Categories
Fly On The Wall Blog Opinion

No Next Day Election Results For Gannett Newspapers

If there was ever a news item worthy of the “Dammit Gannett” tab, it’s this. Via The Nashville Scene:

“Editors at the [Gannett] chain’s papers around the country were informed two weeks ago that deadlines for the print edition could not be extended in order to cover elections. As a result, Wednesday’s editions of The Tennessean, Commercial Appeal and Knoxville News-Sentinel will not have final results for some of the most closely contested statewide races in years.”

Justin Fox Burks

“We do not believe print is a vehicle for breaking news,” Tennessean vice president   and editor Michael Anastasi was quoted as saying.

Anastasi’s not wrong, of course. Broadcast and online media do have advantages when it comes to live and breaking news. How that absolves daily print editions from obligations to print subscribers and expectations of  mere currency remains a mystery.

Folks who pay for paper say it with me now: Dammit!

UPDATE: NiemanLab weighs in:

“Conceptually, the push to separate print — “not a vehicle for breaking news,” that Gannett memo notes — from digital makes a certain sense, of course. And not adding any extra pages of newsprint for election results does save money. (“As you plan for print, please remember that we have tight controls on newsprint costs,” says the memo. “Any pages added need to be ‘made up’ by the end of the year preferably in November.”)

At the same time, it is those incredibly loyal print readers — the ones who have stood by newspaper companies through cut after cut in staff and in the product — who will now see that loyalty tested, again. Gannett, like a number of other newspaper companies, has more than a third of its print subscribers ages 70 or above in many markets. Most read in print; digital is a second and lesser option. (E-edition readers, who essentially get the print paper in digital form, will also be impacted by this decision.) Those subscribers, at Gannett and elsewhere, have seen their subscription rates hiked again and again, raised to the very limits of econometric modeling.”

Ken Doctor’s column notes that, in an effort to push more readers online Gannett is dropping its paywalls for 48 hours, enabling anyone with internet access to read Gannett’s election coverage. It’s a good read that takes a hard look at recent economic and subscriber history.

“What those numbers tell us is that that road to a mostly/fully digital future gets narrower month by month. Digital subscriptions — which sell at much lower prices than print ones, though with lower marginal costs — are gaining ground much too slowly. Given the combination of higher prices, a lesser product, and even increasingly erratic home delivery, print subscribers may provide less of a lifeline to the digital future than Gannett and other publishers now assume in their whiteboard calculations.”

Read it all here.

Categories
Letter From The Editor Opinion

The Local Angle

This is the Flyer‘s 1,500th issue, which means that we’re almost 29 years old, if you do the math. My, how time flies when you’re having fun! And we are still having fun, that I can tell you, my friends.

There have been a lot of changes since February 1989, and a lot of talented people have walked the funky halls and worked in the humble cubicles of our old warehouse office in downtown Memphis. And a lot of talented people are still working here, of course — cranking out stories for print and online, designing pages, and selling local businesses on the effectiveness of our circulation.

By almost any measure, the Flyer has become a Memphis institution, with a long-established circulation of 44,000 and steady pickup rate of around 94 percent each week, rain or shine, year after year.

So, why is that? Why is it that our humble weekly can survive when so many papers around the country are shrinking, downsizing, and failing?

It’s not a secret, really. It’s the fact that we are local. Our employees are local, and our ownership is local, not a corporate behemoth demanding ever-increasing profit margins to keep Wall Street happy. We just have to stay in the black and keep our readers happy. Or irritated. Or whatever reaction we can get from you, as long as you care enough to read us.

The media landscape in this country has been transformed over the past 15 years or so, with local media ownership becoming less and less common, as national corporations buy up locally owned properties and go for “economies of scale.”

For example, Clear Channel, now known as iHeartMedia, is the largest operator of radio stations in the U.S., with more than 850 stations (!) under its control. It’s much the same in the television industry. You may have read recently that the Sinclair Broadcast Group, which owns more stations than any company in the U.S., is poised to acquire many more, as President Trump’s newly appointed FCC chairman loosens regulations — including rules that prohibit corporations from owning more than one station in a market and require local news stations to maintain an office in the community they serve.

Sinclair is a right-wing corporation that turns its local outlets into mini-versions of Fox News, including requiring its stations to run conservative political commentary. They will soon own WREG, it appears. Yay.

And let’s not forget the Gannett Company, which owns The Commercial Appeal and dozens of other papers around the country. The company has eliminated the CA‘s local production and copy-editing operations and laid off many of the paper’s best-known writers and reporters. To further cut costs, Gannett prints most of its Tennessee papers in one plant in Jackson, Tennessee. Due to a company-imposed early print deadline, the CA is now unable to publish about anything that happens after 5 o’clock in the following day’s paper, in the process, making the print sports section essentially worthless.

There is no way a local ownership, one that was in tune with — or cared about — its community, would put out a product like that. Gannett, Sinclair, Clear Channel, and other media mega-corporations see the bottom line and little else. Which is another reason why we do this annual issue that promotes local holiday shopping. These merchants are us. They aren’t big box stores. They aren’t working for stockholders. They’re working to make a living — creating and selling products they believe in. Sure, Amazon makes it easy to shop from your couch, but Amazon doesn’t give a darn about Memphis. So, let’s all keep that in mind this year and spread some cash into our locally owned businesses. Shop local. Eat local. Drink local. Be local.

And, yes, read local.

Categories
News News Blog

Capitol Hill Reporter Rick Locker Leaves Commercial Appeal

Locker and Locker

Rick Locker, the Commercial Appeal‘s longtime Capitol Hill reporter, has left his post to take a job in communications with the Tennessee Board of Regents. As the Nashville Scene‘s Steven Hale put it, in a piece bemoaning the dwindling institutional memory in government reporting, there’s now a little, “less scrutiny for a legislative body that could always use more of it.”

Newspaper culture changed overnight in Tennessee when Gannett added both the Commercial Appeal and The Knoxville News Sentinel to a list of media properties that already included the Tennessean. The CA reporter had become a contributing presence in all of the state’s three major publications, and his voice will be missed. 

Check out the Scene’s commentary for a brief, pithy overview of the situation.