Categories
Opinion The Last Word

The Lies I Tell: The Election, My Niece, and Voter Suppression

Last week, I took my 6-year-old niece with me to early vote. As we walked into the polling place, hand in hand, I lied to her. I didn’t intend to. I just wanted to make the short walk from the parking lot to the building a quick lesson on voting rights.

What we’re about to do, I told her solemnly, is very, very important.

Slipping into the same voice I use to read bedtime stories, I began: A long, long time ago, there were people who fought really hard to keep people like us  —  Black people  —  from voting. But Black people and some white people worked really hard to make sure we could. To make those Black people proud, I said, we have to vote in every election. And, I added as a happily ever after, that’s why we were going to vote today.

Peter Pettus, Library of Congress

Participants in the civil rights march from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama, in 1965

No sooner had the words left my mouth when I realized I had not been honest. Why had I placed voter suppression in the distant past? Why did I feel compelled to leave out the violence, the blood spilled, the murders? Why did I obscure the villains, leaving them colorless as if their identities aren’t known?

The truth is this: Voter suppression, intimidation, and systemic disenfranchisement wasn’t long, long ago or in a place far away. It’s happening now, here, and all around.

Since the 2010 elections, 24 states have passed laws making it harder to vote, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. From shrinking the number of early voting locations, cutting back the early voting period, enacting strict voter ID laws, and purging infrequent voters from the rolls, Republican-led attacks against the franchise seem unrelenting.

Recently, the Memphis branch of the NAACP sued the Shelby County Election Commission after it limited early voting locations to the Agricenter, which is outside the city core and closer to parts of the county that are majority-white, even though Shelby County is predominantly Black.

The NAACP won its suit, but the commission still managed to open late a key early voting site in the city’s core. The commission blamed it on a miscommunication with poll workers, but it read as spiteful, as if election officials were thumbing their noses at voting rights advocates.

The NAACP and the Tennessee Black Voter Project have since sued the commission again, “for its refusal to allow voters who submitted timely, but allegedly deficient, voter registration applications to correct any deficiencies in those applications on or before Election Day and then vote regular ballots.” A judge ruled against the commission this week.

In Houston, Texas, there have been allegations that volunteer Korean translators were being kicked out of polling places. In Kansas, the lone polling place in the majority-Hispanic town of Dodge City has been moved into the county, a mile from the nearest bus stop.

Ever since the Supreme Court overturned parts of the Voting Rights Act in 2013, Southern states previously required to get federal okay before changing election laws rushed to make it harder for Black and brown people to vote.

“The decision in Shelby County opened the floodgates to laws restricting voting throughout the United States. The effects were immediate. Within 24 hours of the ruling, Texas announced that it would implement a strict photo ID law. Two other states, Mississippi and Alabama, also began to enforce photo ID laws that had previously been barred because of federal preclearance,” said the Brennan Center.

But I didn’t tell my niece about the Shelby County, Alabama v. Holder case that took the teeth out of the Voting Rights Act.

I didn’t tell her about Mississippi voting rights advocate and all-around badass Fannie Lou Hamer, an Indianola, Mississippi, tenant farmer who was fired by her plantation owner after she tried to register to vote in 1962. Undeterred, she opposed the state’s all-white delegation at the 1964 Democratic National Convention. Four years later, she was chosen as a delegate for the party’s presidential nominating committee in Chicago.

If I close my eyes, I can see the horrifying image of a battered John Lewis, beaten by a state trooper on Bloody Sunday in Selma, Alabama, in 1965 for the crime of being a Negro trying to register other Negroes to vote. I know the names of martyrs Andrew Goodman, Mickey Schwerner, James Chaney, Rev. James Reeb, and Viola Gregg Liuzzo, all slain because they sought voting rights for Black people in the South.

None of this brutal, gruesome, painful, wretched history did I share with my beautiful, cornrow-wearing, baby teeth-missing, still-needs-a-nap niece. These American stories are the stuff of Black nightmares. So I lied. I turned the fight for the ballot into a fairy tale, where in the end, the arc of the moral universe bends toward justice. And while I hope that comes to pass, I’m not sure that’s true either.

I’m not proud of my lie. I was simply trying to shield my niece from what she’ll see soon enough: That the mean people who didn’t want Black people to vote then are still with us now.

Wendi C. Thomas is the editor and publisher of MLK50: Justice Through Journalism, where a version of this column first appeared.

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

What They Said… (July 30, 2015)

Greg Cravens

About Tim Sampson’s The Last Word column, “Trumped” …

After Trump wins the Iowa caucus and the New Hampshire primary, I expect to see Trump step up on the stage and tell his adoring conservative fans, “Bitches, you just got punk’d!!” And then Ashton Kutcher jumps out from behind the curtain.

Charley Eppes

Trump is a hero. He is the living embodiment of the Republican id. Unrestrained by the need to court the votes of the squishy middle, he is free to pull back the bed sheet and reveal the raging Rotary club president within. He is what the Republican Party would be if we didn’t have elections.

