed with the Election Commission on Wednesday (thereby gainsaying some recent musing out loud about retiring from the Senate). Another filee is– Prince Mongo, the barefoot restaurateur who is generally regarded these days as an idea whose time has come and long gone.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

FIELDS TO TAKE ON JOHN FORD

Fields

Ford

“It’ll be the most interesting political race of the season,” says lawyer Richard Fields, and he may have something there. There are some bigtime races going on both locally and statewide, but the principals are, for the most part, conventional sorts.

There’s nothing conventional, though, about Fields, a prominent civil rights attorney for several decades, and there’s certainly nothing conventional about his chosen quarry this year, State Senator John Ford.

Fields has other reasons for challenging the powerful state senator in District 29 than to generate interest, of course. He regards Ford as “an embarrassment to Memphis and the state of Tennessee.”

Says Fields, “The thing that really did it was his vote on the Senate Finance committee against the tobacco tax a couple of weeks ago. That killed a bill that would have raised $160 million, strictly for education. How could you vote for tobacco and against education?”

Fields cites also Ford’s controversial role as a Day Care proprietor and as a figure in the industry scandals that brought about corrective legislation (legislation that faces various ex post facto perils and obstructions even now). “He was just horrendous, he was right in the middle of it [the scandal], and in my estimation was the cause of it,” Fields says.

There are other issues Fields intends to raise against Ford, including the way in which he believes the senator pulled strings and twisted arms to get himself appointed to the Public Building Authority, but one case he’ll make has to do with the simple fact of residence.

“He doesn’t live n the district, and he doesn’t know what’s going on in his district,” Fields says. “As far as we know, he lives in Collierville.” Fields himself lives downtown, “square in the middle of the 29th District.” And he thinks his familiarity with the district’s concerns, as well as his record of civil rights litigation, will stand him in good stead with the district’s majority-black population.

The California native won’t be the only opponent for Ford, who, like Fields, filed with the Election Commission on Wednesday (thereby gainsaying some recent musing out loud about retiring from the Senate). Another filee is– Prince Mongo, the barefoot restaurateur who is generally regarded these days as an idea whose time has come and long gone.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

KUSTOFF, NORRIS, TAYLOR IN 7TH RACE; LANGSDON OUT

Three out of four of Shelby County’s major Republican hopefuls in the 7th District congressional race now have their hats in the ring — lawyer David Kustoff, businessman/city counciman Brent Taylor, and lawyer/legislator Mark Norris.

On the very eve of Thursday’s filing deadline, one other prospect, plastic surgeon Phil Langsdon, the former chairman of the Shelby County Republican Party, decided Wednesday — albeit reluctantly — not to add his hat to the max.

Taylor, who conducted a two-day bus tour of the district last week, had been the first to announce. He was followed by the others in rapid succession. Kustoff’s announcement said in part: “President Bush needs a congressman from the seventh district he can

count on to support his efforts to fight terrorism, reduce the tax burden on

working families, create jobs and improve the quality of public education.”

As the Memphis lawyer’s release noted, Kustoff headed up the 2000 Bush campaign in Tennessee and is largely credited for the current president’s victory here — one which propelled him into office.

Norris’ announcement said in part: “I believe my experience in state and local government, as a community volunteer, and the fact that my family and I actively farm in Shelby County, equips me to represent the people of the 7th District well. Congressman [Ed] Bryant‘s successor must be able to represent our President and the people of Tennessee in a meaningful way. It would be my honor to do so.”

Norris, a former Shelby County Commissioner, has been a member of the state Senate from outer Shelby County (and portions of Lauderdale, Tipton, and Fayette counties) since his election in 2000.

Langson, who chaired the local party during its years of greatest dominance in the late 90s, said in part: “After a careful review of my support, fundraising commitments, and recent

poll results it appears that I am well positioned to win the 7th District US

House of Representative seat. However, because of my young family, my wife and I don1t believe this is the

time for me to leave home to serve in elective office.”

Each of the Shelby Countians must reckon with candidates from elsewhere in the newly configured 7th district, notably state Sen. Marsha Blackburn of Williamson County in Nashville’s environs.

