Categories
News News Blog

Proposed Change in Fire, Police Residency Requirements Amended

The Memphis City Council continued its discussion Tuesday about lifting the residency requirements for the city’s police and fire personnel, but with a few changes.

The original ordinance, sponsored by council members J. Ford Canale and Gerre Currie, would allow voters to choose whether or not Memphis Police Department (MPD) and Memphis Fire Department (MFD) personnel should have to reside in the city or county, or if they should be allowed to live up to two hours away.

Tuesday Canale proposed four amendments to that ordinance. The first is developing a point system that would create preferential hiring for officers living within the city. The second is implementing a take-home car program for officers living in the city.

The third amendment would change the language of the ordinance, allowing officers to live in bordering counties or within a 50 mile radius instead of the originally proposed two-hour radius.

Finally, Canale recommended that the department only hire outside of the county when the department dips below a full complement of about 2,500 officers.

“We have one goal and only one goal in mind here — to get more men and women to serve the citizens of Memphis,” Canale said. “We’re not on a mission to hire people who don’t live in Memphis. We’re on a mission to put men and women on the street to protect Memphis.”

Councilwoman Cheyenne Johnson questioned why MPD is not able to find enough applicants within the city to fill its roles.

[pullquote-1]

MPD Director Michael Rallings said police departments across the country are experiencing a recruiting crisis and are challenged to find qualified applicants.

MPD Major Sharon Cunningham told the council that of the 13,000 MPD applicants since 2016, only 470 completed the entire application and training process to become officers.

More than half of those who show interest in becoming an officer either never turn in a completed application with the required documents or never show up for the next step in the hiring process.

Of those that do follow through, “Cunningham said 56 percent don’t make it through the physical ability test. Additional applicants are lost after a background check, psychological evaluation, and medical exam.”


After making it through each of these tests, applicants still must graduate from the Police Training Academy. Cunningham said potential officers are often lost here due to injuries.

Rallings added that retention is also an issue, as MPD officers are “highly skilled” and often recruited to work in other departments across the country or here at the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office (SCSO).

“What does the Sheriff’s office have that we don’t?” Councilwoman Jamita Swearengen responded.

Working for the SCSO is “very different,” Rallings said, noting the county’s lighter workload and lower call volume. “You can’t even compare the level of work. It’s like comparing apples and oranges.”

Shifting the focus away from recruiting efforts, Councilman Berlin Boyd told his colleagues that recruiting more officers won’t change the crime demographic in the city, unless the root cause of poverty is addressed.

No votes have been taken on the ordnance yet. If approved by the council after three votes, voters will make the ultimate decision on the ballot next fall.

Categories
News News Blog

Fire Department, Memphis Animal Services Partner to Bring Lost Pets Home

MAS

If you find a lost pet here, you can now take it to any of the Memphis Fire Department (MFD) stations around the city to help them be reunited with their owner.

Through the Fire Finders program, a partnership of Memphis Animal Services (MAS) and MFD, each of the city’s 58 fire stations will now be equipped with a scanner to detect microchips, the small electronic chips that are implanted into pets to help locate them when lost.

MFD personnel will be trained to scan pets and identify their owners. Once identified, the owner will be contacted and reunited with their pet.

Alexis Pugh, MAS director, said before the program, when pets were lost, they would have to be taken to a vet clinic or an animal shelter to be scanned for a microchip, but there are a number of areas here that are “veterinary deserts,” where one might have a hard time finding access to a microchip scanner.

[pullquote-1]

“Every pet should have a microchip, but what we found was that not all of our citizens had the same access to getting microchips or scanning found pets for microchips,” Pugh said. “We’re solving half of that problem with the Fire Finders program, and we are working on a solution for bringing more microchip access to the community in the future.”

MFD director Gina Sweat said that the fire department here is one of the few in the country to offer a microchip scanning service.

“We’re thrilled to continue partnering with MAS to bring innovative solutions like this one to Memphis, without increasing the taxpayer burden,” Sweat said.