Jeff

About Chris Davis’ cover story, “Rockin’ the Halls” …

Thank you for last week’s story about the Memphis Music Hall of Fame, and especially for the focus on the artistry of Jim Dickinson. Of course, in Memphis, museums love to exhibit musicians’ rhinestone jumpsuits or stage costumes. Dickinson’s musical genius was that he helped develop so many of those superstars from studios like Ardent and Zebra Ranch. We’re proud to be able to display an expression of Jim’s artistry in that piano.

I made an insensitive mistake in last week’s article, referring to that piano as “Jim’s soul,” and I apologize to his great family. As a fellow Christian, while I love the awesomely creative expression of that piano, I understand that his soul, through grace, is both huge and eternal, a testament to his great slogan, “I’m just dead, I’m not gone.”

John Doyle, Memphis Music Hall of Fame

About Alexandra Pusateri’s post, “TBI Investigating Darrius Stewart Case” …

Who trusts the TBI or D.A. to investigate this? They need the police to produce evidence that keeps the jails full. Who is going to bite the hand that feeds them? I am so outraged, as a U.S. citizen, by the mentality of the police and their supporters. Police can kill without recourse.

Memphis Belle

I am enjoying watching our local media fan the flames and totally try to have this story blow up into something much more than it actually is. Memphis TV media: It’s just not going to happen here. Sorry.

Midtown Mark

I’m also enjoying reading some of the comments being posted on those local media articles. The local racists are so mad that black people aren’t rioting and protesting over this.

Nobody

I’m enjoying all the wanton police violence sweeping the country. Isn’t this just great? People are dying for systemic reasons we could fix but refuse to address, because it makes us feel icky. Wait, this actually sucks, because it could happen to anyone. Now it doesn’t seem so funny anymore.

Autoegocrat

About Wendi C. Thomas’ column, “Black Wealth Matters” …

Black wealth does matter. If things were reversed and blacks were the minority in numbers but majority holders of wealth in Memphis, the sentiment on the Caucasian side of this issue would be very different.

TruthBeTold

It is important that “black-owned businesses” are actually owned by black people and not just a front man or woman and that the employee ranks have actual black workers whose wages form the actual foundation of community.

Nick R.

About Bianca Phillips’ post, “MPD Does Not Have Passenger Policy for Traffic Stops” …

There is always a problem when any authority exceeds its constitutional limits, be it the MPD or anybody else. If it is unconstitutional for the police to demand ID on a passenger when the police are merely enforcing traffic laws, they do not have the right to go ahead and do it anyway.

If I am walking down the street minding my own business and the police stop me and ask me to show ID, I will not do so unless they can show some probable cause as to why I should comply. None of which gives Darrius Stewart cause to run and then fight with that policeman.

Arlington Pop

Categories
News News Feature

Black Wealth Matters

African Americans make up 63 percent of Memphis’ population. The Memphis metro area is the poorest large metro area in the nation. You don’t get rich working for someone else, or so the saying goes. Connect those three points and you have a straight line between the success of local African-American entrepreneurs and the city’s financial future.

If nearly two-thirds of Memphis is shut out of the city’s economic growth, the city will always be burdened by the problems that follow poverty. Here’s where the Economic Development Growth Engine for Memphis and Shelby County (EDGE) could make difference, although I’m not optimistic. Next month, the EDGE board will vote on new policies, including diversity spending requirements for companies that receive PILOTs, the tax breaks and incentives used to lure new businesses and jobs to town.

Right now, companies are asked to make a best-faith effort to spend 25 percent of construction and controllable spending with minority- and women-owned business enterprises (MWBEs) and locally owned small businesses (LOSBs). The new guidelines would go from a “try-your-best” model to an “or-else” requirement of a 15-percent MWBE/LOSB spend in all categories. Companies that don’t comply could have to pay back some of the tax breaks. But the change won’t translate into additional dollars for MWBEs or LOSBs, which makes it feel more like window dressing than a substantial revision.

Since 2011, EDGE has secured nearly $2 billion in projected investments. About 14 percent ($292 million) of that will go to MWBEs and LOSBs. Fourteen percent. In a city that’s 63 percent black and 50 percent female. But if you ask EDGE’s CEO Reid Dulberger how many millions went to African-American businesses, he can’t tell you, because he doesn’t know.

EDGE doesn’t know because it lumps minority-owned, women-owned businesses, and locally owned small businesses into the same pile. This failure (refusal?) to calculate how PILOTs affect black-owned businesses is inexplicable. We measure what matters. Does building black wealth matter much to EDGE, local government, the Chamber of Commerce, or any other agencies with a vested interest in the city’s financial future?

After white men complained that Shelby County’s race/gender-conscious contracting program was biased against white men, the county switched to a program for locally owned businesses, defined as those with annual sales under $5 million.

To understand how thoroughly people of color are shut out economically, look at data measured by the city of Memphis. Although white men make up around 18 percent of Memphis’ population, their businesses received nearly two-thirds of city municipal contracts.

