Categories
Letter From The Editor Opinion

Letter From the Editor: Gamecocks and Gay Rights

On occasion, I speak to journalism classes. One of the things I always say is that this profession, like few others, broadens you, opens you to new experiences. You meet fascinating people, you observe history unfolding in real time — judicial decisions, civic activism, crime and corruption, war, politics, sporting events, theater, art, music, food — you name it, and journalists cover it.

It’s senior editor Jackson Baker’s journalistic lot to have to occasionally trek to Nashville and cover the machinations of our Tennessee legislature (page 19). But I don’t tell students about this sort of assignment, because I don’t want to scare them off.

Imagine the fear it would strike in these eager young minds if I told him they might have to go to a Bizarro World where the inhabitants fear gays but love cockfighting; where mop sinks are seen as Muslim footbaths and guns are worshiped; where you can vote using an out-of-state hunting license but not with a state-issued student ID. Where parents whose children get bad grades are deprived of money that pays for food or rent. Where evolution is just another “theory,” like gravity and creationism. Where ideology and fear and allegiance to special interests trump common sense and the public welfare.

While history unfolds in the rest of the country, our lawmakers are refolding it. As gay marriage moves closer to reality, our legislators ponder a law prohibiting teachers from even saying the word “gay.” While the rest of the country comes to grips with Obamacare, our governor, unwilling to take on his party’s ideologues, minces around with “alternate” plans that will leave us picking up the health-care tab for thousands of uninsured Tennesseans. While Congress works on a bill requiring background checks for gun purchases, our legislature passes a bill requiring employers to let their workers have guns on their premises.

Two weeks ago, I wrote about the General Assembly’s push to give vouchers to thousands of people so they could send their kids to private and religious schools. I joked at the time about what would happen when they realized such a bill would allow Muslim schools to receive public funds. I was joking, because I thought surely they’d already considered this little complication.

Nope, it turns out they hadn’t, and that derailed the voucher bill til next year — until the good ol’ boys can figure out a way to end-run the Constitution and channel tax-payer funds only to schools that don’t have Muslim footbaths.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com

Categories
Sports Sports Feature

FROM MY SEAT: A Dream Now Dead

I
realized a dream come true last weekend, courtesy the game of football. And I
came crashing back to reality Monday, with football merely the conduit for pain
an entire community must now endure.

I never
got to meet Taylor Bradford, the University of Memphis football player shot and
killed Sunday night on the U of M campus. But Tiger football is a part of my
life — both casually and professionally — every fall, and has been since I
started writing this column more than five years ago. So it’s a loss in the
family, even if extended.

That
dream I mentioned? A friend and I drove to Dallas last Saturday, with our
pilgrimage to Texas Stadium — almost 30 years in the making — central to our
Sunday plans. As children of the Seventies, Johnny G and I have carried Cowboy
blue and silver in our veins since Roger Staubach first bridged the gap between
comic-book hero and flesh-and-blood role model. From the Tom Landry statue —
every bit as rigid as its late subject was over his 29 years as Cowboy coach —
to the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders (their pregame kick line from one
25-yard-line to the other rivals any the Rockettes have ever performed), the
experience made for an afternoon of goose bumps for two Memphians. And that was
before the 28-point victory over St. Louis had been completed.

Over the
drive back from Dallas — 500 miles allow for some serious reflecting, even on
the subject of football — I had some thoughts on the difference between football
in Cowboy country and the variety we know, love, and suffer here in the
Mid-South with the hometown Tigers. A professional orange to a college apple,
you might argue, but within the same pigskin realm. The contrast is dramatic, to
say the least.

But then
the crash. Then reality. Then murder in Memphis.

We
sportswriters aren’t deserving of the soapbox other journalists often stand upon
when it comes to society’s ills. Our job is to report scores, describe heroes,
identify trends — on offense, defense, and in between — that shape the way we
spend our down time. That’s what sports provide: a distraction. Until the
distraction is bloodied by the same horrid reality we all — journalists and real
movers and shakers — must confront when the worst in us seizes the headlines.

Time and
a criminal investigation will provide the details in Bradford’s murder. But
here’s one variable that won’t be affected, regardless of the investigation’s
details: no 21-year-old college junior should be dead having found himself on
the wrong end of a gun. Which brings me to my unwanted soapbox this week.