The program is funded by a grant from Maddie’s Fund, a foundation that provides resources to organizations around the country in an effort to create a “no-kill nation, where every dog and cat is guaranteed a healthy home or habitat.”

Categories
Cover Feature News

“Do the Work”: Memphis Fire Director Gina Sweat’s Tough Road to the Top

As a little girl, fighting fires didn’t exist in Gina Sweat’s reality, nor in her imagination or her worldview. Her reality was scooping ice into bags for her parents’ grocery store and bait shop in Middleton, Tennessee. Her imagination saw her growing up to care for animals as a veterinarian. Back then, being a firefighter was not something that folks thought girls could be. 

Memphis was the big city, about an hour and a half west of her parents’ country store, where people would buy the ice Sweat bagged or check in the deer they’d killed. A few times a year, her family would visit Memphis to buy school clothes or Christmas presents, usually at the Raleigh Springs Mall. 

Sweat was freckly, red-haired, and dressed like a tomboy. She played basketball and was fiercely competitive. She knew at 12 years old that she was different.

Photographs by Justin Fox Burks

Memphis Fire Services Division Director Gina Sweat

After high school, Sweat left Middleton for nearby Freed-Hardeman University. She studied business but hated marketing and accounting. She played basketball, mostly guard and small forward, but jokes, “I was really good at sitting on the bench,” offering a small dose of her hallmark sense of humor.

With a business degree in hand, Sweat started work as a leasing agent for a property management company. She rose to assistant manager, and then to manager. But she wasn’t “ecstatic” about property management and wanted something more fulfilling. 

Some of her dad’s hunting buddies were Memphis firefighters. They knew she was an athlete and that the city’s fire division wanted to hire women. “I didn’t even know that women could be firefighters,” she says.

A bit out of shape after college, Sweat challenged herself to pass the department’s agility test — putting her mind to it, doing the work, and getting back in shape. She was the only female on the field for test-day. She shouldered an air-pack and ran up five flights of stairs. Some male recruits asked to see her score (maybe in hopes of making themselves feel better). They left disappointed and muttering. A “girl” had bested them. Sweat had passed the test, and when she was offered the job in 1992, only four females had been hired before her. 

It’s a scenario Sweat has grown used to: Knowing eyes were upon her as a female rising through the ranks, doing things that had only been done by males, knowing many were just waiting for her to fail.

“Twenty-seven years later, I still feel sometimes like I’m on that same stage,” Sweat says. “It’s happened at every promotion. People watch to see what you’re going to do, if you’re going to fail, and how you’re going to do things.”

When then Mayor-elect Jim Strickland announced he’d picked Sweat as the Director of Memphis Fire Services Division — the division’s highest post — he called it a “landmark leadership choice.” But he waved the flag of Sweat’s merit and dedication to service way higher than he did the fact that she was female — and he did not mention that she was gay.

Sweat says she never set out to make history or be a role model for women or for the gay community. “I was just one of those people who came to work,” she says. Her parents taught her about hard work, and that — more than anything else — is how she rose to her rank. “Do the work” is the ethos from Sweat, Memphis’ funny, fun-loving, first female fire director.

— Toby Sells

Memphis Flyer: How did you feel about the work early on?

Gina Sweat: First of all, the work is hard. I hate to use the term “fun,” but the adrenaline rush and all that is … well, some personalities kind of really embrace that kind of work. The adrenaline was cool, but it was very hard — and hard being different.

A lot of people would take time to watch me, which was funny. I’d be working, and people would just be watching me like I was some kind of sideshow or something. But I think I earned their respect by letting them know that I was here to carry my weight and that I wasn’t looking for anything. They figured out I was there for a job, just like they were; it kind of got a little easier.

Did you feel like you were breaking any ground back then?

You know, I really didn’t. It didn’t really take me long to fit in. I got close with the guys at the station. That’s just how the fire service is. 