Those most likely to dismiss the racial disparity are also those who profit most. “Blacks are enjoined to get over it, to stop playing the victim role, take personal responsibility,” said Darrick Hamilton, associate professor of economics and urban policy at the New School. But diligence and hard work doesn’t translate into wealth for families of color, Hamilton said last week during a webinar on racial wealth inequality sponsored by the Ford Foundation and the Federal Reserve System.

Among the alarming figures he shared from 2011 federal data: An unemployed white head of household had nearly twice as much net wealth ($21,892) as a black head of household working full time ($11,649). Households headed by white high school dropouts had more wealth ($34,700) than households headed by black college graduates ($23,400). Low-income white families had more household wealth ($60,000) than middle-income black families ($42,800).

“The source of the racial wealth gap is that some individuals have access to some seed money so that they can purchase an asset that will appreciate over their lifetime when they are young adults,” Hamilton said.

It would be easy to blame the gap on black people’s bad choices, said William Darity of Duke University, but there’s no evidence to support that theory.

“These historical and existing structural factors mean that individuals who are engaged in trying to do the right thing are actually overwhelmed by the constraints that they’re confronted with,” Darity said.

Those factors are, in short, rooted in racism — a subject that ruffles feathers for black and white people, although for different reasons. But if EDGE, local politicians, and civic leaders want something we’ve never had — economic parity — they have to do something they’ve never done. We could start by measuring what matters, unless it doesn’t really matter.

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

What They Said (June 18, 2015) …

Greg Cravens

About Randy Haspel’s column announcing his candidacy for the GOP nomination, “Ask Not” …

Politics is nice, Haspel, but we need to bring back the Sunday church crowds. A mandatory .50-caliber machine gun in every pulpit! A 144-inch plasma screen direct link to NFL in place of the Baptist baptismal. Actual crucifixions in place of crucifixes! I’d go for that.

Crackoamerican

We’re inching ever closer to the Haspel/Jindal dream ticket our little group has been discussing at Smitty’s psilocybin-fueled rap sessions.

Dave Clancy

About Toby Sells’ story, “MLGW’s Smart Meter Program to Get Vote” …

Why do they want to buy a million meters if they state they have 421,000 customers?

This must have been a decision made by the “smart meter team.”

Deborah Scott

Deborah, it’s the Costco effect.

Mia S. Kite

Egads! I have a “weaponized weapon” on the back of my house, right outside my daughter’s room? What was I thinking?

Oh yeah, I want to be able to better monitor my electric usage and make changes in our habits that result in less demand to burn fossil fuels — and lower my contribution to climate change. Silly me.

Scott Banbury

About Wendi C. Thomas’ column, “Black Lives Matter” …

I think Wendi missed the whole root of the problem she’s trying to solve. The biggest problem is the destruction of the family unit. I would be interested to see a study on youth crime, the types of crime, and the severity of the crime. Also add in youth education outcomes.

Then compare those to the family structure of the child. Is it a single parent household? Is the child being raised by a grandparent? How many children are in the household? I’d be willing to bet you see some positive correlations between the household structure and positive outcomes for the child.

I believe the single most important issue is that of the family. One of the primary reasons gangs exist is because youth don’t have male role models around, so they turn to older male youths who organize in a Lord of the Flies manner and show some form of love and structure.

Please, Wendi, do an article on the topic of family structure and influence, and what can be done to change the culture that’s essentially eschewed the classic family structure.

GroveReb84

Reb, how about making sure that those males have jobs that will allow them to provide for their families and keep those units together?

LeftWingCracker

Great example of an external locus of control. The belief that all the ills of the community are related to outside factors — white people, the police, the laws on the books, etc. Until the community grapples with the problem that many of these issues are internal, no change will be accomplished.

apok

About Bruce VanWyngarden’s Letter From the Editor, “A Bridge Too Far” …

Nice how TDOT lied about consulting with Crittenden County, the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department, and residents in West Memphis that will be greatly affected by the stupid traffic circle that will be a massive cluster flock.

Facebook Hater

Knoxville went through something similar a few years ago: SmartFix40. They shut down I-40 in downtown Knoxville to speed up the construction schedule. It worked. In fact, the construction company finished early to get a bonus. The sky is not falling.

Michael Shoenberger

A roundabout is designed to take the place of a four-way-stop intersection, eliminating the need to turn through oncoming traffic. In this location, a roundabout would create more of a traffic jam than the current cloverleaf ramp system, where you do not have to cross against oncoming traffic. This is the most idiotic idea I have ever heard.

Ncrdb1

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

What They Said (June 4, 2015) …

Greg Cravens

About Toby Sells’ story, “‘Old Bridge’ Could Close for Up to Nine Months” …

Cue the Benny Hill theme music.

CL Mullins

I am curious to see how tractor-trailer drivers moving westbound on Crump toward the bridge will feel about having to navigate a roundabout to access I-55 northbound. That should be fun.

