Categories
At Large Opinion

Is This a Circus?

“We are talking about nothing less than 75 people overruling the wishes of 78,000 people! And you’re gonna cut off debate? Give me a break! Is this a circus? If you can’t sit through a conversation or a debate on something no less than expelling a colleague … you don’t belong here!”

Democratic Representative John Ray Clemons of West Nashville spoke for thousands of Tennesseans last week as he watched his GOP colleagues turn the democratic process into meaningless procedural flimflam. It was a travesty, a mean-spirited exhibition of white men wielding power in the worst possible way.

They did it because they’re used to doing it. They did it because they’ve never paid a price for it, mostly because no one was ever watching before. It was just one of the many tricks the Republicans in the Tennessee House of Representatives used in the process of expelling three duly elected representatives. These included cutting off Wi-Fi in the galleries, postponing action until late in the day after thousands of demonstrators had arrived for the scheduled morning opening, not allowing the three lawmakers to know what would be expected of them in mounting their defense, showing unattributed video of their protests … and, well, I could go on.

It was an astonishing display of autocracy, ruthlessly leveraged by hypocritical ignoramuses — only this time, the entire world was watching — and instead of suppressing the voices of change, as they so clearly intended to do, the Tennessee GOP instead amplified them in ways they could have never imagined in their wildest fever dreams.

Prior to last week, Justin Pearson, Justin Jones, and Gloria Johnson were known only by their constituents, if that. Now they are household names, appearing on major television networks, here and abroad, meeting with Vice President Kamala Harris, and being invited to the White House. Tens of thousands of dollars are flowing into their fundraising coffers.

To those Republicans responsible, I’d just like to take a moment to say: Nice job, you racist, gun-sucking assholes. You’ve embarrassed yourselves and your state, but mostly yourselves. And it couldn’t happen to a more deserving bunch of clowns.

There. I feel better. Especially knowing these fools have helped spawn a new generation of activists, one that will stand strong against the only two arrows the Republican Party seems to have left in its pathetic quiver: a Taliban-esque, no-exceptions, anti-abortion platform and a no-permit, total open-carry, pro-assault-weapons agenda. Good luck running on those issues in 2024 and beyond.

And speaking of clowns … How about that Justice Clarence Thomas, amirite? Turns out that for the past couple of decades he’s been taking hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of luxury yacht cruises, resort vacations, and private jet rides courtesy of a right-wing Texas billionaire named Harlan Crow. Crow also founded a side-hustle PAC for Thomas’ wife, Ginni, and paid her a sweet $150,000 a year to run it.

But nope, no corruption to see here, said Clarence. He and Harlan were just friends, he said, adding that he would stop now that he knew it was wrong.

Never mind that Crow is embedded in the activist judicial group, the Federalist Society, and never mind that he has one of the world’s great collections of Hitler memorabilia. Because that’s normal. Right?

Listen, when I began my journalism career, one of the first things I was told is “don’t accept anything from a potential source, not even a cup of coffee.” The reason being, of course, that any hint of impropriety could compromise a story by calling into question the journalist’s impartiality.

The Thomas case is the very definition of compromising someone’s impartiality with favors. And, much as was the case in Nashville, it went on only because no one was watching. How is it remotely possible that the ethics code for a member of the United States Supreme Court is flimsier than that of a newspaper reporter?

It isn’t, and Thomas knows it. Otherwise, he would have reported the largesse extended to him. It’s absurd on its face. If, however, Republicans are still intent on expelling a Black man from office, I do have a suggestion.

Categories
News News Blog News Feature

Constitutionality of Expulsion Of Rep. Jones and Pearson Questioned by Legal Counsel

The Tennessee House of Representatives recently received correspondence questioning the constitutionality of the expulsion of members Justin Jones (D-Nashville) and Justin Pearson (D-Memphis.)

In a letter addressed to House Speaker Cameron Sexton, counsel for Jones and Pearson said they are “reviewing these unconstitutional actions to understand how best to remedy them.”

“The House Republicans not only wrongfully stripped these Representatives of their rights as duly elected legislators but also disenfranchised the voters they were elected to represent,” the letter said. “Their partisan expulsion was extraordinary, illegal and without any historical or legal precedent.”

The House expelled Jones and Pearson last Thursday, for “leading a floor protest over gun violence.” While Jones and Pearson were joined in this protest by Representative Gloria Johnson (D-Knoxville), they were the only two that were expelled. The measure to expel Johnson failed by one vote.

