Categories
News News Blog

Council Member Calls Colleagues’ Absence “Embarrassing”

At its third consecutive meeting this week, the Memphis City Council was unable to reach a quorum and the council members who have been present all week are growing impatient. 

After four council members supporting Rhonda Logan’s bid for the vacant District 1 seat walked out of Tuesday’s meeting, the remaining six members instated a standing daily meeting until there is a quorum so that the council could vote on December 4th agenda’s 56 items.

Of the six council members who did not walk out Tuesday, only Worth Morgan, J Ford Canale, Frank Colvett Jr., and Kemp Conrad were in attendance at the Thursday meeting. Council members Reid Hedgepeth and Berlin Boyd, as well as the four who walked out, Patrice Robinson, Jamita Swearegen, Joe Brown, and Martavious Jones were not present.

Colvett said the boycotting members’ absence and the inability for the council to vote on other business is “embarrassing.” The business of the city is “grinding to a halt over one vote,” meaning the city could miss out on grant funds for police body armor and sky-cops already paid for by neighborhoods aren’t being installed, Colvett said.

Colvett said the council members not present should put aside their thoughts and feelings

“It is my opinion that there has been every single effort possible that says we are willing to have a conversation,” Colvett said. “We want to have a conversation. We need to have a conversation.

“I would like to say to my colleagues that are not with us, put away your thoughts and feelings and come back so we can have a conversation.”

Canale said “quite frankly it makes me sick,” calling the situation “unfair” and “sad.”

“Here we go again,” Canale said. “It’s the third straight day of holding up city business. We’re all taking time away from our jobs to be here. I don’t know what other people in this room think, but what is this saying to the citizens about us?”

Canale said he is ready for discussion and a resolution, as the “people of Memphis deserve it.”

“We have elected officials that have chosen not to show and do their job because they didn’t get their way,” Canale said. “What does that say? It does not send a good lesson to our youth about sticking around when things get tough and working it out together.”

Colvett ensured the audience and his colleagues that the council will “figure this out somehow, someway.”

Meanwhile, the council is slated to meet again Friday at 4 p.m. in another attempt to reach a quorum of seven members, and the 10-member council still has three vacancies to fill at its last meeting of the year on Tuesday, December 18th.


Categories
Fly On The Wall Blog Opinion

Will The Commercial Appeal Face More Newsroom Layoffs?

Gannett: Newspapers lack resources to spellcheck their own names. Will likely cut more of these resources.

Will The Commercial Appeal face more newsroom layoffs? Probably. Can the diminished daily newspaper withstand more cuts? It’s hard to say. But before getting into any of that, I’d like to share a few of the things Maribel Wadsworth, president of USA Today Network, allegedly told Gannett employees during a company-wide conference call according to a report by The Nashville Scene. I’d then like to provide an easy to understand translation for folks who don’t work in the print media and therefore won’t be hip to the industry’s famously colorful jargon.

• “As we continue this transition … it’s important to understand … that it will require us to think about our overall cost structure in alignment with profitability.”

Translated: layoffs are coming.

• “Going forward, we will be a smaller company.”

Translated: Layoffs are coming.

• “It’s gonna feel rocky at times. It just is. We just have to be very clear-eyed about that.”

Translated: Layoffs are coming.

Tennessean staffers were also told:

• “There is no plan for a mass layoff before Christmas.”

Translation: HAPPY NEW YEAR, SUCKERS!

None of this is surprising. Gannett’s Q3 numbers weren’t good. Digital growth isn’t making up for losses in print and the company is looking to cut operating costs. In previous years, when the CA was a Scripps property, layoffs inevitably followed any efforts to recruit early retirees. It seems as though the trend will continue under Gannett. In November, a company-wide buyout offer targeted employees over 55 with more than 15-years experience. The deadline to take Gannett’s offer of 30-35-weeks pay, and a possible bonus of up to $5,520 is December 10th. 

Categories
Politics Politics Beat Blog

Another George H.W. Bush Memory

There have been so many stories from all sides of every aisle reflecting favorably on  the person of the late President George H.W. Bush. I’ll add one:

In 1991 or so, President Bush came to Memphis on some mission, governmental or political or mixed, and landed on FedEx turf, emerging to meet a large crowd of welcomers in a hangar. I managed to be in that crowd and got close to the rope line so as to get a good snapshot of him.

