Categories
Editorial Opinion

Mayor Strickland’s New Cabinet

So far, the major appointees of Mayor-elect Jim Strickland seem an acceptable bunch. Like the members of his transition team, they are a mix. Appropriately enough for mayoral bridegroom Strickland, the old nuptial saying applies: “Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue.”

The “something old” component, previously announced, includes several retainees: interim, now permanent, public works director Robert Knecht; general services director Antonio Adams; information services director Brent Nair; libraries director Keenon McCloy; executive director of workforce investment Kevin Woods; finance director Brian Collins; and Memphis Police director Toney Armstrong.

Among the “something new” appointees: Douglas McGowen as chief operating officer (COO), a new position; Bruce McMullen as city attorney; Alexandria Smith as human resources director; and Ursula Madden as chief communications officer.

Madden, a longtime news anchor for WMC-TV, Action News 5, also qualifies in the “something borrowed” category, inasmuch as she is a lift from the ranks of the media, a rival “estate” to government in Edmund Burke’s category of major societal divisions.

And “something blue” as a category applies handily to Armstrong, the head of city law enforcement whose tenure in office has in the past few weeks endured despite dismissive rhetoric by two mayors. A C Wharton made a premature announcement of Armstrong’s departure in the aftermath of the election that proved to be, in the old Nixonian-era term, “inoperative.” And Strickland’s persistent refusals during his campaign to commit himself to re-employing Armstrong were widely read (and apparently misread) as a vote of no confidence.

Indeed, it would almost seem that Armstrong himself — as resourceful in the politics of survival, it appears, as in his celebrated detective work (chronicled for a nation in TV’s 48 Hours) — has the major say in his professional destiny, including whether he will abide by his erstwhile, Wharton-era decision to retire in 2017 or keep on keeping on. The director is remarkably direct in his statements, keeping a sense of independence and an even keel, as when he spoke of the “logistical nightmare” he faced after cuts in police benefits played havoc with his forces. And who among us even remembers that group of restive police dissidents he identified as “the monsters” when he took over as director in 2001. Without much fuss or fanfare, they were simply subdued.

And, speaking of independent hands, we confess to being intrigued by Strickland’s “buck-stops-here” determination to reorganize his administration with himself as the hands-on center of the wheel vis-à-vis his major appointees. This contrasts with Wharton’s approach, which was more of a sort of chairmanship relationship to a group of autonomous departments.

All in all, we think Strickland has begun cautiously and well. And, without being at all conspicuous in a ticket-balancing sort of way, he appears to be fashioning an administration that is diverse and representative of several points of view — an administration that does not break jarringly with the preceding one but clearly can move in its own chosen direction.

Categories
News News Blog

Teachers Express Anger Over Compensation Plan

So many teachers showed up to the Shelby County Schools (SCS) board meeting Tuesday night to protest a proposed performance-based compensation plan that attendees were being asked to watch the meeting on TVs in a separate area of the administration building.

During a nearly hour-long public comment period in a standing-only room, teacher after teacher expressed outrage at the new plan, which provides for annual raises based on performance. The issue for many teachers is that performance is determined by their Teacher Effectiveness Measure (TEM) score, which ranks from level one (lowest) to level five (highest). Those with level one and two scores will not receive raises, but teachers with level three scores will get an $800 raise. Teachers with level four will receive $1,000, and level five teachers will get $1,200.

teacher_pay.jpg

The TEM scores are partially determined by student surveys and a school’s overall standing, and some teachers don’t think those factors should judge their individual performances.

“I’ve had no cost of living adjustment in four years, and my health insurance has quadrupled in 10 years,” said Ethan Randall, a teacher a Kingsbury High School. “And the current TEM process is entirely subjective.”

As teachers took turns at the podium, opponents of the compensation plan held up signs and cheered. But when a handful of teachers expressed support for the new plan, the opposing teachers in the crowd booed, leading SCS Board Chair Teresa Jones to chide them. She asked security to remove anyone who interrupted the speakers “by any means necessary.”