At least one Shelby County Democrat, Drew Pritt, has said he will file to run for the seat which incumbent Bryant is vacating to run for the U.S. Senate. Pritt has worked in several local campaigns and recently was part of a winning effort in a lieutenant governor’s race in Illinois.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

SURGING BRYANT ENDS STATEWIDE TOUR IN SHELBY

If Ed Bryant believes he is an underdog to Lamar Alexander in the current Republican primary for the U.S. Senate, he did not betray that sense of things to the crowd of several score that welcomed him at Shelby Farms Monday afternoon for the last stop of his statewide announcement tour.

Neither did the crowd, a keyed-up group of local GOP celebrities and other backers who seemed to share the 7th District congressman’s sense that “something was going on” in Tennessee Ð that “something” being a grass-roots rebellion against Alexander or, more precisely, against the Republican establishment figures that have been backing the former Tennessee governor and twice failed presidential candidate as a successor to outgoing GOP Senator Fred Thompson.

“It’s happening from the bottom up,” declared Bryant. “This isn’t going to be a

from-the-top-down election.” Alexander was the candidate of some people in Washington and some people in Nashville, said Bryant, who added that on a tour of East Tennessee, a supposed Alexander stronghold, “I didn’t see any support for Lamar. I had been thinking that maybe we could hold our own up there. Now I think we can carry it.”

Bryant said he had commitments of support from 30 of the 42 Republican members of the state House of Representatives and nine of the 15 members of his party in the state Senate. And most of the others were uncommitted rather than leaning to Alexander, he said.

The congressman was unsparing in his criticism of his Republican opponent who, he said, had not won an election in 20 years, had “a national reputation of not being conservative,” and who was “indecisive.” Implicitly comparing the moderate Alexander to former vice President Al Gore. Bryant said “this state did not vote for such a person as president” in 2000. By his own prior admission, Alexander was “not suited” for legislative service and was on the wrong side of several contemporary issues, Bryant alleged..

In 1985, while governor, Alexander “advocated a state income tax,” Bryant said, reminding the crowd that “Don Sundquist has endorsed him” (but not reminding them that current Governor Sundquist, whose support for income-tax legislation has soured his name with may Tennessee Republicans, had plucked Bryant himself out of relative obscurity by recommending him to the first President Bush for District Attorney General in 1993).

“Now he says he ‘didn’t mean it,’” said Bryant scornfully of Alexander’s recent attempts to distance himself from that early flirtation with a state income tax. The congressman also reminded the crowd that, while running for president in 1999, Alexander had dismissed then opponent George W. Bush‘s phrase “compassionate conservatism” as so much “weasel words.”

Describing himself as a known conservative, Bryant said Alexander was currently engaged in an effort to remake himself ideologically, “to jump on my back, but I’m trying to toss him off, trying to get away from him.” It was “time for a change,” Bryant said, time “to permit the old Political Guard to gracefully retire.”

As a local show of strength, Bryant’s climactic announcement-tour appearance in Shelby County was convincing. Though outgoing Shelby County Mayor Jim Rout, District Attorney General Bill Gibbons, and several other local GOP officials have endorsed former Governor Alexander, the turnout of Bryant supporters Monday was impressive. Shelby County Commissioner Morris Fair introduced him, and numerous other local officials (e.g., County Trustee Bob Patterson, Probate Court Clerk Chris Thomas, Register Tom Leatherwood) and candidates for office were on hand.

Republican candidate for Shelby County mayor George Flinn was moved to recall that he and Bryant had been members of the same social fraternity (Sigma Nu) at Ole Miss –as had GOP Senate leader Trent Lott, who has expressed reservations about President Bush’s reported preference for Alexander. Flinn’s Republican opponent in the mayor’s race, State Representaive Larry Scroggs, was even more firmly attached to Bryant; his son Kenny Scroggs is the congressman’s Memphis-area field representative.

And the statewide grass-roots sentiment of which Bryant spoke was visible enough that several national reporters and columnists thought to point out over the weekend or on Monday that Alexander might be in for a serious battle in Tennessee.