Leftwing Cracker

Now that is scary-looking, even with no traffic around! Truckers are experienced drivers, but most Memphians are not familiar with roundabouts. You should see the people driving straight across the one by Target and PetSmart out at Poplar and I-240!

Linda

Memphis drivers can’t deal with straight roads of more than one lane. Give them two lanes and they will inevitably end up in the wrong one to make their turn, at which point they will stop both or more lanes of traffic or just endanger the lives of everyone by making their turn anyway, traffic be damned. And if a road happens not to have enough lanes to suit their purposes, they make their own.

Watching the roundabout on TDOT cameras should prove to be an entertaining pastime.

Jeff

About Tim Sampson’s last Rant …

Say it ain’t so! Please don’t reduce The Rant to once a month. It is the only thing worth reading in your paper. Tim Sampson and Randy Haspel are brilliant comics who help to expose the brain-dead beliefs of right-wing crazies and the coming takeover of America by the Koch brothers and other power-mad Republican scum. Remember, just because you’re paranoid, doesn’t mean the Republicans are not out to get you!

Russell Pryor

Editor’s Note: Tim and Randy will each write once a month in our new “Last Word” column. They will be joined on alternate weeks by Jen Clarke and Susan Wilson. Clarke’s first column debuts in this issue.

About Wendi C. Thomas’ Truth Be Told column, “Good Moves” …

If these young ladies survive the gauntlet that society has set up for their youth, they should make deadly competition for their more affluent age-group members. If they’re on a level field of competition.

JR Golden

About Bianca Phillips’ story “Bus Riders Union Asks for Improvements to North Terminal” …

As a user of the North End Terminal for my daily commute, I agree it could use some improvements. I have never used the restrooms, but the waiting areas are filthy, with litter especially evident outside. I once observed a bus driver toss litter from their window onto the pickup area.

There is rampant cigarette smoking in the parking lot and the seating areas, often directly under the “No Smoking” signs. As for the security guards, I have seen only exemplary treatment of riders by them. Yes, they bark at people walking in the bus lanes, but that makes perfect sense to me from a safety standpoint.

Some riders are not great examples of humanity, but most riders I interact with are friendly and polite. That goes for most of the drivers and other staff. Given the time constraints drivers operate under, especially when dealing with less-than-considerate riders and unpredictable traffic, I am generally impressed with their professionalism.

Hodag

About the ongoing battle over the Greensward in Overton Park …

I was at the Memphis Zoo on Memorial Day. The Greensward (aka, a huge field of weeds) area used by the zoo had not one soul enjoying this precious piece of future parking. This is an absolute joke. The leftists hate that people drive and park to see caged animals. They should be honest about what’s really eating them.

Ohknow

Ohknow, your hatred for things green and your love of all things caged is so over-the-top stereotypical as to be suspicious. What is your real agenda, comrade?

Mia S. Kite

Categories
Cover Feature News

Cuba, Si!

HAVANA — It’s difficult to pinpoint the exact moment when I fell in love with this place. Was it when I zip-lined over the treetops at a coffee plantation that had been turned into a national park? Or when, drenched in sweat, I struggled valiantly to keep pace with a salsa teacher’s swiveling hips and quick feet?

It could have been during a visit to the Museo Nacional de la Campaña Alfabetización, a tribute to the successful 1961 literacy campaign. Or perhaps it was the Cuban coffee at every meal — and in the evenings, the smoothest rum I’ve ever tasted.

The Museo Nacional de la Campana Alfabetización, the national literacy museum

Just a few days into a weeklong trip, I swore to myself that I would be back. I was in one of the first Memphis groups to visit Cuba after the December 17th announcement by President Obama that U.S.-Cuban diplomatic relations would resume for the first time in more than 50 years.

Travelers enjoying a cigar

In March, the University of Memphis’ study abroad program sent just over a dozen students and community members to Havana. Dennis Laumann, an associate professor of African history, led the group, many of whom were enrolled in his Afro-Cuban history class.

The December announcement meant that we could bring back up to $100 worth of Cuban cigars and rum, souvenirs that were previously forbidden by U.S. restrictions.

A Flamenco dancer

If you’ve traveled to other Latin American or Caribbean countries, Havana will feel familiar. There’s the warm weather, the rain showers that last only moments, the pastel-painted buildings, and supper-time staples of rice and beans.

But when the world’s richest nation forces a smaller, developing one into an economic corner for decades, the poorer nation struggles to thrive. Proof of the struggle surfaces in the crumbling facades of once-beautiful homes and the scarcity of retail outlets where you could practice consumerism and capitalism.

For me, and I suspect, most generations that have no memory of the 1962 Cuban missile crisis or the Cold War, the U.S. isolationist strategy served mostly to create a mystique about the island.

Forbidden fruit always tastes sweeter. And Cuba was delicious.

Here are some highlights from the trip:

The Cars

If you close your eyes and think of Cuba, chances are your mind will produce an image of a 1950s-era, hulking American sedan. Rows of cars just like that greeted us in the parking lot at José Martí International Airport.