On Monday, April 10th, the Nashville Metropolitan Council voted unanimously to reinstate Jones to the state legislature. The Shelby County Commission is scheduled to vote on Pearson’s reinstatement on Wednesday, April 12th.

According to Tennessee Lookout reporter Adam Friedman, the trio was “accused of violating the House rules of decorum when they took over the speaking podium to lead chants with a crowd protesting the lack of action by lawmakers on gun violence after six were killed — including three children — in a mass shooting at a religious school in Nashville.”

The representatives’ counsel also explained that if both are reappointed, it must lead to “the full and immediate restoration of their rights as members of the House.”

“Representatives Jones and Pearson, if reappointed, should be promptly sworn back in as members of the General Assembly and granted the same benefits, rights, duties, and liberties as any other members of the General Assembly and granted the same benefits, rights, duties, and liberties as any other member,” the letter said.

They also called for the returning of their parking and badge access to the State capitol, healthcare, and status on committees.

The letter also stated that any “retributive action,” such as discrimination, threats, or actions to withhold funding for government programs would “constitute further unconstitutional action that would require redress.

“The world is watching Tennessee,” they said.

The attorneys representing Jones are former U.S. Attorney General Eric H. Holder, Jr., C. William Phillips, and R. Gregory Rubio of Covington & Burling LLP. Representing Pearson are Scott J. Crosby, Jef Feibelman, and Sarah E. Stuart of Burch Porter & Johnson.

Categories
News News Blog News Feature

Tennessee House Republicans Expel Two Democrats, Keep One, Over Gun Floor Protests

The Tennessee House of Representatives voted along party lines to expel Democratic Reps. Justin Jones and Justin Pearson from its body for leading a floor protest over gun violence one week ago, but Rep. Gloria Johnson survived expulsion by one vote.

The expulsion vote against Jones, D-Nashville, was 72-25, and 69-26 against Pearson, D-Memphis. It needed 66 votes it pass.

The vote against Johnson, D-Knoxville, was 65-30, one short of the number needed to expel as seven Republicans voted to keep her.

The trio is accused of violating the House rules of decorum when they took over the speaking podium to lead chants with a crowd protesting the lack of action by lawmakers on gun violence after six were killed — including three children — in a mass shooting at a religious school in Nashville.

Rep. Charlie Baum, R-Murfressboro, was the only Republican to vote against kicking Jones out. Rep. Sam Whitson, R-Franklin, was present but did not vote on Jones’ expulsion resolution.

The expulsion hearing for Jones went on for nearly two hours.

Reps. Jody Barrett, R-Dickson; Rush Bricken, R-Tullahoma; Bryan Richey, R-Maryville; Lowell Russell, R-Vonore; Mike Sparks, R-Smyrna; Baum and Whitson voted against removing Johnson. Reps. John Gillespie, R-Memphis, and Bryan Terry, R-Murfreesboro, were present but abstained from voting.

The expulsion hearing for Johnson lasted 90 minutes.

Baum, Gillespie and Richey voted against expelling Pearson. Whitson was present but did not vote to remove Pearson.

The expulsion hearing for Pearson lasted 90 minutes.

Twitter thread of the expulsion hearing

OK, so now in the expulsion hearings @JRClemmons, an attorney, is trying to make the point that the video the GOP just showed “was in direct violation” of house rules disallowing members to shoot video on the floor.
“Are we going to punish them as well?”

— Anita Wadhwani (@anitawadhwani) April 6, 2023

Tennessee Lookout is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Tennessee Lookout maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Holly McCall for questions: info@tennesseelookout.com. Follow Tennessee Lookout on Facebook and Twitter.

Categories
Politics Politics Feature

Turmoil at Capitol

Not since the income tax riots of 2001 has the Tennessee state capitol building in Nashville seen such intensity. Monday’s session of the General Assembly, which included the introduction of resolutions in the House threatening the expulsion of three Democratic state representatives, concluded with the crowded galleries shouting epithets — including “fascists” — at members of the Republican supermajority.

Outside the capitol, worse things were being chanted by massive crowds at the expense of GOP Governor Bill Lee, who, like the Republican lawmakers, was faulted for inaction on gun safety following last week’s gun massacre at a Nashville Christian school.

“Eff Bill Lee!” the demonstrators chanted.