Yes, it starts out as a job, but then a firefighter is something you become. You’re spending nine or 10 24-hour shifts a month — that’s a third of your life. You’re living with these people every day. You’re cooking, you’re eating, you’re cleaning, you’re working together. Then, all of a sudden, the horn goes off, and you’re risking your lives together. You become a very close-knit group. It didn’t really take me long to embrace that kind of camaraderie and try to figure out how I fit and how I contribute. I worked constantly to make sure I was capable of doing my job.

There were men stronger than me. But maybe I can run farther than them. Maybe I was better at something that they weren’t. I think being brought up playing team sports helped. I was always just figuring out a way to contribute. The guys I worked with saw that. You know, people from outside who didn’t know me would start talking just because I was a female. But [my co-workers] were pretty quick to shut that stuff down. It was like, “I can talk about my sister, but you can’t.”

How did you begin to progress through the ranks?

I had a really good lieutenant. I hadn’t been on very long, and he said, “I signed you up for the driver’s promotion test. There’s the books you need. Go study.” I just said, “Okay, yes sir.” People think maybe I have some military background, and I don’t, but, apparently, my personality probably would have been good for that, too.

He told me to study, and I did. We’d practice driving, and I made driver. That was a little over three years … which was about as fast as you could get promoted.

Then, for the lieutenant’s promotion, it was, basically, an assessment center that you go through. It was a competitive process, which lends well to my personality because I was always a bit competitive in nature, especially when I was younger. I studied, applied myself, and ended up number two on the lieutenant’s lists. Same thing with battalion chief. It was an assessment-center process, a competitive process. 

[Battalion] Chief Lloyd Hope made lieutenant before me. Chief [Hope] and I were number one and number two on the battalion chief’s list, and that really … ruffled some feathers.

What did they say about it back then?

There wasn’t much they could say. It was a competitive process, and the rules were clearly laid out. I played the game. So don’t be mad at me if I played it better. 

Later, I went through the process for division chief. I ended up being number one through that process. That’s when I got assigned to headquarters. At the time, the director had kind of a rotation of the deputies that worked up here, but I chose to stay. That’s probably been key for me ultimately becoming the director. 

I chose to stay and learn about what it takes to actually run the department and build relationships at City Hall and understand how the budget works. Working under director [Alvin] Benson and director [Michael] Putt after that and having that mentoring. My deputy director [Michael L. Jubirt], he’s always been a good mentor to me. So it’s only natural that, when I got this job, he was gonna be my right hand.

How did Strickland approach you for the director’s job?

When I had my interview with him, I came out, called my mom, and said, “I either just screwed up my career or I did good.”

I had met him before, and I think we really hit it off. But we had a very serious conversation. He asked me some tough questions, and I think I gave him some tough answers. He calls me one day … and says, “I want you to be my fire director.”

It was surreal. But he said, “The only thing is, you can’t tell anybody. There’s a process, and we want to make the announcement.”

I was going to a [firefighter] graduation that night, and I was actually giving the speech. I’m there, I can’t tell anybody that I’ve had this phone call, and I look out at all these young faces. All of a sudden, I had this overwhelming [feeling] like, oh, my God, this is my responsibility now. I tried not to get emotional about it. Because people would have been like, “She’s a wreck. What’s wrong with her?” That moment was just kind of surreal.

Going back to your career as a firefighter, do you remember any big calls or scary calls on which you had to go?

750 Adams. It was a high-rise fire that happened in 1994. I had about two years on the job. Two firefighters got killed at the fire. Up to that point, it was kind of fun and games. We were fighting fires, and you have all this adrenaline rush. That night, I realized [how serious the job was] because I actually saw people I knew get killed. It was tragic. Even though I’d been on the job for two years at that point, I was still a green rookie. You realize, okay, this is really serious. This job can kill you.

About a month before that, one of the guys on the company with me … we were at a fire at the Ponderosa paper plant down off Thomas. It has those big bales of paper, and they fell on him and trapped him. He was trapped for 46 minutes. That was 25 years ago, and I still remember. They were baled together with baling wire, and the sprinklers were going off. So we had no visibility, and we were digging him out for 46 minutes. It ended up ruining his career. Those two things happened within a month of each other. I almost quit.