A 1950s-era car in pristine condition

Although they may appear to be in mint condition, the only original part is the body, said Rodrigo González, the Cuban program coordinator for Girasol Study Abroad. The cars are “museums on wheels,” he said, and the owners must be magicians to keep them running.

Antique cars shared the roads with Korean-made Kias and boxy Lada sedans, Russia’s version of the Volvo. Many of the cars double as taxis, although they may not be marked as such.

Our taxi driver, Hendry Lago

For about $5 Cuban convertible pesos (the dollar exchange rate is about 1:1), Hendry Lago transported two fellow study abroad travelers and me from Old Havana to our hotel in a gleaming, candy apple red 1955 Chevy.

The seats were covered in pristine white and gray leather and the chrome trim sparkled like the car just pulled off the lot. But on the dash was a very modern touchscreen sound system and under the dash, an air conditioner strong enough to fight Havana heat.

Lago looked like he stepped off the set of Grease with his slicked-back hair and snug jeans. He took the scenic route, cruising down the Malecón, the road that curves along the coast. As he drove, Meredith Kaback pulled a tube of red lipstick from her purse.

The occasion called for it, she said, passing the lipstick to me. I agreed.

The wind was in our hair, the sun warmed our skin, and our lips matched the car. I was smitten.

Cigars

Our tour included a trip to a cigar factory. From the street, the H. Upmann cigar factory, founded by Germans in 1844, was indistinguishable from surrounding buildings.

Our tour guide, Idalmy, told us in her no-nonsense tone: No cameras, phones, or bags were allowed inside. We must stay together — no wandering off (as some of us were prone to do).

Once inside, the cigar factory guide led us up a flight of stairs. He steered us into a long room lined with rows of desks. Bent over the desks were men (and a few women) with stacks of flattened tobacco leaves in front of them. Many of the workers wore ear buds to listen to music on their cell phones. To help pass the time, the factory hired someone to read the newspaper to the cigar makers, the guide said.

The most experienced rollers make the bigger cigars, laying leaves on top of each other and sealing them together with a vegetable-based glue.

In another room, women sat with piles of dampened leaves. With one fluid motion, they stripped the stem from the middle of the wide leaves. No men would want to do this work, our guide told us. This job was for women only. (This was said with no awareness that his remark was sexist.)

In Cuba, cigar factories are state-run. Between 10 to 20 percent of the profit goes to the farmer and the rest goes to the government. No cigars were sold inside the factory, but an overcrowded, small store nearby offered Cuban rum, coffee, and several kinds of cigars, including the Cohiba and Montecristo brands.

The other tourists were surprisingly aggressive, shoving other shoppers out of the way, but I put my Memphis on and muscled my way to the counter.

Cuisine

If there was one disappointment, this was it. With rare exceptions, the food was mediocre.

Breakfast at Hotel Paseo Habana was your standard fruit, fruit juice, eggs, and toast. I followed the advice from TripAdvisor reviewers and ordered French toast, which was tasty the first morning, but not so much after that. Ask for syrup and you got a crystalized pat of honey.

One standout: Doña Juana, a paladar (privately owned, not state-run restaurant) on the top floor of a home in the Vedado neighborhood.

Half of the study abroad group walked there one night, where we had the terrace to ourselves. The menu was in English and Spanish. The server was pleasant and patient as he took our orders.

If you want to impress people on the cheap, this was the place to go.

When the server showed up with shots of Havana Club rum for everyone, I waved him away, thinking he’d brought the drinks to the wrong table.

One of the community members in our group announced that he’d ordered the liquor for us and we all cheered. I thought to myself: He must be rich. Then I looked at the menu again: Seven shots set him back about $7.

For $20, you could get a perfectly cooked lobster dinner with generous portions of rice, black beans, and salad.

Also worth trying: the Las Terrazas coffee at the former coffee plantation (now national park and biosphere reserve) that bears the same name. This small cup of coffee, cacao liquor, milk, and ice was chocolate happiness.

Art

Callejón de Hamel is a short alley devoted to Afro-Cuban culture, art, and music in the Havana Centra neighborhood. Much of the art is made of found objects, such as the old bathtubs cemented into walls. On the bottom of the tubs were poems, which were often political in nature.

Found-object art in the alley of the Callejón de Hamel, which showcases the Afro-Cuban culture.

“Grandma, why do the towns fight?” began one poem of a conversation between an elder and a child. “For love and respect.” 

“And the powerful?”

“For gold and leisure.”

On top of a building that overlooked the alley were two water tanks, one labeled “Agua Blanca” and the other “Agua Negra.” It was a social commentary on the absurdity of racism, which several Cubans proudly claimed no longer exists in their country.

The revolution did bring a formal end to segregation, but scholars we talked to acknowledge that the stains of racism remain. They point out that the faces tourists see are more likely to be white. And since most of the Cubans who fled for Miami are also white, it is their relatives who benefit from remittances sent from the states.