The three Democrats in jeopardy — representatives Gloria Johnson of Knoxville and Justin Jones of Nashville, along with Memphis first-termer Justin Pearson — had gone to the well of the House last Thursday, and, with the aid of bullhorns, encouraged protesters in the galleries to keep demanding action on guns.

A vote on expulsion of the three will probably take place Thursday, along with, equally probably, energetic new protests on their behalf and for gun-safety legislation.

• On Thursday this week, Chancellor JoeDae Jenkins will hold a status conference on suits by mayoral candidates Floyd Bonner and Van Turner against an apparent edict by the Shelby County Election Commission (SCEC) requiring five years of prior residence in Memphis for candidates.

Neither candidate could clear a strict interpretation of the SCEC’s edict, which is included on the Commission’s website via a link to an opinion from former Commission chair Robert Meyers.

Jenkins gave a preliminary ruling last Friday against the SCEC’s effort to include the city of Memphis as a co-respondent against the suits.

• There was some unprecedented attention given to the matter of county contracts at Monday’s public meeting of the Shelby County Commission, and it all started while the body was considering the meeting’s “consent agenda,” ordinarily regarded as routine and largely consisting of pre-screened items.

With Democratic member Britney Thornton in the lead and with fellow Democrats Erika Sugarmon and Henri Brooks, among others, taking part, members kept county financial officers and economic opportunity administrator Shep Wilbun in the well for more than an hour answering detailed questions about each and every contract up for a vote, including many that appeared to be essentially maintenance matters.

The two basic questions were: How many bids were there for the contract? And how many bidders were minority? In most cases there was an obvious and even enormous disparity in the two numbers, which was, of course, the point of the questioners.

Categories
News News Blog News Feature

Tennesseans Respond Online to Actions Against the “Tennessee Three”

A GoFundMe, an open letter, and a viral video that some say constitute “assault” against a Nashville lawmaker are swirling online in the wake of a gun-violence protests at the Tennessee Capitol and a move to expel some Democratic lawmakers. 

All of it follows the April 27th shooting at Nashville’s Covenant School last week that left three children and three adults dead. A massive protest brought hundreds to the Capitol the following Thursday. 

On the House floor that day, Reps. Justin Pearson (D-Memphis), Gloria Johnson (D-Knoxville), and Justin Jones (D-Nashville) supported the protesters. During the legislative session, Jones spoke through a megaphone holding a sign that read “protect kids, not guns.” The three then moved to the Speaker’s well and “began shouting without recognition” and ”proceeded to disrupt the proceedings” from 10:50 a.m. to 11:42 a.m., according to a House resolution. 

Republicans filed three resolutions Monday to expel Pearson, Johnson, and Jones — the now-called “Tennessee Three” — from the state House of Representatives. The three were stripped of their committee assignments, and access to the garage, doors, and elevators at their office buildings. 

This brought hundreds more to the Capitol Monday to protest with some yelling “fascists, fascists!” at Republicans from the House gallery and many more to yell “Fuck Bill Lee!” outside the building. 

A viral Twitter video from Jones (below) shows the fracas inside the House Monday. In it, Jones films Rep. Justin Lafferty (R-Knoxville). As he closes in on Lafferty to apparently film what is on his phone, Lafferty turns, Jones’ phone camera moves erratically, and someone can be heard saying, “hey, get your hand off of me!” Jones posted the video at 8: 30 p.m. Monday. So far, the video has been viewed nearly 5 million times. 

The video prompted numerous responses like these: 

House members are expected to vote on the expulsions Thursday. Many online organized a GoFundMe Monday evening to help with expect legal fees to fight the move. As of Tuesday morning, the fund raised $10,537 of its goal of $25,000. 

GoFundMe

“Democracy is at stake due to the extremely unfair and unconstitutional behavior of [House Speaker Cameron Sexton (R-Crossville)],” wrote donor Amanda McDowell. “He should be the one being ejected, although we all know hell has a better chance of freezing over first. 

“The [Tennessee] Three should be commended for actually caring about their constituents and the children of this state. They ran for office to serve the people, and it truly shows. They have my gratitude and full support.”

Some urged Twitter users to sign a digital open letter to their leaders in the legislature. The letter pulls no punches, callings Republicans’ actions “shameful,” and warning that “elections will be coming soon.” 

”You all should take this opportunity to make Tennesseans feel better instead of putting armed guards in public schools that you refuse to properly fund,” reads the letter. “Expelling these Democrats will make you all the infamous Republicans who tried to squash democracy in Tennessee.”