Within a few months, we made another fire [call] back at 750 Adams. I remember being in the stairwell and going, “Hell no.” I thought, I either have to quit or I’ve got to suck it up. And I sucked it up and went.

I think those three things together were defining moments. I lost one of my closest buddies to a career-ending injury. And we lost two firefighters, and I had to witness that. Then, being back in that same place and facing that fear and deciding that this is what I want to do.

The other is the [Family Dollar] store fire we had down on Watkins, where two firefighters got killed. I was the battalion chief at that fire. It ended up being in the back of the store where they actually pulled [Charles] Zachary out. The first two of my guys actually pulled him out.

That’s where Lieutenant [Trent] Kirk was trapped. I went to fire school with Lieutenant Kirk. So I knew him very well. There was another guy on the scene who had gone to fire school with us who told me who it was. 

We don’t leave people behind. It was bad. We got a rescue company back there. We weren’t able to get Lieutenant Kirk out. They had almost found him, but I had to pull them out. I had to make them come out. 

It was probably one of the toughest calls I ever had to make. I knew from all my training, all my experiences — everything — [that they needed to come out], and they knew, too, that they needed to come out. Within a very short period after I pulled them out, the whole back of that store flashed over. So it could have easily been four more fighters who died that night. 

In your role as director, what have you changed? In what direction are you moving the fire service?

My leadership style is a bit different. Historically, there’s always been that labor/management thing. All of a sudden, I turn around and I’m “they.” How do you bridge that gap with the person in the field for them to truly know that everything I’m doing is in their best interest? For the folks who’ve known me for a long time, that’s a really easy sell. For those who haven’t, they’re starting to get it. 

“Because we’ve always done it that way” is not the answer anymore. Why do we do it that way? We started questioning ourselves, looking for better ways to do things. We want to be the best, most innovative fire department in the country. The Memphis Fire Department was a Class 1 fire department back in the 1970s, as far as our insurance rating. We’ve been a two since then, and we have a goal to get back to a one, and I think everyone has bought into that goal. We’ve gone through a process [for a new rating], and I hope, when we get those results, it will be a very positive thing for the department and the city. 

In line with the mayor’s initiatives to become data-driven, I was probably one of the first fire directors to set up my own data team. We looked at process improvement and data to make decisions. In the past, decisions were made for either personal reasons or maybe they were made intuitively — with some data that may or may not have been accurate.

What’s a decision that data would influence?

Do we need to build a new fire station? We look at run volume and distances to where developments are and determine whether or not that’s something that’s needed. 

Can you talk about being a leader in the LGBTQ+ community?

It’s not a big secret. I realized I was different at a very young age, in many ways. First, I had red hair and freckles. I was a bit of a tomboy. It seemed like I’ve always been in situations where I was kind of different. When you’re a kid and you have curly hair and freckles, you want straight hair and no freckles. When you’re a kid, you want what you can’t have, especially if you’re a girl, and kids can be kind of cruel. 

[Sweat wrote after our interview to say she felt cursed for being different when she was younger, but “now I realize that being different really was my gift. It’s our differences that make us special, not our similarities.”]

I guess I was probably about 12 when I realized that, okay, there’s something different here. But it wasn’t really something you talked about, so my early adult years were just trying to sort all of that out. 

When I got out of college, I came out to my mom, and she told my dad. I don’t know if me and my dad have ever just talked about it, but when I realized that they still loved me, it was okay. Everybody doesn’t have that luxury. Sometimes it’s not that mom and dad don’t love them anymore, it’s just that they can’t deal with it, and they don’t have the support that I had.    

I didn’t set out to be a spokesperson for women or the gay community. I’m not one of those who goes out to rallies. But if you go to Midtown, you’ll see me hanging out, supporting [the gay community]. If someone knowing my story … if it helps them, then maybe this is the best time for that.   