When Bush had got to a point more or less in front of me, I raised my camera, a 35-millimeter sort, to my eye and prepared to press the shutter. The President, observing me two or three ranks back. and imagining me no doubt to be there as a plain citizen, not a news person, interrupted the conversation he was having at the rope line and raised his arms, palms to either side, waving his arms outward in a gesture meant to tell the crowd to move aside, leaving me a good shot-line. Simultaneously, he offered one of the most pleasant smiles imaginable, not the mindless grip-and-grin sort public figures have in such ample stock but one of eye-twinkling complicity (or so it seemed to me).

Just as I pressed the shutter of the camera, the old film-roll sort, I heard the tell-tale sound of the camera’s motor, telling me that I had taken my last shot with that roll and the film was beginning its automatic rewind. President Bush must have heard that whir, too, or perhaps merely read and translated my stricken expression. In any case, he clearly knew what had happened, and his kindly look transformed into one of obvious compassion with my predicament, culminating, seconds later, with a wink and a “so-it-goes” shrug..

That striking display of empathy is what I took away from that day in the hangar, not a photograph but a moment that still remains in my memory as a mini-portrait of the man.

Categories
News News Blog

MATA’s ‘Ongoing Process’ of Upgrading Bus Stops Limited by Funds


Of the 4,200 Memphis Area Transit Authority (MATA) bus stops in the city, only about 300 — or a little over 7 percent — are equipped with both shelters and seating.

John Lancaster, MATA’s director of scheduling and planning, said the ridership and number of boards associated with stops is a major criteria in determining where new shelters should be built.

Lancaster said that 70 percent of the key bus stops where there are more than 25 boards a day have shelter and seating.

“We’re putting shelters where they are most needed,” Lancaster said. “There are very few places that actually merit a shelter.”

Other criteria that’s considered is the comfort level of the stop and if it is a significant transfer point.

[pullquote-3]

Basic bus stop upgrades are prioritized based on factors like number of boards, the demographics of the surrounding neighborhood, and proximity to a medical facility, civic building, or educational institution.

The agency uses a point system, in which different criteria are assigned a point value. For example, if a bus stop averages more than 50 boards on weekdays, then 40 points are awarded.

If a bus stop is a significant transfer point, it is awarded 10 points. The points from each category are then added together for a maximum total of 100 points. The stop’s assigned point value is taken into account when prioritizing improvements.

Lancaster said MATA is constantly taking inventory of stops, and eliminating and adding stops based on service changes and other factors.

Rider Woes

Justin Davis of the Memphis Bus Riders’ Union (MBRU) said his group talks about bus stops a lot.

“Many bus stops in town don’t have adequate seating or cover from the elements, and often shelters aren’t well-maintained,” Davis said. “Some neighborhoods have stops in places where there are no sidewalks, and that can be dangerous for folks who are waiting.”

[pullquote-2]

Davis also said that sometimes the ads placed on the sheltered stops is a hindrance to riders, citing instances where bus drivers passed by riders waiting to board because they couldn’t see the riders for the ad.

Sammie Hunter, co-chair of the MBRU and a regular bus rider, said MATA needs to overhaul its bus stops. Hunter routinely catches the 42 Crosstown, which is MATA’s second-most popular route, according to the agency’s officials. Though the route averages about 2,184 riders per weekday, Hunter said “if you look at the stops along the route, you won’t see very many shelters or places to sit.”

“People have to stand in the rain and cold,” Hunter said. “Sometimes we’re tired and still have to wait 20 or 30 minutes at a stop with no where to sit down after a long day of work. It can get uncomfortable from time to time.”

Money Matters

Echoing sentiments made by MATA officials in the past, Lancaster said funding is a major obstacle to making enhancements to the city’s bus stops.

“It’s an ongoing process,” Lancaster said. “The big thing for all of this is funding.”

A basic bus stop with a sign, paved boarding area, street lighting, pavement markings, and sidewalk connection costs between $3,000 to $10,000 without a shelter and costs between $10,000 and $20,000 with a shelter. If a real-time display monitor is added, the price goes up to between $15,000 and $30,000. MATA does not have the capital funds, he said.

“We would love to have them at all of our stops, but we just don’t have the money to do it,” Lancaster said. “You can get up to some really, really big numbers pretty quick.”

MATA

Types of bus stops and the associated costs

MATA’s ongoing bus stop improvements total $67.8 million. The agency is in the process of making those improvements now, but is “doing it a trickled pace because we just don’t have enough money, manpower, and resources,” Lancaster said.