In the last several weeks a series of increasingly blunt signals have come out of Washington to the effect that Alexander’s candidacy, just as Lott had indicated, enjoyed the backing of the White House and the National Republican Senatorial Committee, headed by Tennessee Sen. Bill Frist.

While acknowledging Monday that “some elements” of the NRSC were pushing hard for Alexander, Bryant said Frist himself had not expressed a preference. As for speculation that, between now and Thursday’s filing deadline for statewide candidates, President Bush might make a point of stating a preference for Alexander, perhaps even in Tennessee, Bryant said, “That’s not going to happen.”

And the congressman’s campaign manager, Justin Hunter, was blunt on the subject. “Even if the president should do that, Ed Bryant is going to continue to be a candidate.”

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

SURGING BRYANT ENDS STATEWIDE TOUR IN SHELBY

If Ed Bryant believes he is an underdog to Lamar Alexander in the current Republican primary for the U.S. Senate, he did not betray that sense of things to the crowd of several score that welcomed him at Shelby Farms Monday afternoon for the last stop of his statewide announcement tour.

Neither did the crowd, a keyed-up group of local GOP celebrities and other backers who seemed to share the 7th District congressman’s sense that “something was going on” in Tennessee Ð that “something” being a grass-roots rebellion against Alexander or, more precisely, against the Republican establishment figures that have been backing the former Tennessee governor and twice failed presidential candidate as a successor to outgoing GOP Senator Fred Thompson.

“It’s happening from the bottom up,” declared Bryant. “This isn’t going to be a

from-the-top-down election.” Alexander was the candidate of some people in Washington and some people in Nashville, said Bryant, who added that on a tour of East Tennessee, a supposed Alexander stronghold, “I didn’t see any support for Lamar. I had been thinking that maybe we could hold our own up there. Now I think we can carry it.”

Bryant said he had commitments of support from 30 of the 42 Republican members of the state House of Representatives and nine of the 15 members of his party in the state Senate. And most of the others were uncommitted rather than leaning to Alexander, he said.

The congressman was unsparing in his criticism of his Republican opponent who, he said, had not won an election in 20 years, had “a national reputation of not being conservative,” and who was “indecisive.” Implicitly comparing the moderate Alexander to former vice President Al Gore. Bryant said “this state did not vote for such a person as president” in 2000. By his own prior admission, Alexander was “not suited” for legislative service and was on the wrong side of several contemporary issues, Bryant alleged..

In 1985, while governor, Alexander “advocated a state income tax,” Bryant said, reminding the crowd that “Don Sundquist has endorsed him” (but not reminding them that current Governor Sundquist, whose support for income-tax legislation has soured his name with may Tennessee Republicans, had plucked Bryant himself out of relative obscurity by recommending him to the first President Bush for District Attorney General in 1993).

“Now he says he ‘didn’t mean it,’” said Bryant scornfully of Alexander’s recent attempts to distance himself from that early flirtation with a state income tax. The congressman also reminded the crowd that, while running for president in 1999, Alexander had dismissed then opponent George W. Bush‘s phrase “compassionate conservatism” as so much “weasel words.”

Describing himself as a known conservative, Bryant said Alexander was currently engaged in an effort to remake himself ideologically, “to jump on my back, but I’m trying to toss him off, trying to get away from him.” It was “time for a change,” Bryant said, time “to permit the old Political Guard to gracefully retire.”

As a local show of strength, Bryant’s climactic announcement-tour appearance in Shelby County was convincing. Though outgoing Shelby County Mayor Jim Rout, District Attorney General Bill Gibbons, and several other local GOP officials have endorsed former Governor Alexander, the turnout of Bryant supporters Monday was impressive. Shelby County Commissioner Morris Fair introduced him, and numerous other local officials (e.g., County Trustee Bob Patterson, Probate Court Clerk Chris Thomas, Register Tom Leatherwood) and candidates for office were on hand.