When
will we finally get it? When will we — Memphians, Americans, human beings —
realize that guns are destroying our freedoms, and not protecting them? That
guns turn grievances — minor and otherwise — into capital crimes? That guns in
the hands of young people are tragedy on a stopwatch? That people don’t kill
people, not without weapons, and that guns are the weapon of choice for most
killers?

Taylor
Bradford certainly had dreams. Maybe he dreamed of playing in Texas Stadium one
day (in a Cowboy uniform or otherwise). He certainly dreamed of closing the gap
between football as Dallas fans know it and the football Memphis fans recognize.
A track-and-field star at Antioch High School in Nashville, Bradford had come to
focus on football, and took it seriously enough to transfer from Samford
University to Memphis, where he could play for a program that would fulfill an
athletic dream. Most tragically, Bradford was a dream realized — all by himself
— for Jimmie and Marva Bradford, parents who now must find a way not to hate the
word Memphis, forget whatever football is played here.

The
Tigers will apparently play Marshall University Tuesday night at the Liberty
Bowl, as originally scheduled. The game will be televised on ESPN2. Marshall’s
football program, of course, is most famous for having been rebuilt from the
horror of a plane crash that killed in the entire team in 1970. I don’t imagine
there will be much excitement in the voice of your television analysts at
kickoff.

The game
shouldn’t be played. If it means forfeiting to Marshall, that’s what Tiger coach
Tommy West should do. Football should draw us to society’s margins, where we can
cheer, laugh, even boo events that don’t really matter. Whether performed in the
glow of a stadium that has seen five Super Bowl champions or in an oversized
arena clinging to life as a viable community asset, football should be that fun
distraction a society craves.

A
football player murdered? A human being murdered? The game stops. No time for
distractions.

Categories
Opinion The Last Word

The Rant

Three issues arouse passions like no other. These litmus-test subjects (and I feel very confident asserting this) are God, Guns, and Gays. Given the e-mails that I get when I write on any of these topics, they evoke more unreasoned emotion than anything else.

“God, Guns and Gays” (which I also think was my prom theme) can cause family rifts, chasms in relationships, and outright irrational behavior in humans.

Other writers have suggested that if I want to be liked I shouldn’t go near God, Guns, or Gays. But my thinking is that I have never been liked, so why start trying so late in the game? Moreover, there are 300 million people in the USA (180 million of them here legally), and it is a fool’s game to try to please them all, so here goes …

First, about God: When this subject comes up, people are usually referring to their own particular deity, and therein lies the problem. Almost any action can be justified by someone’s religion, most of which are based on books written more than 1,000 years ago and which are open to all sorts of interpretations. We must remember, moreover, that only 30 percent of the world’s population is Christian and that those 2.1 billion Christians belong to dozens of different denominations, each of which slices and dices the Bible in its own way.

We are in a war now because a certain sect takes a jihadist view of the Koran. This sort of thing, if you read history, never ends well.

The Pilgrims came to North America to flee religious persecution and to worship as they chose. With that in mind, the Founding Fathers made the separation of church and state one of the fundamental tenets of our democracy. They were clear: They wanted a democracy, not a theocracy.

So, when it emerges that upward of 150 young graduates of the late Jerry Falwell’s Liberty University law school are holding down important jobs in the Bush administration, it concerns me. And when one of the most senior staffers in the office of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales (who resigned under pressure and took the Fifth Amendment) also turns out to be a graduate of Falwell’s fourth-tier law school, it is clear that mixing religion and law is the objective.

Many of these zealots do not recognize the separation of church and state (much in the same way that they do not recognize fellow parishioners in the liquor store).

In the wake of the Virginia Tech tragedy, guns have become topical again. And as in all matters of importance, I believe less government intrusion in the matter is the best policy. Liberals like Rosie O’Donnell spend much of their time preaching about more gun-control laws. And if you think guns make people criminals, then spoons are what make Rosie fat. Therefore, we should really outlaw spoons. And if government regulates spoons, could forks and knives be far behind?

Remember, three of the Fort Dix terrorist suspects had been in our country illegally for about 20 years. Between them, they had 75 arrests and citations, and our crack government agents failed to investigate their illegal status. I put no faith in government’s ability to effectively police anything.