In the Jaimanitas neighborhood, artist José Fuster had turned his community into a wondrous, tile-covered paradise. Although Fuster was out of town, we had lunch in his dining room and spent about an hour marveling at the fanciful sculptures he’s created in his courtyard and along the walls that line sidewalks.

His painting style has earned him the title “Picasso of the Caribbean.” Less than a block from his house, he erected a tile rendering of Hugo Chávez, superimposed over the Cuban and Venezuelan flags.

History

When I asked fellow travelers what their favorite part of the trip was, I expected them to gush over the old cars or maybe the tour of the coffee plantation, where we saw the stone outlines of slave quarters and some of us went zip-lining. But without exception, they were most impressed by the Museo Nacional de la Campaña Alfabetización, the national literacy museum.

The small one-story building holds artifacts associated with the 1961 literacy campaign. In a 1960 speech to the United Nations, Fidel Castro declared that Cuba would be the first nation that “will be able to say it does not have a single illiterate person.”

The next year, more than 250,000 literacy tutors, at least 105,000 of whom were between the ages of 9 and 16, went from cities to rural areas, living and working alongside the farmers during the day and, at night, teaching them to read.

Caricature art showing the animosity between Cuba and the U.S. in the Rincon de las Cretinos.

In a single year, museum director Luisa Campos told us, the illiteracy rate fell from 23 percent to under 4 percent. (The adult illiteracy rate in Cuba today is less than .2 percent, compared to 14 percent in the United States).

Campos asked Nafal Valdes, the quiet, unassuming bus driver who shuttled us around town, to come to the front of the museum classroom.

volunteer

Valdes, Campos told us, had been one of the literacy volunteers. She opened a thick, yellow register book to the page with a tiny black-and-white photo of Valdes at 16.

As we stood and applauded, Valdes wiped away tears.

“When you look at any society, it’s what that society places value in that really defines it,” said Luther Mercer, the managing director of programs for New Leaders, a national nonprofit that develops school leadership.

There are no interactive exhibits at the literacy museum or at the Museo de la Revolución, housed in the stately presidential palace last occupied by ousted Cuban dictator Fulgencio Batista. Instead you’ll find stunning architecture, elaborate murals, and stone tributes to beloved revolutionaries Castro, Ché Guevara, and Camilo Cienfuegos.

A first-floor museum hallway held the only blunt testament to the animosity between Cuba and the United States I saw. In the Rincon de las Cretinos (the corner of cretins), were caricatures of Batista and U.S. Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H. W. Bush, and George W. Bush. The denouncements are in English, Spanish, and French.

“Thank you, cretin,” reads the placard next to W’s caricature, “for helping us to make socialim [sic] irrevocable.”

The enmity doesn’t extend to Cubans, who were, without exception, warm and friendly.

Our group spent a lot of time talking with members of Proyecto Espiral, a grassroots community project committed to sustainable development led by young adults.

“They were all very proud of who they were as Cubans,” Mercer said.

And yes, we could talk to whomever we wanted, about whatever we wanted. Before I went to Cuba, I’d been warned to look out for “watchers” who would eavesdrop on our conversations, listening for anti-socialist musings.

Before graduating senior Aukina Brown left on the trip, her friends were full of baseless warnings. “They said our plane would disappear; Fidel Castro wouldn’t let us come back — all kinds of stupid stuff,” Brown said.

But I never had the sense that we were being watched. Most police don’t even carry guns. We walked for blocks and blocks at night and barely generated a catcall.

Granted, the window A/C units at the hotel were loud and the towels scratchy. We had no access to the internet — and I didn’t miss it a bit.

It is hard to remember to throw toilet paper in the trash, not into aging septic systems. Paying the bathroom attendant to get a few squares of toilet paper got old.

“Don’t compare everything to America when you’re there,” Brown said. “Americans can be very nit-picky. … You can’t go with a closed mind and get everything out of it.”

beautiful architecture

If you travel for adventure and to make memories, you will enjoy Cuba.

And now is the time to go, before the country is affected (infected?) with all that the United States has to offer.

Gonzalez, one of our tour guides, said we were lucky to come when we did. “You’re in a historical moment. Until now, most of the Americans have been good Americans,” he said, only half-joking. “But soon, we will get tourists that would have gone to Cancun.”

Those tourists might demand the amenities they’d find on other islands, which could ruin what makes Cuba special.

“I just don’t want Cuba to become Jamaica,” Mercer said. “I don’t want to see Treasure Island down there. I don’t want to see Atlantis Resort. I don’t want to see a McDonald’s on the corner. I’d like to see this place keep its cultural identity and its sense of self and give what it has to offer to the world.”

Categories
News News Feature

Deciphering the District Attorney’s Math

Last year, the Shelby County District Attorney’a office touched 153,000 cases. That’s more cases than there are people in Bartlett, Germantown, and Collierville combined.

That number is terrifying — and misleading. (More on that later.)