Republican candidate for Shelby County mayor George Flinn was moved to recall that he and Bryant had been members of the same social fraternity (Sigma Nu) at Ole Miss –as had GOP Senate leader Trent Lott, who has expressed reservations about President Bush’s reported preference for Alexander. Flinn’s Republican opponent in the mayor’s race, State Representaive Larry Scroggs, was even more firmly attached to Bryant; his son Kenny Scroggs is the congressman’s Memphis-area field representative.

And the statewide grass-roots sentiment of which Bryant spoke was visible enough that several national reporters and columnists thought to point out over the weekend or on Monday that Alexander might be in for a serious battle in Tennessee.

In the last several weeks a series of increasingly blunt signals have come out of Washington to the effect that Alexander’s candidacy, just as Lott had indicated, enjoyed the backing of the White House and the National Republican Senatorial Committee, headed by Tennessee Sen. Bill Frist.

While acknowledging Monday that “some elements” of the NRSC were pushing hard for Alexander, Bryant said Frist himself had not expressed a preference. As for speculation that, between now and Thursday’s filing deadline for statewide candidates, President Bush might make a point of stating a preference for Alexander, perhaps even in Tennessee, Bryant said, “That’s not going to happen.”

And the congressman’s campaign manager, Justin Hunter, was blunt on the subject. “Even if the president should do that, Ed Bryant is going to continue to be a candidate.”

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

COSTAS TOUTS MEMPHIS’ FORTUNE

TV sportscaster Bob Costas, doing a promo on AOL for his HBO program “On the Record,” took note this week of big sports news being made in (and on behalf of) the Bluff City. After beginning with a reference to the passing of television legend Milton Berle, Costas sequed into this: “Meanwhile, what a week it’s been for Memphis, Tennessee.On Monday, the city of Graceland gets named as host of the upcoming heavyweight showdown between Mike Tyson and Lennox Lewis. Then, that same night, the city’s new NBA team, the Grizzlies, with Rookie-of-the-Year candidate Pau Gasol, goes into Portland and rallies from 25 down to knock off the red-hot Trailblazers. Also, led by freshman phenom DajuanWagner, the Memphis Tigers reached the final of the NIT here at Madison Square Garden. In New York. So, whether Elvis is alive or not, Memphis still has Mike, Lennox, Pau, and Dajuan…”

And that, of course, was before the U of M Tigers beat South Carolina for the NIT basketball title.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

Getting Noticed

With all the attention being given to people named Ford of late — most notably, U.S. Rep. Harold Ford Jr., who considered a race for the U.S. Senate; his father Harold Ford Sr., whose lucrative contracts pertaining to the state’s TennCare program received extensive publicity; and Uncle John Ford, who floated a trial balloon for a congressional race in case his nephew made the Senate run — other Fords have been left out.

To wit: Sir Isaac Ford, the congressman’s youngest sibling, and Ophelia Ford, his aunt. Both are candidates in the forthcoming countywide elections, and neither has received extensive publicity for their political views. Ophelia Ford — who is opposing her brother Joe Ford for the county commission seat he was recently appointed to by other commission members (and which was formerly held by the late Dr. James Ford, a sibling) has, however, been given in-depth treatment, both in the Flyer and in The Commercial Appeal, for her determination to break into the male-dominated inner sanctum of the political Ford family.

And several prominent local women will hold a reception for Ophelia Ford at the home of lawyer Jocelyn Wurzburg at 4744 Normandy this Thursday night.

No such treatment has yet been received by the 28-year-old Sir Isaac, who remains on the August general election ballot as an independent candidate for Shelby County mayor and whose candidacy, insofar as it has been thought of at all, has been dismissed as enigmatic or inconsequential.

The prevailing theory seems to be that young Ford was a family plant as a hedge against the possibility that Bartlett banker Harold Byrd, since withdrawn, might win the Democratic primary. (Byrd and the Fords have had their problems.) According to that theory, Isaac Ford’s candidacy now is little more than a reminder to favored Democratic mayoral candidate AC Wharton that the family is still around and needs to be paid some heed.

Yet another theory is that the Isaac Ford candidacy is little more than a lark — or at best an attempt by the candidate and brother Jake Ford, his presumptive campaign manager, to reach parity with other members of the family.