Homosexuality, as we all know through televangelists, is a learned behavior. Much like those with cerebral palsy or red hair, folks who are gay “choose” it. All a gay guy has to do is close his mind to Brad Pitt and pray a lot and he will be fine. Not as fine as Brad Pitt, but okay.

And what better way to make amends for the way you are than to spend your life in constant denial of the way you are so that you can please the pious people who hate you in the name of religion?

If the real reason that those who condemn gay marriage do so is because they do not want gays having sex, my suggestion is quite the opposite. As most married folks have found, there is no better way reduce the incidence of sex than to get married. The Religious Right may want to rethink that one.

Bush and the neo-cons seem to want us to fight for our God with Guns and without Gays — to preserve the American way of life, as they see it, against Muslim terrorists. Given his popularity numbers, I am not sure the American people are with Bush in this semi-religious war.

The bottom line: Life is short, so spending too much time pushing your views about these personal matters on others is a waste of time. Live a good life. Be an example for others. You will find that is the best way of encouraging people to see things your way.

Ron Hart is a columnist and investor in Atlanta. His e-mail address is RevRon10@aol.com.

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

Letters to the Editor

Guns and Disasters

Regarding the “Cheat Sheet” (April 5th issue): While I would agree in theory with the premise that law enforcement officers would have better things to do than confiscate the guns of law-abiding citizens during the aftermath of an emergency or natural disaster, the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina demonstrated that some in law enforcement thought otherwise.

I’m not sure a Tennessee state law will be any more useful in protecting our rights than the Bill of Rights was for those in New Orleans. However, I’m a proponent of the measure anyway. I’m certainly an advocate of revealing the abuse of power by any level of our government. And, if nothing else, this measure has brought renewed attention to some of those abuses.

Tracy Addison

Memphis

An MLGW Experience

My husband and I received a letter from MLGW saying that over the course of 2005-2006 we weren’t charged properly for gas due to a meter malfunction. It took MLGW over a year to figure out its mistake, and they have now issued us a bill for over $500 for “back charges” and kindly said that payment arrangements can be made.

What is the proof of these charges? They sent us a nice spreadsheet that we could have recreated. Why, after a year of inconsistent billing, are they just now telling us we owe them? Does it really take that long to catch such a critical error? Does the city think we have that kind of money just lying around?

Why do so many get perks while we have to pay for a year of MLGW’s mistakes? I think this is an unfair practice, and I do not think we should owe back charges of any kind. My husband and I plan to contact MLGW and not only dispute these extra charges but demand proof that we even owe them in the first place. I am curious as to how many other Flyer readers have experienced this problem.

Farrar Lindner

Lakeland

Editor’s note: If you have experienced similar problems with MLGW, please let us know.

Food vs. Cigarettes

Is it right that food pantries go bare because Tennessee’s food tax is so high? Absolutely not!

Is it right that while Tennesseans pay 8.35 percent tax on groceries, the tax on cigarettes is only 20 cents per pack? No way!

Tennessee’s current tax system places unfair burdens on the backs of our state’s most vulnerable while giving smokers the benefit of a low tax. This is not just. We must reduce the burden of heavy taxation on food and increase the tax on cigarettes.

Governor Bredesen proposes to raise the cigarette tax in order to increase the budget for education. We suggest that increased spending on education will not improve the success of our state’s children if they are not receiving adequate nutrition at home. Sadly, some families have to make the hard choice of which groceries to buy because high taxation eats away at their critical buying power.

Current bills in both the state Senate and House of Representatives propose a food tax/cigarette tax swap. SB 93 and HB 114 propose to decrease the food tax by 3 percent and increase the cigarette tax by 40 cents per pack. Contact your legislators and tell them you support these bills.

Emily Orten, Erica Thomas,
Sherika Goodman

Memphis

The volunteer state

In honor of National Volunteer Week, April 15th-21st, I am writing to urge more people to do as I have done and volunteer at animal shelters. Though it can be dirty cleaning cages and scrubbing runs, it is very rewarding not only to help cash-strapped nonprofit shelters but also to see the animals in their care heal, begin to trust, and blossom.

How much joy I’ve gotten fostering kittens, grooming those whose coats need attention, and socializing the very fearful ones who have less chance of finding a home. Those who love animals are sorely needed no matter your skill level. Come help out!

Cheryl M. Dare

Memphis