But it serves to conjure up notions of imminent danger, and I suspect that’s why District Attorney Amy Weirich dropped that figure two weeks ago in Nashville, when she pressed a Senate committee to kill the “75 percent” rule.

The 75 percent rule says that whatever public funding the DA’s office receives, the public defender must also get three-fourths of that amount.

There’s no corollary: If the Shelby County Commission gives the public defender $10,000, Weirich complained, it doesn’t have to give the DA a dime.

Weirich argued that each office should seek funding independently. In a just world, that makes sense. But the criminal justice system is weighted toward the prosecution, which has powers public defenders don’t. At the prosecutor’s service are police and sheriff’s departments, and state investigators who collect evidence, and experts ready to give testimony.

The public defenders must rely on the veracity of those reports, prosecutors’ integrity, and the investigators and experts it can afford. The 75 percent rule is essential to leveling the playing field and protecting the indigent’s constitutional right to effective counsel.

Although the rule has been in effect for decades, it hasn’t been enforced. According to a 2011 report by the Tennessee Administrative Office of Courts, public defenders get 60 percent of state funding. Previous attempts to kill the 75 percent rule failed, and the most recent bill was shipped to a summer study committee.

In the meantime, Senator Randy McNally (R-Oak Ridge) has come up with a budget amendment that would gut funding for public defenders.

“If a local government provides a funding increase or supplement to the office of the public defender in the judicial district,” the amendment reads, “the appropriation made by the provisions of this act to the local government or District Public Defenders Conference for the office of the public defender in that district is reduced by the amount of the local funding.”

In English: If the county commission gave the local public defender’s office an additional $100, the state would decrease by $100 the amount of state funding for that public defender’s office. This would freeze the public defender’s budget, punish indigent clients, and boost the advantage district attorneys already enjoy.

McNally could not be reached to explain the problem his amendment solves. But the amendment is consistent with conservatives’ narrative about the poor, whose deprivation is the result of their own failings. If the poor stand accused of a crime, it’s because they’re guilty.

To right-wingers, the volumes of evidence showing racial disparities in arrest rates, conviction rates, and sentences are figments of liberals’ imaginations.

Another reason to wreck public defenders’ offices lies in prison privatization. How do you maintain a steady supply of people to fill Tennessee’s for-profit prisons?

The government can make new crimes out of previously legal behavior, manufacture a phony war on drugs, set mandatory minimum sentences, and hyper-police communities of color. Now we have another way: Bankrupt public defenders.

But let’s get back to the numbers. According to records, Weirich’s office handled 157,576 new cases in 2014. The number of cases doesn’t appear to be artificially inflated. For example, a suspect charged in connection with 14 separate robberies would count as a single case.

Of those 157,576 cases, 22 percent were traffic citations, 28 percent were misdemeanor citations, and 43 percent were misdemeanor defendants.

That means around seven percent were felony defendants accused of serious crimes like rape and murder. Suddenly, the numbers aren’t so scary.

Add to that the state Supreme Court’s recent rebukes of Weirich’s office and the reversal of two convictions, including last week’s overturned guilty verdict of accused rapist Frederick Herron, and the DA’s complaints seem less relevant.

If the legislature eliminates the checks and balances for the indigent accused, that should be a crime.

Categories
News News Feature

Selma Bound

On Sunday, thousands will descend upon Selma, Alabama, to remember the bloody Sunday 50 years ago when white state troopers attacked peaceful marchers who sought voting rights for black citizens.

Memphians Rychetta Watkins and Joy Turner will be among those retracing the demonstrators’ steps across the Edmund Pettus Bridge, the site of the attack. With them will be 500 fellow members of Girl Trek, a three-year-old national nonprofit that helps black women live healthier lives, primarily through local walking groups.

During the #Selma50 events, speakers will no doubt expound upon the marchers’ determination and the subsequent 1965 Voting Rights Act (since gutted by the conservative faction of the Supreme Court). But without the physical capacity to walk, to put one foot in front of the other, to advance steadily despite the blasts of fire hoses, tear gas, police dogs, and even bullets, the movement would not move.

Without the act of walking, history would be stripped of the Montgomery bus boycotts, the Bloody Sunday march, the 1963 March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, and even parts of the Underground Railroad.

“So much of what the activists did was centered around walking … and claiming their right to public spaces,” said Watkins, a program development consultant. “The Girl Trek story is about understanding our history and understanding that our strength begins with our physical health.”

Both women take inspiration from one of Girl Trek’s heroes, Mississippi voting rights activist and sharecropper Fannie Lou Hamer.

Her most famous quote, “I’m sick and tired of being sick and tired,” spoke to the frustration that accompanied black Americans’ attempts to gain the franchise.

But Hamer’s words could also have a more literal interpretation. A video of her 1964 testimony before a Democratic National Convention’s committee shows an overweight Hamer who gets stuck between two tables as she leaves the room. She can be seen breathing heavily as a man rushes up to move a table so she can pass by.