Through all this, Isaac Ford has maintained that his candidacy is serious and that he will end up being elected mayor. Concerning the fact that there have been few if any visible signs of that prospect, or even of his being in the race, Ford shrugs. “In politics, you don’t want to peak too early.” Eventually, he says, “someone as talented and young and charming as myself” will attract the right kind of notice.

Sir Isaac (that is his given name, and he signs himself that way, though the “Sir” is most often dropped among family and friends) hopes to begin getting the appropriate attention with the release of several “position papers,” some of which he made over to the Flyer.

One of the papers is a broadside against the prospective victory of Wharton in the Democratic primary. “[I]f the democratic [sic] nominee is not either C.C. Buchanan, C.J. Cochran, or State Rep. Carol Chumney [all primary opponents of Wharton], then the democratic party will not have a viable, credible candidate with liberal views. They will have a democratic puppet controlled by republicans’ [sic] money, and their conservative ways.”

Ford’s own candidacy “stands on more of a socialistic-capitalistic platform, and will encourage quality county development in the inner city and suburbs.”

One plank in that platform is a more or less straightforward espousal of city/county consolidation with single-source funding for city and county schools.

Another plank would seem timely in view of the recently accomplished location of the Lewis/Tyson heavyweight championship bout at The Pyramid, with training camps to be located in Tunica. It envisions the conversion of South Third Street into Tennessee’s component of a Memphis-to-Mississippi thoroughfare connecting downtown with the casino complexes of Tunica.

“My administration will propose to enhance an economic alliance agreement to benefit both areas,” Ford’s position paper says.

Another paper addresses the subject of the Shelby County Election Commission, toward whose conduct of the forthcoming elections Ford expresses a suspicion that “the fix is already in.” Among other things, he maintains: “Reliable sources have alerted me” to the commission’s potential for “foul play with early voting results, and election day results, also tampering with voter registration forms, and utilizing resources to encourage voters in county districts two, and three not to vote.” He proposes a federal “watchdog committee” to keep this from happening.

Along with his position papers, Ford included a release announcing a press conference “to define, and describe the infrastructure in candidate Ford’s mayoral campaign.” The time is specific enough, “12 noon,” but the date and venue of the press conference are handled by the initials “T.B.A.” — to be announced.

* Another candidate who would prefer to have greater attention paid his efforts than he has so far received is Dr. George Flinn, who is vying with state Representative Larry Scroggs of Germantown for the Republican nomination for county mayor.

Flinn held a reception at Owen Brennan’s Restaurant on Poplar last week that attracted a larger-than-usual crowd at the facility, whose multiroom reception area tends to magnify even small groups into apparent throngs. Flinn’s crowd needed no such magnification, though its numbers were provided mainly by faces unfamiliar in political rallies than by the usual rank and file who attend such events.

“That’s good. That’s what we’re going to surprise people with on May 7th,” said Flinn, who concedes that Scroggs seems to have a lock on most Republican Party regulars. The physician/businessman, who operates a number of radio stations, says he will kick off his media campaign with several radio and TV spots on the first of April.

Scroggs, meanwhile, kept up a round of appearances on time off from his legislative duties in Nashville, appearing at a forum on consolidation in Collierville last week to elucidate his views.

* It was a good show, hastily advertised, and lacking therefore in some of the audience that should have been its due. But the 2002 version of Memphis’ Gridiron Show at the Al Chymia Shrine Temple on Shelby Oaks — which began and ended with well-produced tributes to post-September 11th New York — did what some of its more elongated and self-indulgent predecessors failed to do:

This year’s version — titled “Smokey and the Bandits” — consistently entertained. Less was more, both gagwise and songwise. The same might be said for a list of celebrity attendees that was short here and there — no Willie Herenton, no Jim Rout, few members of the state legislature or of the city council or of the county commission — but rich in public figures who happen right now to be cynosures.

Notably, there were Democratic U.S. Senate nominee-designate Bob Clement, the congressman from Nashville; once and future Senate hopeful Harold Ford Jr., the congressman from Memphis; and soon-to-be-emeritus Governor Don Sundquist.