I get invited to speak to a lot of women’s groups. It is different being a woman in a male-dominated world. I don’t think, as a gay woman, it was as difficult for me in the fire service as it would have been for a gay man, just because of the living situation. 

There were some concerns when I first started thinking of becoming the fire director, wondering, politically, could that somehow be a problem? Or would my people have a problem with that? But I’ll say the mayor has been nothing but supportive.

He gave me the opportunity because I did the work. I put the resumé together. I learned the director’s job. So when the time came, I was ready.

The whole label thing really frustrates me. My body of work speaks for itself. If you took my picture off my resumé, the body of work I’ve done here stands on its own. 

The message I would want anybody to know — no matter your sex, race, political affiliation — do the work and be ready. 

I do feel a certain pressure as a woman not to fail. I don’t want the next woman director — and there will be one one day — not to get the opportunity just because “well, we tried a woman once, and she really messed it up.” But I have a huge support group here in the department and the city. I have a great partner who supports me at home. My mom and dad love me. I have a lot of great friends. 

I’m going to try and do this job the best I can and leave it in really good hands.  Editor’s note: This cover story was edited for length and not for content.

Categories
News News Blog

Task Force Discusses Memphis Police and Fire Staffing

Alexandria Smith

A public safety task force will meet over the coming weeks to discuss ways to recruit and retain Memphis police officers and firefighters. The group met on Thursday afternoon at Memphis City Hall to outline challenges in staffing both departments.

Alexandria Smith, the city’s chief human resources officer, shared results of a survey of police and fire employees that found the departments are suffering from morale issues and are failing to recruit officers fast enough to fill the attrition gaps. Smith said police and fire staffing is her number-one priority.

Police and fire employees reported in the survey that they were happy with the city’s tuition reimbursement and college incentive pay, but they were unhappy with retirement and pension benefits. 

Members of the task force reported that at least nine cities have been recruiting officers and firefighters from Memphis, causing many of the best potential employees to leave after only a short time working for the city of Memphis. Much of the conversation centered around both attracting and retaining millennials, who some task force members said were more likely to get their training in Memphis and seek other jobs elsewhere.

The task force will look at benefits and health insurance options, career development opportunities, and streamlining the promotions process. A study is underway that compares compensation and benefits offered in Memphis with the other cities recruiting officers away from Memphis.

They’ll meet again at Memphis City Hall at 3 p.m. to discuss pension benefits and their effect on retention and recruitment. 

Categories
News The Fly-By

Q&A with Gina Sweat

In December, newly elected Mayor Jim Strickland appointed longtime Memphis Fire Department employee Gina Sweat as the new director, replacing former Director Alvin Benson.

Sweat, the department’s first female director, has been a firefighter for 23 years, rising through the ranks since 1992. Strickland noted that Sweat was chosen for the job “on her merits and her dedication to service” in a press conference announcing her position. The Flyer was able to catch up with Sweat for her thoughts on the new job.

Alexandra Pusateri

Gina Sweat and Mayor Jim Strickland

Flyer: How does it feel being the first female fire director?

Gina Sweat: To be honest, it’s quite humbling. It wasn’t my goal to set off to be the first female fire director. I was just one of those people who came to work. My parents taught me from a very young age the value of hard work, that you earn what you get by working hard and applying yourself. That’s really been my whole approach to my career, because it was hard being a female and not being as physically strong as the men. So you have to find ways to work smarter. They could muscle through things, and I couldn’t.

I never set out to be a role model for women. I just set out to be the person who came to work and did what I was supposed to do. By doing that, and always applying myself, I find myself in this position today. It just shows you can work your way to the top. I think anyone can do what I’ve done. I’ve just been fortunate to have been in the right place at the right time and making sure I was making the right decisions.

Are you hoping to tackle any specific issues as fire director?

We have a great fire department here in the city of Memphis. We’ve had some morale issues, and some of those things I can’t do anything about. But I am going to listen to what’s going on in the field to try and find things I can do. Even if they’re small [things], just to let the firefighters know that I am paying attention and hearing them, just trying to find some little wins to let them know that I have their back.