MATA has to find more local funding sources to “grow the pot,” as local funding is the key to leveraging federal funds, Lancaster said.

That’s where the newly-formed Shelby County Ad Hoc Transit Committee comes in, Lancaster said.

Headed by Shelby County Commissioner Van Turner, the committee is comprised of representatives from the city, county, MATA, Innovate Memphis, and the MBRU. The goal of the group is to find dedicated funding sources for the agency.

The committee’s next meeting is scheduled for 3 p.m. on Tuesday, December 11th in the County Administration Building.

Categories
Food & Drink Hungry Memphis

Gary Williams’ Legacy

Sad news today. Gary Williams of DeJaVu has passed away.

Williams was a gentleman in the truest sense. He was kind and helpful. There was never an unreturned phone call. He was all positive vibes. When news came out that his restaurant DeJaVu on S. Main was closed, he said, “You know me, I’ll be back.” And he was. He reopened the restaurant in its original location on Florida earlier this year.

Williams has left a legacy of enthusiasm and good cooking, of being there when folks needed a little support. He will be missed.

In 2016, Williams wrote an essay for Memphis magazine about what it means to serve the community. A snippet is below, but the whole thing is worth reading.

I began my career like many chefs, learning from my mentors and developing the dream of one day owning my own restaurant. I didn’t have much growing up in New Orleans, but my life was abundant in love and support from my family and friends. I try to put a little of that magic in all that I do. Love and support goes a long way with people. It just so happens that I was blessed with the opportunity to own my own restaurants and catering services throughout the years. This career has allowed me to travel all over the country meeting athletes, celebrities, politicians, and travelers from all over the world. It also gave me the privilege to work with many young people side by side helping them grow into the wonderful people they have become or one day will be.

That is what this business is about: people, not just those who come in to enjoy the food and experience, but also the people that help make those magical moments happen. Many of us in this business spend more time at the restaurant than we do at home, so we’re a lot like family. There are so many different types of people in this business that I have had the pleasure of working with. You have college students, young professionals, career servers, and cooks, all bringing their personalities to this business. Everyone pulls together in the busy times with the sole focus of taking care of the guests that we are so blessed to have come into the restaurant. At the end of the day, we know we may have made a couple of mistakes but we did our best to make sure that our guests left happy.

 

Categories
News News Blog

Man Faces 20 Years on Credit, Debit Card Fraud

Ever wonder who steals your credit or debit card information from ATMs?

Well, in Memphis it might have been Cristian Balazs-Andras. When the undocumented Romanian was arrested in June, he had 68 fraudulent gift cards with him, according to U.S. Attorney D. Michael Dunavant.

Balazs-Andras, 24, was arrested at First Tennessee Bank in Germantown after he tried to use gift cards at the ATM there that he had re-encoded with stolen credit and debit card numbers. Surveillance video captured the man using electronic skimming devices and other machines to commit fraud at SunTrust Bank branches throughout the Memphis area.

Earlier this week, Balazs-Andras pleaded guilty to two-counts of access device fraud, according to Dunavant. The maximum penalty is 10 years in federal prison and a $250,000 fine for each charge. He is is scheduled to be sentenced in February.

“Access device fraud, skimming scams, and debit/credit card theft victimizes innocent citizens and compromises the security of banks,” Dunavant said in a statement. “Protecting the integrity of financial institutions and transactions is a top priority of this office, and this case demonstrates that such crimes of dishonesty for financial gain do not pay.”

The case was investigated by the United States Secret Service.

Categories
News News Blog

Man Pleads Guilty to Urinating on Kellogg’s Line

YouTube

The man who filmed himself urinating on a production line at Kellogg’s in 2014 pleaded guilty to tampering with consumer products Friday and now faces up to three years in prison and a $250,000 fine.

Gregory Stanton worked at Kellogg’s Memphis manufacturing facility in 2014, the year he filmed himself urinating on the line, according to a news release from U.S. Attorney D. Michael Dunavant. Stanton uploaded the video to the internet two years later.

In 2011, Stanton was indicted by a federal grand jury for tainting consumer products “with the intent to cause serious injury to the business of any person.”

On Friday, Stanton pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge Jon P. McCalla. He is set to be sentenced in February. 

