Categories
Opinion

From Pyramid Big Dig to Big Do-Over

pinchpyramid.jpg

The chances of an earthquake destroying the Pyramid in the next 100 years are slight. The chances of a demolition in the next few years are a lot better.

Bass Pro Shops and Robert Lipscomb seem to be resigning themselves to what a lot of people have been saying for years: the Pyramid just doesn’t work for a tenant that wants to put in a giant retail store and a hotel and get some use out of the observation deck and all that unused space in the lower level.

Seismic danger, “dueling building codes” and the bond market are getting blamed for the hit, but come on, this merry-go-round has been turning for six years. The Pyramid has become a symbol of failure, and apathy. FedEx Forum made it obsolete. The first question a visitor asks is “what’s that?” and then you have to tell them, “Yes, but, it’s empty.”

“If it costs too much to stabilize it then you have to decide if it is usable for anything,” Lipscomb said Tuesday.

It might be worth more as salvage material and bare ground. Then Bass Pro, if it is really committed to Memphis, could build what it wants instead of adapting to what is there. If the company wants a downtown presence at some other location, then Peabody Place has some space.

The status report that the city handed out Tuesday says:

“The Pyramid and Pinch District have received the most attention, but the City of Memphis redevelopment vision is much bolder. It is not about the addition of a retail magnet and a distinctive retail district, but more precisely, it is about building a thriving, active Convention Center District.

“The absence of this kind of district has always put Memphis at a competitive disadvantage in our ambitions for a successful convention center.”

The city is going ahead with its plans to acquire property in the Pinch District and the Lone Star property between the interstate ramps.

If the Pyramid is shaky, then the ancient convention center is shakier. What the city seems to be suggesting is something on the order of the new convention centers in Nashville and Jackson, Mississippi. A hugely expensive project at a time when the municipal bond market, according to daily news reports, is comparable to the stock market or the real estate market two years ago, especially for issues that are not backed by taxing authority.

The groundbreaking ceremony for the Pyramid was called The Big Dig. The odds are getting better that we will see a Big Demo before we see a Bass Pro downtown.

Categories
News

Time to Fish or Cut Bait for Bass Pro/Pyramid Deal?

“Bass Pro has had enough time,” said Commissioner Joyce Avery. “Either they make their decision or let’s go with something else.”

“Something else” could be the Ericson Group’s proposal for a $250 million indoor amusement park. The plan includes a “Disney-esque” theme park, a shopping mall at the foot of The Pyramid, improvements to Mud Island, and a 300- to 400-room hotel. Under the proposal, which would rival the Graceland expansion, Ericson would buy the property, pay off The Pyramid’s existing debt, and do so without public tax dollars …

Read the rest of Mary Cashiola’s column on the various Pyramid schemes being tossed around in the public arena in this week’s Flyer.

Categories
News The Fly-By

With Baited Breath

“Bass Pro has had enough time,” said Commissioner Joyce Avery. “Either they make their decision or let’s go with something else.”

“Something else” could be the Ericson Group’s proposal for a $250 million indoor amusement park. The plan includes a “Disney-esque” theme park, a shopping mall at the foot of The Pyramid, improvements to Mud Island, and a 300- to 400-room hotel. Under the proposal, which would rival the Graceland expansion, Ericson would buy the property, pay off The Pyramid’s existing debt, and do so without public tax dollars.

“I’d like to see it judged on its own merits,” said Memphian Greg Ericson, “but I think it’s a superior project to what’s out there.”

In its ongoing flirtation with Memphis, Bass Pro has signed three letters of intent with city and county government, the latest of which expires January 31st. This week, the commission asked Mayor A C Wharton not to sign any additional letters of intent with Bass Pro.

“We’ve been told repeatedly that a deal was just around the corner with Bass Pro,” said Commissioner Steve Mulroy. “I think an amusement park is a better use for the public than a glorified bait shop.”

Though the letters of intent were both non-exclusive and non-binding, some commissioners felt the conversation with Ericson was a bit premature or that they were somehow cheating on Bass Pro. But after three years, it’s hard to imagine when the right time for this conversation might be.

Ericson not only went through the initial Pyramid re-use committee process several years ago; the committee recommended his proposal in its final report.

After a meeting with Willie Herenton, in which the mayor suggested Ericson buy the land, he included that in his proposal. The last time Ericson met with the County Commission, they wanted to know if he could actually get financing for an indoor theme park, even though he didn’t have a letter of intent. When he came back last week, he had a team of moneymen with him.

“We don’t need three-and-a-half years to go through the letter of intent phase,” Ericson said. “If we started today, we could have everything funded and signed one month from today.”

The administration said it would study Ericson’s financing and present a report to the commission before the end of January.

On the face of its proposal, I’m not for or against Bass Pro. But I get the sense that the company is just — if you’ll excuse the paraphrase — not that into us. And when you compare that to the boy next door who has been persistently pursuing The Pyramid, it’s all the more apparent.

Besides Ericson’s financial proposal, which greatly outscopes Bass Pro, and all the pretty pictures of roller coasters, a few things turned my head.

Outside of the initial $250 million investment, the Ericson group would spend $5 million a year on marketing the amusement park to the 85 million people within a day’s drive of Memphis. That’s New Orleans, Atlanta, Dallas, and even Chicago.

By comparison, there are already Bass Pro stores in Atlanta, Dallas, and Chicago and one planned for Denham Springs, Louisiana, outside of Baton Rouge. Heck, there’s already a Bass Pro located here.

As part of the retail-space component in its plan, Ericson could also easily incorporate Bass Pro. “The beauty of our proposal is that there is plenty of room for both of us,” Ericson said.

I think the community at large has been more than patient and fair to Bass Pro. At the commission’s committee meeting, there was some discussion about whether the county would need to issue a request for proposals (RFP). Ultimately, it was decided it would not, but not before Ericson reminded commissioners his company already did that.

“We already went through an RFP process,” Ericson said. “Bass Pro never did.”

Just having another suitor for The Pyramid is good news. In July, Memphis chief financial officer Robert Lipscomb said the city didn’t have any leverage because no one else was interested. If this gets a proposal out of Bass Pro — and it’s the best proposal for The Pyramid — then I say, Cheers, here’s to a long and happy life together.

Perhaps Mulroy put it best: “We have another option,” he said. “It would be foolish of us if we didn’t consider it.”

Categories
News

County Commission Committee Urges No More “Letters of Intent” for Bass Pro/Pyramid Deal

A County Commission committee has
approved a resolution asking Memphis Mayor Willie Herenton not to sign another letter of intent with Bass Pro for The Pyramid if nothing further with the company develops before the January 31st deadline.

The commission is looking at a proposal for an $250 million redevelopment plan with an indoor amusement park and a hotel proposed by the Ericson Group.

The city and county have signed three letters of intent already with
Bass Pro. The county has something of a gentleman’s agreement to let the city be the lead agency in negotiating for a new use for The Pyramid.

Commissioner Mike Ritz expressed the commmittee’s concerns: “The city may want to extend the letter of intent some more … How do we keep that from happening?”

The resolution will come before the full County Commission on Monday.