I do want to find ways for us to become more engaged with the community, which is going to fall in line with the recruitment efforts we do. We’re looking at ways to engage our youth and introduce them earlier to these career opportunities that are open for them, putting them on a path so they’ll know how to become a firefighter.

Once we recruit the right people, we have to make sure they stay on the department. We are losing more firefighters than we have in the past, but I think if we can head that off before it gets out of hand, we’ll be in a much better place.

Where will you be focusing your recruitment efforts?

We’re going to focus our initial efforts in the city of Memphis and the metro area. I think it’s important to recruit people who have some ownership in the community: people who have family and ties to the community, their churches, schools. I think that’s going to help us with the retention part.

In the past, when they did go outside of the city, we got firefighters, but a lot of them didn’t stay. They got the experience here and went back home. Some of them did stay and became Memphians, but I feel strongly that we have people here in the city [who could work for the fire department]. We need to invest in our youth a little better, and we can find quality people here in our hometown.

Categories
News The Fly-By

City Agencies Help Memphians Cool Off

“It’s not the heat. It’s the humidity.” There’s a phrase Memphians have heard a million times. But here lately, it seems the heat and the humidity have teamed up for an especially brutal summer.

Temperatures in July were scorching but averaged only slightly above the average high for the month of 92 degrees. With temperatures peaking at 99 degrees, as seen on July 29th, the humidity and temperature have been combining for heat indexes (what it actually feels like outside) as high as 108 degrees. And temperatures are forecast to remain in the 90s for the foreseeable future.

Jimdelillo | Dreamstime.com

“We do have an increase in heat-related emergencies in the summer, specifically June and July,” said Lieutenant Wayne Cook of the Memphis Fire Department. “These calls come in for a number of causes, such as overheating when exercising or working on jobs or simply from people outside doing lawn care.”

The fire department received about 60 heat-related emergency calls in June, but in July that number more than doubled to around 130, according to Cook.

Shelby County reported four “probable” heat-related deaths as of July 30th. This number is up from last year’s fatality total of two. None were reported in 2013. The heat also killed a dog last week, after it was left in its owner’s car at Wolfchase Galleria for hours. The car’s windows were cracked, but that didn’t help on a day when the heat index reached 112.

“Make sure to stay cool and hydrated, especially during the middle of the day when it is the hottest,” said Elizabeth Hart, public health information officer for Shelby County. “And don’t ever leave pets and kids inside the car for any length of time.”

On July 13th, Memphis Light, Gas, & Water (MLGW) implemented the Special Reconnect Program in which customers who are without one or more utility services can pay $250 plus a reconnect fee to reestablish service. As of August 3rd, 444 customers have taken advantage of this program.

MLGW doesn’t disconnect service for certain groups of people, such as the elderly and those with physical disabilities, on days when the heat index reaches 95 degrees.

A C Wharton’s office has opened cooling centers across the city when the heat index has reached 105 degrees or if there is a great need. These centers, such as the Orange Mound Community Center, typically remain open until 8 p.m., when any high temperatures will have passed. This summer, the Memphis Area Transit Authority has provided transportation to the cooling centers for those who needed it.

In addition to all of these efforts, the fire department has also been going door-to-door when there is extreme heat to check on those in need. However, Cook says the responsibility to keep everyone safe falls on all Memphians.

“Conditions can change from one minute to the next. It is important to check on those who are most vulnerable, such as the elderly and children,” said Lt. Cook. “Staying indoors in an air-conditioned space for only two hours a day can make a difference.”

Categories
Letter From The Editor Opinion

Letter from the Editor: Split the Baby

I got several calls from Memphis Police and Fire Department employees this week. They were all angry about the proposed cuts and changes to their pension and health-care plans and wanted the Flyer to “tell the truth” about the situation.

The core truth is that the city — as mandated by the state — needs to find a way to pay down its pension obligations in five years. It can do this by cutting costs, raising revenues (taxes), or a combination of the two.