Dunavant

“American citizens and consumers rely upon food manufacturers engaged in interstate commerce to provide them with safe and consistent products,” Dunavant said in a statement. “Unfortunately, this defendant betrayed that trust by tampering with and tainting food products. We commend the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for their investigation in this matter, and we are pleased that the defendant has been held accountable for his criminal conduct.”

Robert M. Hiser, Acting Special Agent in Charge, FDA Office of Criminal Investigations’ Miami Field Office, said “maintaining the safety and wholesomeness of the U.S. food supply is a critical priority for the FDA.”

“Today’s announcement should serve as a clear reminder that the FDA will not tolerate illicit tampering activity in our nation’s food supply,” Hiser said in a statement.

Categories
Letter From The Editor Opinion

When Notoriety Backfires

Notoriety is a funny thing, and when it comes, you’d better be prepared to roll with the flow. Get your people ready. When the public turns its eyes to you, anything can happen. Andy Warhol famously said that in the future everyone will be famous for 15 minutes, but these days fame does not arrive and depart with such tidal efficiency. It sloshes and roils like choppy surf. One day, you’re on top of the news cycle; 24 hours later, no one remembers your name, as you sink beneath the waves. (See, Scaramucci, Priebus, Hicks, Tillerson, McMaster, Spicer, et. al.)

When you’re a corporation, like, say, United Airlines, notoriety can eat your lunch. A couple bad PR moments — a passenger dragged off a plane, say, or a dog dying in an overhead bin — and your reputation is shot. The only good news is that expectations are lowered, as in, “Oh, we were on the tarmac for three hours and they sent my bag to Milwaukee, but what do you expect? It was United.”

There are ways around this peripatetic cycle, of course. One way is to become president. When you’re president, you can be famous 24 hours a day, if you want to be. You can be famous every 15 minutes, nonstop. You can turn every news cycle into your own reality show, filled with people talking about what you said and how you said it, where you went and what you did. It can be all about you. Which is how President Donald Trump appears to like it.

But this week, Trump is having to take a seat in the gallery and watch as the nation pauses to remember President George H.W. Bush, who passed away at 94 last weekend. Bush 41 was not without flaws during his presidency; some of his domestic policies, his “Willie Horton” ads, and his ignoring of the AIDS crisis were marks against him. But Bush and Russian President Mikhail Gorbachev together engineered the end of the Cold War and brought down the Berlin Wall, a monumental achievement that will remain his enduring presidential legacy. Bush was, by most accounts, a decent and honorable man who loved his family and served his country with dignity.

During Bush’s presidency, he was plagued — unfairly, given that he was a World War II combat pilot and played college baseball — by what was called the “wimp factor.” He was compared, on occasion, to George McFly, the hapless character played by Crispin Glover in Back to the Future, to whom Bush bore some resemblance. George McFly’s nemesis was the evil bully, Biff Tannen, who delighted in giving George noogies and shouting, “THINK, McFly!”

It’s not a stretch to see the parallels between blowhard Biff and Trump, who, at a rally just a few weeks back, took great delight in making fun of the elder Bush’s volunteer program, “a thousand points of light.”

“A thousand points of light. What the hell was that?” Trump smirked to his adoring cult. “Can somebody explain that to me? I don’t think anyone ever understood that.” He might as well have added, “THINK, McBush!”

Ha. Ha. Nothing says class more than making fun of a dying 94-year-old former president and war hero for a cheap laugh. But time has a way of evening scores. In Back to the Future, George found his courage, gave Biff a shot to the jaw, and won the girl, demonstrating that the fearsome bully was all bluster and bravado. Time may do the same to Donald Trump.

I believe the next few weeks will test the country’s resolve — and the rule of law — as Robert Mueller’s Russian investigation brings to light more unsavory connections between the Trump organization and Russian intelligence during the 2016 campaign. We’d best batten down the hatches. Trump’s American reality show will reach new heights of drama and intrigue — and maybe even a season finale.

But no matter what happens, it helps to remember that notoriety fades in a flash and history is written in indelible ink. If Donald Trump lives to 94 and his body is brought to the Capitol Rotunda, I suspect the years will not be as kind or as forgiving as they have been to George Herbert Walker Bush.

Categories
Politics Politics Feature

Shelby County Commission Ponders Matters of Time

Toward the end of Monday’s meeting of the Shelby County Commission, second-term member Mark Billingsley, looking out from his seat on the stage of the Vasco Smith County Administration Building, swept an arm out toward the auditorium’s row of seats, all virtually empty, as Billingsley pointed out, save for a few isolated staff members.