Finally, some news reporters on Twitter reminded users that the state GOP refused to vote to expel Rep. David Byrd (R-Waynesboro) in 2019 after allegations surfaced that he had inappropriate sexual contact with teen girls in the 1980s. 

The resolution to expel him was sponsored by Johnson, who now faces expulsion for her part in the gun protests.  

Categories
News News Blog News Feature

House Republicans Move to Expel Three Democrats Over Floor Protests

Republican lawmakers sponsored resolutions Monday to expel three Democrats who led a protest on the House floor last week as hundreds of people rallied outside the chamber for tighter gun laws before the session devolved into a fracas. 

The bills are aimed at state Reps. Justin Jones of Nashville, Justin Pearson of Memphis, and Gloria Johnson of Knoxville. They’re sponsored by Republican Reps. Andrew Farmer of Sevierville, Gino Bulso of Brentwood and Bud Hulsey of Kingsport.

Members voted on party lines, 72-23, to vote on expulsion  Thursday when the House goes into session again.

Spectators in the House balconies reacted by shouting, “fascists, fascists!” before being escorted out by state troopers. As lawmakers shot video of the event, Rep. Justin Lafferty, R-Knoxville, turned to Jones, who was standing nearby, grabbing Jones’ phone and shoving the freshman lawmaker.

House Democratic Caucus Leader John Ray Clemmons characterized Lafferty’s move as “assault.”

The House Democratic Caucus and Tennessee Black Caucus later opposed efforts to expel the three lawmakers.

“The political retribution is unconstitutional and, in this moment, morally bankrupt,” the Black Caucus said in a statement.

Thousands of people protested the state’s lax gun laws again Monday on the War Memorial Plaza and inside the Capitol, many of them high school students, a week after the shooting deaths of six people at The Covenant School in Green Hills.

A two-thirds vote of the chamber is required for expulsion of any member, but Republicans hold a supermajority with 75 of the House’s 99 seats.

The trio is expected to be given a chance to defend themselves before the entire chamber.

Resolutions by the three Republican lawmakers point out the state Constitution enables the House to punish members for “disorderly behavior.” House rules include “preserving order, adhering to decorum, speaking only with recognition, not crowding around the Clerk’s desk, avoiding personalities, and not using props or displaying political messages.”

All three resolutions contend Jones, Johnson and Pearson “did knowingly and intentionally bring disorder and dishonor to the House of Representatives through their individual and collective actions.”

It notes the trio moved to the well last Thursday at 10:49 a.m. and started shouting and pounding on the podium, leading chants with a crowded gallery and “engaged in disorderly and disruptive conduct, including refusing to leave the well, sitting on the podium, and utilizing a sign displaying a political message.”

Jones and Pearson both used a megaphone to rally the crowds.

The resolutions state the targeted members have been notified about the potential expulsion.

Republican Rep. Sam Whitson said Monday he wanted Democrats to take action against the trio for disrupting the chamber. Democratic leaders balked at the idea.

House Speaker Cameron Sexton accused them of “insurrection,” a claim they vehemently deny.

Protests continued Monday night inside the House chamber with Sexton having state troopers remove at least two people for outbursts as Republican Caucus Chairman Jeremy Faison discussed the need for people to refrain from “mob” behavior.

State Rep. Bo Mitchell responded that the House needs a “little light” shed on it.

Tennessee Lookout is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Tennessee Lookout maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Holly McCall for questions: info@tennesseelookout.com. Follow Tennessee Lookout on Facebook and Twitter.

Categories
News The Fly-By

MEMernet: Skaters, Clowns, and a Dashiki

Memphis on the internet.

Tony and Tyre

Legendary pro skater Tony Hawk announced on Twitter last week that half the sales of a photo of himself and pro BMX rider Rick Thorne will go to the Tyre Nichols Fund. The fund will build a skate park in Nichols’ memory.

“He was a talented skater among other admirable traits,” Hawk tweeted. “Let’s keep his legacy alive.”

City Clowncil

Posted to Reddit by u/12frets

Performers with the UniverSoul Circus attended last week’s Memphis City Council meeting. But u/Sho_nuff_ wondered, “Why are the city council members sitting in the back row?”

Headline h/t to Shea Flinn.

Dashiki Shake-up

Posted to Twitter by Justin Pearson

Newly elected state Rep. Justin Pearson (D-Memphis) induced ulcers in Nashville last week.