The proposal at hand would turn the current guaranteed pension plan for city employees into a 401k plan. It would also reduce benefits and/or raise the costs of health care for current employees and retirees.

The Memphis City Council majority is determined not to raise property taxes, come hell or high water, the stated rationale being that it will motivate people to leave Memphis. The 6,000 police and fire personnel and other city employees contend that they are being asked to carry the entire burden of fixing the budget mess for the rest of us.

The council has gotten support for its “no new taxes” position from the Memphis Area Chamber of Commerce (COC), which launched a campaign against any tax hike. A counter-campaign has sprung up, urging citizens not to patronize businesses that are COC members.

And speaking of hell and high water… one fireman I spoke to alluded to certain “measures” that could be taken to demonstrate how important his department is to the city. He was referencing the rumors that have been circulating for a week or so about a “sick-out” over the Fourth of July weekend.

A sick-out of fire and police personnel on a holiday weekend filled with fireworks and massive downtown crowds would be a PR disaster for both departments, in my opinion, and would only harden the views on both sides of the issue. Especially, if there were a fire or a crime that caused the loss of life due to a lack of response.

That said, taking away promised health benefits, especially from retirees on a fixed pension is just wrong. And remember, these employees don’t get Social Security, so their pension is it when it comes to supporting themselves in their old age.

I’m quite obviously not an expert in city finances, and Lord knows the city has spent enough on consultants and experts to cover my retirement quite nicely. But surely there is a baby to be split here somewhere. A small tax increase isn’t going to send people fleeing en masse. And the switch to a 401k plan isn’t going be the end of the world for city employees.

We need to keep and attract highly qualified police and fire department personnel. A fear of not being safe will send as many people fleeing the city as a tax increase will. It’s time to make a deal — before things get even hotter.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com

Categories
News The Fly-By

Memphis Police and Fire Consider Moving Offices

The Memphis Police Department (MPD) headquarters is “crowded and costly.” The Memphis Division of Fire Services headquarters has a nice river view and is “not the highest and best use of the property.” The two departments could cut costs for taxpayers by moving in together and sharing some back-office staffers. 

Toby Sells

Those ideas come from the city’s five-year strategic management plan published in January by the PFM Group consultants. The real estate ideas have come back into focus recently, as the Memphis City Council considers a deal to take over the Donnelly J. Hill State Office Building.

The building is worth about about $2.4 million, and the state would hand over its title to the city for the use of 400 parking spots in the Peabody Place garage for the next 15 years.

The city now has eight leases for office space around town. It pays about $3 million each year in rent to provide office space for about 460 employees. Real estate consultants have told councilmembers they could consolidate many of these offices into the Donnelly building on Civic Plaza, including the Memphis Housing Authority, Housing and Community Development, and Information Technology. 

But much of the conversation on the state building has at least touched on moving MPD. The department is now housed on three floors of the Shelby County Criminal Justice Complex, more commonly known as 201 Poplar. MPD moved there in 1982 but quickly outgrew it. Complaints about space constraints have come from former police directors James Bolden and Larry Godwin and current director Toney Armstrong.     

“Honestly, I think we have outgrown 201 Poplar,” Armstrong told councilmembers in budget discussions in 2012. “We have been able to grow at the uniform patrol level but not at the investigative level, simply because we don’t have the space for it.”

The cost to rent the currently cramped space is $1.4 million per year. That’s way too high, according to the consultant’s five-year plan. At the end of 2012, the average rate for Class A office space — the very best office space — in downtown Memphis was $16.75 per square foot, according to the city’s consultants. Taxpayers are leasing the MPD space in 201 Poplar for about $17.70 per square foot. 

The fire department has largely been left out of the recent conversations about office moves and consolidation, but the PFM report said its Front Street location is “not ideal” and is in “what could be a prime location for development.” 

The five-year plan said that Memphis police and fire should consolidate some of their office functions, and even communications, to save money. And, it said, sharing a physical location would help do just that.