Sundquist, who was notably absent from this month’s Lincoln Day Dinner of the Shelby County Republican Party (which he co-founded some decades back), opined that some sort of budget solution might be in the offing in the General Assembly “as soon as the filing deadline” (April 4th for legislative positions) is over with. He did not demur at someone’s suggestion that, wherever Tennessee might stand among the states on the scales of income, health care, and education, it had earned the right to be considered Number 50 — dead last — where state legislatures are concerned.

The governor nodded. “And the good ones are leaving,” he said, noting the continuing exodus of experienced and conscientious lawmakers — most recently House Finance Committee chairman Matt Kisber of Jackson.

Also present at the Gridiron Show, the proceeds of which go to fund scholarships at area universities, were three candidates for Shelby County mayor — Democrats Chumney and Wharton and Republican Flinn. ( There was much discussion in the Wharton camp — both by the candidates and by an aide or two as to whether state Rep. Chumney might have got the better of him in some often sharp exchanges at Whitehaven High School Saturday, during the second of two forums (of a scheduled four) sponsored by the county Democratic Party this election year for its primary candidates.

“One person said I won … and another said she did,” Wharton said. He inclined to the former view himself, but it was apparent that he was reflecting both on the strategy of returning the often aggressive Chumney’s fire during debates and on the wisdom of participating in such forums with her at all. (He would likely continue doing both, he acknowledged.)

* Chumney’s campaign got some attention recently that she would just as soon have not received. It came in the form of an e-mail sent to members of her personal network by Paula F. Casey, current president of the Downtown Neighborhood Association and a longtime activist for women’s issues.

In part, the e-mail reads, “As a cofounder of the Women’s Political Caucus in 1983, I want to see a woman in an executive position in this county someday. However, Carol Chumney is NOT the woman,” and goes on to argue, among other things, that Chumney adopted opportunistic positions in the legislature and, as one example, had “aligned herself with the right-wing fundamentalists” to oppose right-to-know legislation on behalf of adopted persons seeking information about their parents. (Chumney favored certain restrictions on the discharge of such information.)

Once close friends and allies, Chumney and Casey have been distant since their highly public disagreement in 1994 over the form and function of the state Women’s Suffragist Commission, which Casey had initially proposed but which, Casey believed, Chumney attempted to gain control of during legislative establishment of the commission’s machinery.

Ultimately, the commission was jointly headed by Casey and state Sen. Thelma Harper of Nashville but not before Casey felt her reputation had been unfairly maligned.

* The campaign manager for lawyer Guthrie Castle, a Democratic primary candidate for the District 5 County Commission seat, charged the Shelby County Election Commission Tuesday with abdication of its legal and moral responsibility in declining to rule on the validity of Castle’s complaints regarding opponent Joe Cooper’s financial disclosures.

“It’s sad that fear of not being elected or appointed comes before the moral authority of this commission,” Jeff Sullivan told members moments after his effort to invalidate Cooper’s candidacy was ruled beyond the purview of the commission.

Castle’s complaint, formally presented by Sullivan, charged that Cooper’s most recent financial disclosures evidenced illegally large contributions from individuals and other entities, defiance of disclosure obligations in the case of outstanding debts, inaccurate information, and a variety of other “illegal contributions and illegal loans.”

Under advice from its attorney, Philip Kaminsky, the commission ruled that it was now empowered to act on the complaint, which should, Kaminsky said, be taken directly either to the office of the state Election Registry in Nashville, to the office of the district attorney general, or to that of the state attorney general..

A little strong,” was Styles’ reaction to Sullivan’s criticism. Whether directly prompted by the incident or not, Kaminsky entertained a small group after the meeting with a story that went this way: One man brought another into a Texas courtroom and demanded that the accused be punished for stealing two chickens. “Hang him!” said the judge, who was told by a shocked bailiff, “Your honor! You can’t do that.” Kaminsky hastened to the punch line: “I can’t?” said the judge. “Well, I’ll let him go then. I can do that.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

After the Earthquake

The turmoil unloosed by U.S. Senator Fred Thompson‘s surprise withdrawal from his reelection race two weeks ago created expectations within Democratic ranks that have since subsided — with both U.S. Rep. Harold Ford Jr. of Memphis and (wonder of weekend wonders!) Tipper Gore having ultimately deferred to Nashville congressman Bob Clement, who announced his Senate candidacy this week in Nashville in a ceremony of party unification.

