On Wednesday, August 12th, 73 House Republicans sent a letter to Governor Bill Lee asking him to call a special legislative session to consider legislation about counties requiring that our children wear masks in schools. Though Lee refrained from calling a special session, he did issue an executive order on Monday, August 16th, allowing parents to opt their children out of mask-wearing, regardless of their school district’s rules.
Around 2010, Republicans passed and touted virtual schools in Tennessee. When the pandemic hit and people wanted virtual, they said it was bad and children needed to be in the classroom. When children returned to the classroom and masks were required to keep them and teachers safe, Republicans wanted to take the masks away.
Now, they’ve come up with another new plan for our children. But this one puts our babies, teachers, and families at even more risk.
This is interesting because I thought Republicans campaigned on smaller government and local control. However, it appears that Democrats in the Tennessee legislature are the real advocates for smaller government and local control. Republicans on the campaign trail talk about local control, but in reality they’re for state control when it comes to something that runs counter to the national Republican agenda and, in many cases, the defunct Trump playbook.
This happened when Memphis removed the Nathan Bedford Forrest statue in what is now Health Sciences Park. It happened earlier this year in the discussions about teaching our young people about race relations in a comprehensive manner. It’s happening again, except this time, they are affecting the safety of our children, our teachers, and our citizens.
The statistics are sobering. According to a case count compiled by The New York Times, the daily average of Covid-19 cases in Tennessee more than doubled (+126 percent) in 14 days. The same for the numbers of Tennesseans hospitalized (+109 percent). According to the Tennessee Department of Health, cases among children under 10 rose sharply in the beginning of August, once again more than doubling. So far, the state has counted more than 52,000 cases in patients 10 years old and younger, and six deaths. To some lawmakers, who are making their arguments based on percentages, six deaths may be acceptable to them. To me, six deaths is too many — and those six deaths could possibly have been prevented.
Now, in spite of those alarming numbers and the fact that only six Tennessee counties have implemented some form of a mask mandate, Republican legislators wanted to bring lawmakers back to Nashville in order to issue vouchers as a punishment/alternative for those parents who don’t want their children to have to wear a required mask (only indoors) while in school. This idea would have allowed them public money to take their children to a private school where masks are not required, the school voucher financial plan being a goal Tennessee Republicans have pursued with vigor. Though Lee’s executive order effectively removes vouchers as an option for this school year, by making masks optional by a state-level executive order, the governor has again cribbed notes from the GOP playbook of undermining local government. This time, the issue is not one of a public park or school curriculum, but of the health and safety of our children.
This is way too much for the citizens of our state. The continued adversarial relationship between the state and Shelby and Davidson counties (the state’s largest contributors of tax dollars and resources) is nonproductive and stressful to all citizens.
How do you say decisions on community health should be made locally and in the very same breath and sentence remove local control in regards to children wearing masks at school? Many children in Shelby County and across the state live in multigenerational households. More and more children are requiring hospitalization when contracting Covid and can easily transmit the virus to parents and other family members whom they may come in contact with. These conditions may prove debilitating or fatal for a child or their family members. I disagree with the executive order. It is irresponsible. The goal is to stop the spread of the virus in Tennessee. This executive order in no way will curb the spread of the virus. As a matter of fact, it may accelerate the spread of Covid in our state.
Furthermore, trying to live and keep one’s family alive and healthy through this pandemic is stressful enough in and of itself. I pray that those of us who are in state leadership will take a few breaths and give local government and leadership an opportunity to govern without the threats coming from “little big brother.” Remember, we are talking about real and actual lives and livelihoods.
Antonio Parkinson is a Democratic member of the Tennessee House of Representatives representing District 98.