The Memphis opinion machine cranked up Tuesday with some blaming Memphis in May’s record losses on the Tom Lee Park redesign and others calling the Beale Street Music Festival lineup “garbage,” “out of touch,” and “ass as fuck.”
News dropped late Tuesday (well, after Flyer working hours, anyway) of a 30-year-record-low crowd at Memphis in May (MIM) this year resulting in a record-low financial loss of $3.48 million.
In its annual report, MIM blamed much of this on the redesigned Tom Lee Park. The $63 million renovation was mostly complete by the time the festival geared back up for a return to the park this year.
That design was tailor-made for MIM, created under a mediation agreement ordered by Memphis Mayor Jim Strickland. That means MIM’s instructions drove many of the details of the redesign.
This still did not stop festival organizers from saying the “the return to Tom Lee Park was marred by difficulties including: obtaining a lease with the Memphis River Parks Partnership (MRPP), problems with access to the park, restrictive use of essential park features, designs not meeting agreed-upon specifications, and a park with 40 percent less useable space.”
Jerred Price, a candidate for Memphis City Council this year and moderator of a Facebook page called Save the River Parks & the Festivals, laid the blame on MRPP, and especially its CEO Carol Coletta.
“The Tom Lee Park excessive redesign is hurting our festivals which create hundreds of millions in tourism dollars, business for our local small businesses, and our economy,” Price said in a post Tuesday. “MRPP violated the terms of their mediation agreement terms.
“Something must be done. Memphis River Parks Partnership needs to be held accountable. Lose the festivals, lose hundreds of millions in economic impact.”
Among the post’s 10 comments, many urged a lawsuit against MRPP.
“Time to sue the shizzle out of MRPP and Coletta,” said Ann Bridgman. “Every vendor, every employee, and every single business that took a hit Downtown this year and for years to come.
Bridgman said she walks in the park nearly every day and is underwhelmed with the money spent on the new design. She said it had no water features and wondered where were the “lasers and dancing lights.”
But MIM shared the blame when it came to low attendance at Beale Street Music Festival. There, it also listed “astronomically elevated talent costs, plus ticket sales competition from big-name artists’ concerts in the Memphis area during late first and early second quarters of this year.”
Here, Memphis Reddit users stepped in with unfiltered opinions on a post by u/mothman26, which linked to a WMCTV story on the MIM news.
“Lineup was overall subpar,” wrote u/AcanthopterygiiNo603. “Headliners were weak.
“Also, I am a lifelong hip hop fan, but acts like Finesse2tymes clearly promoting violence should be passed over. The whole scene was uncomfortable and with the crime epidemic, promoters need to be more aware of who they are choosing.”
u/Sacrolargo agreed with MIM officials that other shows in other markets likely drew attendance from Music Fest. u/Sacrolargo said Shaky Knees Music Festival was in Atlanta that weekend. U/mothman26 pointed out that Taylor Swift also played Nashville that weekend.
Some, though, said MIM officials were “out of touch” when planning its music lineup and suggested getting outside help to plan its next year.
Others, however, were happy to offer unvarnished criticism.
“Lineup was garbage, not sure it needs to be any more complicated than that,” wrote u/Typical_Control_1175.
“The line up was ass as fuck,” wrote u/Black_n_Neon.