The claiming of first dibs by Clement, who was most senior among available Democrats, was an ironic echo of the orderly way in which Republicans ordinarily arrange a political succession. The GOP, meanwhile, saw itself in the kind of predicament normally incurred by Democrats — with a primary contest between former Governor Lamar Alexander and 7th District U.S. Rep. Ed Bryant threatening to involve state Republicans in an internecine struggle with moderate-vs.-conservative and insurgent-vs.-Establishment overtones.

At the Shelby County Republican Party’s annual Lincoln Day Dinner in Memphis last weekend, Bryant contended that Alexander’s forces were trying to dry up his fund-raising ability but insisted that he and his conservative supporters would fight on and win against the former governor, who had on his side favorable polls and enough money to begin TV advertisements. “There’s something happening in Tennessee,” said Bryant, who evoked the image of grass-roots rebellions in East Tennessee and West Tennessee.

Republican gubernatorial candidate Van Hilleary, the 4th District congressman who is still favored over persistent primary challenger Jim Henry, confided his anxiety that the new attention given the Senate race might retard his own fund-raising vis-à-vis his ultimate potential opponent, Democrat Phil Bredesen.

Hilleary, who had not yet reciprocated an endorsement he had received several weeks ago from congressional colleague Bryant, did so in a de facto manner. After suggesting in an interview that Henry’s financial support, such as it was, came from sources close to Alexander and Governor Don Sundquist, with whom he disagrees on most matters, Hilleary would introduce Bryant to the Republican throng as one who “will be a great U.S. senator.”

Absent from the Shelby County banquet were both Sundquist, who had co-founded the local affair three decades back, and Alexander, who had visited Memphis earlier in the week, collecting endorsements from outgoing Shelby County mayor Jim Rout and others.

Correction and Clarification Ex Parte: State Senator Steve Cohen insists he never “draped his arm” around mayoral dropout Harold Byrd during a multistage encounter between the two that took place at the annual awards banquet of the University of Memphis Alumni Association. The actual chronology of the matter, which was reported here last week as a composite of others’ tellings, is as follows, reports the senator (who had earlier declined extended comment):

1) Cohen — an outspoken supporter of another Democratic candidate, Shelby County public defender A C Wharton — approaches Byrd and tells him he has done “the right thing” by withdrawing from an unwinnable county mayor’s race, which at some point the senator compares to his own 1996 experience in a 9th District congressional race against ultimate winner Harold Ford Jr.;

2) Byrd responds by not turning around to greet Cohen, saying tersely, “You better leave.”

3) Cohen withdraws but either seeks out or encounters Jo Tucker, Byrd’s sister, whom the senator advises that Byrd has been “rude” to him, and, after declaring that the Bartlett banker isn’t handling his disappointment well, suggests he’d be better off avoiding public functions and taking some time off;

4) Shortly thereafter Byrd approaches Cohen, grasps his arm, advises him not to talk to members of his (Byrd’s) family, and threatens to “whip [Cohen’s] ass.” The senator’s response, as he recalls it: “If you don’t get your hands off me, I’ll punch you in the nose.”

Clearly, neither threat was realized, so things blew over.

· Byrd’s point of view, it should be said, remains unspoken to. The erstwhile candidate remains involved in civic and business matters but is otherwise keeping a low profile and has not been available for comment.

He impressed members of the Phoenix Club, however, when, instead of canceling, he showed up for a prescheduled luncheon talk last week and, members say, discussed the circumstances of the Shelby County mayor’s race with candor, precision, and good cheer.

The bottom line: He withdrew because his head told him he couldn’t win, and his heart, reluctantly but ultimately, followed.