Billingsley went on to suggest  to his colleagues that the commission’s recent decision to change the start time of its meetings from 3 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. — ostensibly, on the initiative of new member Mick Wright, to enable more members of the general public to attend meetings — had failed, and that maybe the commission ought to revert to its previous start time.

A couple of things struck at least one observer as unusual: 1) that the effective half-hour difference did not seem all that consequential; and 2) that it had been Billingsley himself, at the beginning of his first term, four years ago, who had moved for a change in the body’s start time, from 1:30 p.m. to 3 p.m. And his reasoning back then? That such a change would enable more members of the general public to attend meetings.

In one sense, given the number of reasonably significant matters that have occupied this commission in its first couple of months, the matter of starting time might have seemed relatively unimportant. But is it? Commissioner Wright, who represents Bartlett, had originally suggested an even later start time, 6 p.m., but that was shaved back during later consideration, on the grounds that, while the public might indeed be freer to attend in the evenings, staff members — whose presence on many matters is essential — would be inconvenienced by having to stick around.

There is no perfect time for a public body to meet, of course. The Memphis City Council’s start time for its Tuesday public meetings has, for several years, been 4:30 p.m., a time that strikes something of a mean between the needs of public and city government staffers, but seems mainly to be of advantage to the 10 o’clock newscasts of local television stations, by providing them with relatively fresh newsbreaks.

On Monday, Wright earned a bit of teasing from colleague Edmund Ford Jr., who noted that several of Wright’s initiatives involved clock time, including another matter up for discussion on Monday — that of Daylight Saving Time. Wright had suggested that the back-and-forth shifting — back an hour at one time of year and up again later on — creates unnecesary dislocation in people’s lives.

Wright first proposed including the state’s abandonment of Daylight Saving Time as an item in the commission’s recommended legislative package for the General Assembly but later said he’d be satisfied with the imposition of year-long Daylight Saving Time. The idea in either case, with or without DST, was to maintain a year-long consistency.

Ultimately, the commission approved an amended version of Wright’s resolution, one that would urge the General Assembly to reconsider the issue of Daylight Saving Time without recommending a particular course.

• As befits a local legislative body, perhaps, the incidence of partisan disagreements is not large, but it does exist. It showed itself on a few matters Monday.

One instance concerned the meaning of a resolution asking the General Assembly to amend the state’s Basic Education Program (BEP) “to fund additional school Resource Officers, Social Workers, and Counselors.”

A debate of sorts erupted over the meaning of the term “Resource Officers.” Amber Mills, the resolution’s original sponsor and a Republican, wanted the term construed to denote security officers. Or, at least, she accepted commission Chairman Van Turner‘s paraphrase of her intent to mean something such-like.

Other commissioners, including the body’s Democrats, wanted a looser definition, and they prevailed in a party-line vote, in which Wright, Billingsley, and Brandon Morrison, all Republicans, sided with Mills on the losing side. The final  resolution, with the looser definition intact, then passed 12-0.

Another Mills resolution asked the General Assembly “to avoid the adoption of Legislation, Policies, Rules of Regulations requiring the implementation of unfunded mandates.” This one, arguably reflecting a traditional Republican concern, was approved unanimously once it was reworded to specificy “unfunded education mandates” — which Mills accepted as expressing her basic intent.

A third matter reflected this commision’s apparent inclination to skirt possible divides in the interests of unity. This was regarding an ordinance, up for the second of three required readings, to amend the requirements of the Shelby County Minority and Women Business Enterprise Program (MWBE).

As outlined by Shep Wilbun, chief county diversity officer, the ordinance went into minute detail defining the terms, numerical and otherwise, that either permitted or encouraged the awarding of contracts in greater numbers to firms owned by women and/or African Americans. In the end, there appeared to be general agreement on the commission that the accretion of new detail was such as to make an already abstruse process even more “cumbersome” — an adjective supplied by Commissioner Morrison.

And thus the ordinance was routed back to committee to undergo a process of simplifcation.

• Last weekend saw a visit here by Tennessee Democratic Party chair Mary Mancini, one of several planned for statewide under the head, “Analyze, Organize, Mobilize,” to discuss party affairs and strategy. A group of 30 to 50 local Democrats met with Mancini at the headquarters building of U.S. Pipefitters Local 614 in Arlington.