“We literally just got on the state House floor and already a white supremacist has attacked my wearing of my Dashiki,” Pearson tweeted. “Resistance and subversion to the status quo ought to make some people uncomfortable. Thank you to every Black Ancestor who made this opportunity possible!”

Categories
Politics Politics Feature

Movers, Shakers, and Wannabes

Gone from Memphis on a new professional mission that is an advance itself which may lead to more is Liz Rincon, who is heading to Chicago to become the new director of development for the Chicago Philharmonic.

Liz Rincon with Chooch Pickard at her going-away party

Rincon, a longtime activist, has been the proprietor of the Rincon Strategy Firm for, lo, these several years in Memphis and has shepherded many a candidate in a city and county election. She is well-known as an expert in “cutting turf,” i.e, mapping out and organizing neighborhood door-to-door actions, and for her efforts in assisting the city of Memphis in encouraging residents of impoverished areas to accept Covid vaccinations.

• John Marek, the activist and cannabis entrepreneur who ran for the city council’s 5th District seat four years ago, losing to current incumbent Worth Morgan, may try it again, depending on the final shape of the council districts (the bluer the better, from the point of view of Democrat Marek). Alternatively, he is considering a challenge to incumbent Chase Carlisle for the Super District 9-1 seat.

Likely candidates for the 5th so far include Nick Scott, owner of the Alchemy restaurant at Cooper-Young, and Meggan Wurzburg Kiel, an organizer at MICAH (Memphis Interfaith Coalition for Action and Hope) and former director of support for Soulsville Charter School.

• Greg Blumenthal, who long considered being a candidate for the 5th District council seat, has opted instead to join two other activists, John Carroll and George Boyington, in forming a new political consultancy. The trio is assisting Memphis mayoral candidate Van Turner (who is also helped by the firm run by Matt Kuhn and Mike Lipe), as well as District 86 state House candidate Justin Pearson.

• Justin Pearson,who came to fame as the leader of the successful 2021 campaign against a proposed oil pipeline to be routed through South Memphis, is running with the same vigor for the District 86 seat which was made vacant by the death in November of 93-year-old Barbara Cooper.

Anyone who remembers Pearson’s stewardship of the successful battle against the pipeline knows that he has a way with campaigns and a knack for dramatizing issues. His task of late is more personal. He is attempting to convince the voters of District 86 to vote him in as Cooper’s successor rather than any of several opponents. This past weekend, Pearson turned his birthday party into a fair-sized rally. He has door knockers aplenty at work, has collected a pile of endorsements, and is said to be ready to send out mailers.

As no doubt are others. Nine other candidates are competing, several with good chances, especially considering that, as in the case of any other special-education vote, the turnout is likely to be low. Among the contenders: Tanya Cooper, Barbara Cooper’s daughter and an educator in her own right; Julian Bolton, a longtime member of the Shelby County Commission and other public endeavors who is well remembered among the somewhat elderly voters who regularly vote in this district; Will Richardson, who ran up a decent vote in his August primary challenge to Rep. Cooper; Rome Withers, son of the well-remembered photographer Ernest Withers; Dominique Frost, employee of Shelby County government and an insurance entrepreneur; and Clifford Lewis, son of a well-known activist.

Categories
Uncategorized

Aspirants to Cooper Seat Queue Up

With a qualifying deadline set as soon as December 15, would-be candidates are rushing to get  their petitions for the state House District 86 seat made vacant by the recent death of longtime legislator Barbara Cooper, who died in October at the age of 93.

With more names expected, the list of would-be candidates as of early Monday — all Democrats so far — include Julian Bolton, Tanya Cooper, Clifford Lewis, Will Richardson, and Justin Pearson.  

Bolton served several terms on the Shelby County Commission, Tanya Cooper (Barbara Cooper’s daughter) was a recent candidate for General Sessions Court Clerk, Lewis is an activist, Richardson was Barbara Cooper’s unsuccessful opponent in the 2022 Democratic primary, and Pearson was the youthful leader of the successful 2021 anti-pipeline movement in South Memphis.

Primary date for the special District 86 election is January 24, with the general election scheduled for March 14.

The name of Barbara Cooper, the longest-serving Tennessee legislator, remained on the November election ballot, and received enough votes to certify her as the winner. Governor Bill Lee issued a writ of election for the vacated seat on November 28.