· Some other antagonists of Sen. Cohen, ideological ones, were in town last week: members of the Gambling Free Tennessee Alliance, a lobby formed to fight the upcoming Cohen-sponsored lottery referendum.

The two principal speakers at a press conference at the airport were former ambassador to France Joe Rodgers, who raises significant amounts of money for Republican causes, and former legislator Tommy Burnette, who was described by Alliance spokesperson Michael Gilstrap as being “a liberal by any definition.”

In addition to moral arguments, Rodgers and Burnette attacked the assumptions of the lottery from their presumed ideological positions. Among other criticisms, Rodgers said the scholarships promised under Cohen’s lottery proposal would require more matching funds from state coffers than could reasonably be afforded under the present difficult fiscal conditions.

Both men conceded that current polls show statewide sentiment to be overwhelmingly in favor of a lottery but — citing the case of a recently defeated referendum in Albama, where early polls had predicted a win for lottery proponents — predicted that would change.

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

CASTLE REP HURLS CHARGE AT ELECTION COMMISSION

The campaign manager for lawyer Guthrie Castle, a Democratic primary candidate for the District 5 County Commission seat, charged the Shelby County Election Commission Tuesday with abdication of its legal and moral responsibility in declining to rule on the validity of Castle’s complaints regarding opponent Joe Cooper‘s financial disclosures.

“It’s sad that fear of not being elected or appointed comes before the moral authority of this commission,” Jeff Sullivan told members moments after his effort to invalidate Cooper’s candidacy was ruled beyond the purview of the commission.

At the time the vote was taken at the heel of the meeting, only three members were sill present, but one of those who left early, Republican member Rich Holden, had said that the Commission members were in agreement on all the matters then still pending — presumably including the Castle complaint, which had been belatedly added to the agenda by Chairman O.C. Pleasant.

Castle’s complaint, formally presented by Sullivan, charged that Cooper’s most recent financial disclosures evidenced illegally large contributions from individuals and other entities, defiance of disclosure obligations in the case of outstanding debts, inaccurate information, and a variety of other “illegal contributions and illegal loans.”

Therefore, said the complaint, Cooper should be declared ineligible to run, and “the illegalities and improprieties reflected in Mr. Cooper’s Campaign Disclosure Statements should be referred by this Commission to the District Attorney and the Tennessee Registry of Election Finance for investigation and appropriate action.”

Also presented by Sullivan was a statement from Tony Dailey, general manager of Clear Channel Outdoor, alleging that an unpaid debt from one of frequent candidate Cooper’s prior campaigns in the amount of $23,700 constituted “an involuntary, but illegal, contribution.”

Philip Kaminsky. the Commission’s attorney, advised members that Tennessee election law did not permit the county Election Commission, whose function was primarily “ministerial,” to act as requested in the case of the “Class 2” violations cited by the Castle complaint. He said the commission was empowered only to assess fines and other minor penalties for such “Class 1” violations as late filings of disclosures. He suggested that complaints like Castle’s should be taken directly either to the office of the state Election Registry in Nashville, to the office of the District Attorney General, or to that of the state Attorney General..

The three Commission members still on hand — Democrats Pleasant and Myra Styles and Republican Nancye Hines – then voted unanimously to support Kaminsky’s recommendation that no action be taken on the complaint. (Like Holden, Democratic member Greg Duckett had previously left — in his case to catch a flight at the airport.)

Whereupon Sullivan made his statement strongly implying the commission’s abdication of legal and moral responsibility — a charge he made explicit when asked about it in a separate later interview.

“A little strong,” was Styles’ reaction to the accusation. Whether directly prompted by the incident or not, Kaminsky entertained a small group after the meeting with a story that went this way: One man brought another into a Texas courtroom and demanded that the accused be punished for stealing two chickens. “’Hang him!’” said the judge, who was told by a shocked bailiff, “’Your honor! You can’t do that!’” Kaminsky hastened to the punchline: “’I can’t?’ said the judge. ‘Well, I’ll let him go then. I can do that!’”

A disappointed Sullivan indicated afterward the complaint would probably not be pressed through court channels.