On hand to assist in the process, in the wake of what has been a highly successful year or two for the party, was Shelby County Democratic Party chair Corey Strong, who confided that he intends to focus on his job as special project director at Shelby County Schools and does not plan to seek reelection in March, when local Democrats meet in convention.

The forthcoming convention will re-inaugurate a cycle that was interrupted when the Shelby County party, having fallen into disunity and ineffectiveness, was dissolved by Mancini in 2016.

Categories
Film Features Film/TV

Green Book

Here’s a conundrum for you: How do you make a person less racist?

Screaming “You’re racist!” at them doesn’t seem to help. But there’s one thing that does seem to help reduce hatred and bigotry of all kind: exposure. The more people you meet who are different from you, the less likely you are to hate them for the color of their skin or their language or religion or sexual orientation or whatever. Travel, in other words, helps bring us together.

That’s more or less the theme of Green Book. It’s 1962 in New York City, and Tony Lip (Viggo Mortensen) has a pretty good gig as a bouncer (“I’m in public relations”) at the legendary Copacabana night club. It’s a beautiful and elegant place populated by the rich and famous — and also a bunch of mobsters. That means Tony has to occasionally mix it up it with a well-heeled but rowdy Italian guy in order to keep the peace. But after an incident with a don’s hat goes a little sideways, the club gets shut down for the last two months of the year, so Tony’s got to find a new job.

Viggo Mortensen (left) and Mahershala Ali take to the road in Peter Farrelly’s Green Book.

He makes a few bucks betting fat guys he can eat more hot dogs than they can, but with the holidays coming up, underground competitive eating contests aren’t going to cut it. Then he gets a job interview with a doctor who needs a driver.

Dr. Don Shirley (Mahershala Ali) couldn’t be more different than Tony, who has lived his whole life in the same Bronx neighborhood where his father and grandfather also lived. Dr. Shirley’s got three PhDs, none of which are in medicine.

“He’s a doctor of piano playing,” Tony says later.

“Can you be that?” asks his wife Dolores (Linda Cardellini).

Yes, you can. But it was not common in 1963 for a black man to have a PhD in the arts; to have studied in Russia, Germany, and Italy; or to have a comfortable career playing his own neoclassical jazz compositions for the rich and powerful. Dr. Shirley needs a driver because he’s embarking on a two-month tour, where he and his trio will play both cavernous concert halls and intimate chamber recitals. The catch is, the tour will swing through the deep South, and Dr. Shirley knows at some point there’s going to be the kind of trouble where a beefy, mobbed-up Italian from the Bronx is going to come in handy. After some negotiation, Dr. Shirley meets Tony’s price, and they’re off. But not before Tony is forced to become acquainted with the Green Book, a publication from the Jim Crow era that listed black-friendly hospitality establishments all through the segregated South. Once they’re on the road, however, the odd couple will discover that just sticking to the book is not enough to avoid bigotry, discrimination, and outright violence.

The obvious and easy comparison for Green Book is Driving Miss Daisy, only with a white guy behind the wheel and a black guy playing the part of the patrician passenger. In practice, however, it’s not that simple. Directed by Peter Farrelly, half of the Farrelly Brothers, who brought us such carefully crafted social experiments as There’s Something About Mary and Dumb and Dumber, this film is not precious or preachy — or at least, not too preachy.

For much of its length, it’s basically a two-hander set in a tail-finned blue Thunderbird traveling on the then-new Interstate system and on the back roads of Kentucky, North Carolina, Tennessee, Louisiana, Georgia, and finally, Alabama. The chemistry between Mortensen and Ali is critical, and the two actors spend the film elevating and occasionally transcending the material they’re given to work with. Mortensen grew a totally authentic gut for the production, and he and Farrelly can’t stop throwing food gags into the mix. (The best is when Tony eats a whole pizza like he’s hoisting a slice on the street.) Ali is all about dignity, his performance recalling Ellis Haizlip, the effortlessly classy TV host profiled in the documentary Mr. Soul!, who, like Dr. Shirley, was a gay man who found an accepting home in the New York of the ’60s. The juxtaposition of class (Tony is poor, Dr. Shirley is wealthy) and race (as an Italian Yankee, Tony is only slightly more accepted than Dr. Shirley in the hierarchy of Southern society) make for the film’s most interesting moments. But if you’re looking for a piercing critique of race and class, seek out Sorry to Bother You instead. Green Book is well-meaning and competently made, but anodyne and ultimately ephemeral entertainment.