One of those supporters was Becky Taylor, a teacher at Idlewild. She called the compensation plan equitable and cited the fact that Memphis teachers make higher salaries than teachers in Nashville.

“In most professions, performance-based pay seems rational,” Taylor said.

After the public comment period, Superintendent Dorsey Hopson defended the compensation plan, and he claimed that many of the plan’s opponents were spreading misinformation.

“When we look at overall performance of this district, we have got to do something different,” Hopson said. “We have got to drastically improve achievement.”

Hopson said he’d heard some teachers complain that SCS could only afford to fund the new plan if the number of level five teachers was lowered. But he said that wasn’t true. He said 80 percent of SCS’ teachers were currently at levels four and five, and the new system was based on those numbers.

“It is also absolutely false that there’s a plan to rate teachers low,” Hopson said. “We want teachers to be evaluated fairly.”

Board member Kevin Woods told the teachers in the room that the board is listening to their concerns with the new plan, and he said he’d like to see the board develop a more comprehensive approach to evaluating teacher performance. But he agreed with Hopson that something has to be done to improve overall achievement.

“I heard one teacher say that Memphis was the highest paid district in the state, but we also need to be the highest performing district,” Woods said.

Categories
Flyer Flashback News

Flyer Flashback: Election Result Challenges

What goes around comes around. You can say it that way, or you can say much the same thing in French.  Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose. That’s a little fancier, but let’s face it: Each of these expressions is a cliché, and they each got that way for the simplest of reasons. Patterns of life don’t change much. Or, to say it yet a third familiar way, there is nothing new under the sun, and there are only so many ways to express that fact.

As we go to press, the Shelby County Election Commission (SCEC) — or, to be more exact, the county Election Administrator’s office, which in theory is overseen by the Election Commission, is under suspicion again (again!) for not getting an election right.

A candidate for the Shelby County Commission is challenging the election commission’s unofficial count, which showed him losing a primary action by 26 votes; his own count, derived from photostatted specimens of the tabulated print-outs from each precinct in his district, has him in an exact tie with the presumed winner. Either his or the SCEC’s unofficial count is right. Maybe neither is. In any case, a fair amount of suspense was mounting in advance of  this week’s planned election commission meeting to formally certify results.

Kevin Woods and Rev. Kenneth Whalum Jr.

We’ve been here before. In 1974, a box of precinct returns that had somehow gone missing turned up just in time to overturn the already declared outcome of a congressional race. And, in the 25 years of the Flyer‘s existence, uncertainty of election results has been a fact of life.  

In 2006, there was a challenge to several outcomes in the county general election, and in 2010, there was another. In the last case the challenge got hairy, indeed, going on for months as recorded in a score of Flyer articles. (Sample headline from September 17, 2010: “Election Protesters Turn Fury on Consolidation, Public Officials.”)

Each of these situations required a court to rule, and, while the official results were sustained by a court in both of those years, that wasn’t the case in 2012 when (sigh) it happened again. Precinct lines had been drawn wrong for a school board election, and this time, Chancellor Kenny Armstrong, as chronicled in an online Flyer article on Monday, August 19, 2013, declared  invalid (because uncertain) the narrow election victory of Kevin Woods over the Rev. Kenneth Whalum Jr. in a battle of incumbents who had been forced to run for the same seat in the newly reconfigured Shelby County Schools (SCS) board.

Said His Honor: “The election commission here made no concerted effort to avoid the problems that occurred in this election for school board positions. … These mistakes in assigning so many voters to incorrect school board districts cannot be simply ignored in an effort by the court to not take the step of declaring an election invalid.”

So justice hath prevailed? Maybe, maybe not. Woods, who has gone on serving in the meantime and, in fact, got elected chairman of the SCS board, exercised his right to appeal that verdict, and that process is still underway. It may be that the current contest for the County Commission’s district 10 will meander on for an equally prolonged period, which would really complicate the forthcoming August 7th general election between one of the contending Democrats and a Republican nominee.

Or maybe things got worked out at this week’s election commission meeting, in which case we’re all breathing a sigh, not of exasperation but of relief.