But the Donnelley building wasn’t on the table in January when the five-year plan was published. Instead, the plan said the city should renovate the old police headquarters at 128 Adams, which has been vacant for the past 30 years. 

The renovation price tag of about $30 million puts the project out of reach, the city’s Chief Administrative Officer George Little has said in past budget discussions.

Consultants said the cost would be offset by eliminating rents in other places or could be paid from the sale of the fire department headquarters on Front Street. Or, the report, said 128 Adams could be sold to a private developer.

Categories
News News Blog

Memphis Firefighters Protest Equipment Cuts

Off-duty firefighters protest equipment cuts.

  • Off-duty firefighters protest equipment cuts.

About 15 off-duty Memphis firefighters gathered outside Fire Station 25 on Willow this morning to protest possible cuts in equipment, one of several items in the city budget proposal.

Most held bright red signs reading, “Your rescue truck is closing! You and your family are in danger!” If the city approves Memphis Fire Director Alvin Benson’s proposed budget cuts, the department could lose 111 jobs, 7 fire engines, 6 ladder trucks, and one rescue truck over the next three years. No ambulance cuts are proposed.

According to Memphis Fire Fighters Association president Larry Anthony, the cuts would bring the department back to 1972 staffing and equipment levels. Yet the city has annexed Cordova, Hickory Hill, Southwind, and Wolfchase since that time, and Anthony maintains that current staffing and equipment levels are necessary to ensure public safety.

In 2003, firefighters Trent Kirk and Charles Zachary died while fighting a Family Dollar store fire on Watkins Street. After the incident, the fire department director requested the city add two additional rescue trucks to its fleet of two. Only one was added, and now the city council is considering removing that extra truck from operation.

“These cuts will be devastating sooner or later,” Anthony said. “Someone will be hurt.”

The city council will vote on budget cuts next Tuesday.

Categories
Letter From The Editor Opinion

Letter from the Editor: Why Don’t You Try Me?

I’ve long believed that the reason no one keeps their New Year’s resolutions is because the new year happens in January — the dead of winter. The new year starts for me in early February, when the Memphis winter eases and spring bulbs send up tender shoots of green. On the first warm, sunny day, I’m ready to “get in shape,” so for the past few weeks, I’ve been jogging/walking around Midtown several days a week.

Last Saturday, I was striding purposefully along North Hawthorne Street with Ry Cooder’s “Why Don’t You Try Me” filling my ears, when a man walked out of his front door and waved me down. He was carrying two liter bottles of white wine in one hand, a lit cigarette and wine glass in the other. He said something, but I couldn’t hear him, so I pulled out my earbuds and said, “What?”

“Call 911,” he said. “Someone is committing arson in the back of my house.” He said this casually, as though he were saying, “I really like your running shoes.”

“Seriously?” I said.

“Yes,” he said, calmly, taking a drag. “They’re closing the windows and lighting things on fire. Oh, wait. I’ve got to go get my dog out.” He walked back up the sidewalk, opened the front door, and a confused-looking miniature Doberman pinscher skittered out. “Stay, Randall,” the man said.

I called 911, told the dispatcher what was happening, and within three minutes a couple of large fire trucks came roaring up, sirens blasting. At that point, I figured I’d done my civic duty and left. As one of my co-workers said later when I told him this tale: “It’s not every day you walk into a David Lynch movie.” Which is true.

But the incident did make me think about what firefighters and other emergency responders have to deal with on a daily basis. Those firefighters had no idea what they’d find when they entered that house. It could have been a blazing fire or Truman Capote seated in a La-Z-Boy with a gun — and they had to be ready to deal with either circumstance.

Federal, state, and local budgets are now being balanced on the backs of working people, while the Wall Street fund managers and corporations who precipated our current financial doldrums get huge bonuses and tax breaks. Who do you think should be sacrificing more? As far as I’m concerned, it shouldn’t be the people who teach our children, answer emergency calls, and put out our fires.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com