There is still too uncanny a resemblance between the election machines we’ve been using to choose our leaders and the slot machines some of us use to probe for weaknesses in the law of averages.  

Surely there’s a better way to do this democracy thing, but if it keeps on turning up the same old seven and six in election after election, we’re here to report the fact.

Categories
News News Blog

Dorsey Hopson on the SCS Budget, School Closures, and Re-zoning

Dorsey Hopson

  • Dorsey Hopson

Shelby County Schools (SCS) Superintendent Dorsey Hopson, SCS Chief of Staff Reginald Porter, and SCS Board Chair Kevin Woods addressed the media today on several key issues affecting the school system.

On the budget:
* Hopson said SCS has $227 million less in this year’s budget than in last year’s budget. Budget hearings will begin on Friday and last for 4 to 6 weeks.
* Some SCS central office positions may be cut, but Hopson said “the goal is to keep cuts as far away from the classroom as possible.”

On re-zoning:
* SCS board members will be tasked soon with voting on more than two dozen student attendance zoning changes. Re-zoning adjustments are needed because of the separate municipal school districts that are opening in the new school year. Several public re-zoning hearings that were scheduled for this week have been rescheduled because of the weather.

* Hopson said his proposals would “keep zoning as close to [students’] houses as possible.” Porter vowed that “student interest is first and foremost when we make the decisions.”

On school closures:

* Although Westhaven Elementary students will be moving to Fairley Elementary next school year because Westhaven’s building is in poor condition and must be demolished, the board plans to ask the Shelby County Commission for $11 million to build a new school that will be occupied by Westhaven and Fairley students. Hopson said Fairley would eventually be torn down as well, if the commission grants the funds to build a new school. Woods said he believes the Shelby County Commission would support this plan, and he feels confident they’ll vote to fund construction of a new school for Westhaven and Fairley.

* Northside High School, which was on the chopping block for closure, was one of a few schools the board voted to keep open. They have a year to boost enrollment and academic achievement. Hopson said that could possibly be accomplished by boosting career and technology programs there in the hope of attracting back students. Currently, 300 students are zoned to attend Northside, but only 280 kids are enrolled there. Hopson said it’s important for that school to win kids back. If Northside doesn’t improve in one year, it will be forced to close, and Hopson said the board will be in talks with Memphis Housing and Community Development Director Robert Lipscomb about alternate uses for the building.

* Hopson said he’s still working on plan for what will happen to the nine school buildings that are closing next school year. He said some may be sold, and others may be released to charter schools.

On new schools:
* Hopson said they’ll be doing an analysis to determine if any neighborhoods could actually support more schools. He believes there’s a need to build a new school in southeast Shelby County and one near northwest Shelby County around the Bartlett area.

On the SCS cleaning contract:
* The new budget includes about $1 million more for a contract with cleaning company, GCA. Hopson said “It’s no secret there were a lot of complaints” about how well the company was cleaning schools in the past, and he blamed those problems on a staffing issue with the cleaning company. Budgeting more should pay for more workers to clean schools, he said.

Categories
Opinion

Stand for Children Stands for . . . What?

61BGVY2W4EL._SL500_AA300_.jpg

A group called Stand for Children held a press conference last Friday to, well, pat itself on the back. Nothing wrong with that. Politics is not for the shy. Four candidates it backed for Unified School Board were elected, but three others lost and one of the winners was unopposed. Still, a decent batting average.

Jane Roberts of the Commercial Appeal, Les Smith of Fox 13, and I were the only ones who showed up at the office on McLemore across from Soulsville and Stax Academy. That’s a small showing compared to, say, a mayoral press conference. I think it shows some uncertainty about exactly where Stand for Children stands, who they are, and how much clout the group has. We wound up having more of an informal conversation with Tennessee director Kenya Bradshaw and three of the candidates than a press conference.

The uncertainty was reflected in our choice of adjectives. I like “upstart” group. Les went with “education advocacy organization” and The CA has gone with “education reform group.” One thing we agreed on is that Stand For Children is unusually well funded and spent more than $150,000 on the school board races, which is a huge amount. It doled out some $90,000 to campaign workers who were paid $10 an hour.