Hamer was just 59 when she died. I wonder if she would have lived longer if her existence as a black woman had not been endured, as author Zora Neale Hurston described in her novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, as the mule of the world.

Science has now proven what we could only intuit during the movement’s early years: Chronic stress makes you sick, increasing your risk of weight gain, depression, and heart disease. It’s no surprise that black women, subject to the double whammy of racism and sexism, are more likely to be obese, to have diabetes, heart disease, and to die earlier than white women from those diseases.

For Watkins, the intersection of human rights and health reminds her of the days when she was first learning West African dance. She asked her teacher: What do I have to do to be good at this?

The answer: You have to be strong.

“That resonates on so many levels,” Watkins said. “We get trapped in this stereotype of a strong black woman in only an emotional sense. Too often we think it’s a virtue to sacrifice our physical health to take care of our families and our communities.”

Black women are strong because we have to be, Watkins said, but we can be smarter about how we fortify ourselves. “It starts with honoring your body,” Watkins said. “That is what enables you to do all the rest.”

Turner sees the Girl Trek trip as an opportunity to recommit to better health and voting in all elections, not just presidential ones. She was struck by the police brutality toward would-be black voters as captured in the riveting historical movie Selma.

“I don’t think I would be strong enough to be out there walking arm in arm, getting beat in the face,” said Turner, a grant and contract administrator for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.

But she does have the strength to get on the bus and head to Selma. Said Watkins: “The journey continues for full equality for all Americans. The journey to make sure this country lives out the truth of its creed is by no means done.”

To mark the distance of the 1965 march from Selma, Alabama, to the state capitol in Montgomery, Girl Trek members are encouraged to pledge to walk 54 miles during the month of March. To learn more, go to girltrek.org.

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

What They Said (February 26, 2015) …

Greg Cravens

About Chris Davis’ webpost, “Ole Miss Student Gored by Spanish Bull” …

Ole Miss student: “How can we top UT’s Butt-Chugging event?” Mr. Milley: “Watch This!”

Charley Eppes

With all due respect to Mr. Milley, I’d rather grow old telling my grandkids about the time I survived a goring by a raging bull in Spain, as opposed to hearing bumblin’ Joe Biden publicly refer to me as his “old butt buddy” and having to explain that gaffe for the rest of my life.

Mr. Milley, it could be worse, a lot worse. Glad you lived to tell the tale, sir.

Nightcrawler

I agree, Nightcrawler. That young man should definitely blame Obama for this. Especially when he gets home and has honest American doctor bills, unlike the time he will spend in Spain being treated with godless free socialized medicine.

Jeff

About Wendi C. Thomas’ column, “Good Jobs Lost” …

I feel bad for this lady, but there’s a question that I kept asking myself while reading this article that wasn’t addressed. Why is she still living in Memphis if she can’t find a job here with her high skill set?

If I were to lose my job here, it’s possible I couldn’t find another locally because my skills are specialized. But I’m pretty sure I could find a similar job elsewhere if I were willing to move. There are reasons I probably wouldn’t move, but they have nothing to do with economics or the disappearance of middle-class jobs.

Brunetto Latini

The medical field is as hot as a firecracker right now. Did I read correctly she is both experienced and degreed and can’t find a job, so she hasn’t worked in the field in nine years? I would like to know the rest of the story.

Arlington Pop

Has anyone looked into the cost of relocating, especially with children in school close to graduating? With the constant cuts to NIH funding, there are not as many jobs available anywhere for people with this skill set. Age discrimination is also a factor once you pass age 45, so for those of you in that age group, be prepared.

Been There

All of Wendi’s columns should be turned into epic novels so she can answer any possible question a grumpy old man could dream up. They obviously are incapable of making assumptions based on reason and need Wendi to spoon feed them the answers to every scenario.

Nobody

About Joe Boone’s cover story, “All About That Uptown Funk” …

What an inspiring story about great people doing great, creative things in Memphis. Thanks for giving us the story behind the hit.

Leelo

Nice article supporting Memphis art. However, if you really want to support Memphis arts and artists, you should know (and care enough) to give credit to the artist who painted that fabulous door you so proudly sport on your cover. It would have been nice to have mentioned one of Memphis’ true art treasures, Lamar Sorrento, who is known (and collected) by art lovers worldwide and also a darn good musician. Friends of Lamar say, “Not Cool.”

Fontaine

About Toby Sells’ story, “Council Gets First Look at MATA Trolley Plan” …

It is critical for the small business owners on Main Street that a viable transportation option is in place AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. The cold/rainy weather makes foot traffic draw to a stand-still, so without some alternative, we all stand to lose.

Main Street Business Owner

Councilmembers Flinn and Collins don’t sound serious about one of the top tourist attractions Memphis has. They don’t think an enormous amount of money should be spent to rectify a problem or reinvest into the system? That’s the problem that caused the issue to begin with. Memphis has to get leaders serious about upgrading this system and even replacing the aged trolleys with modern LRVs like you see in the new Atlanta Streetcar project that just opened. Until we get that kind of leadership on council, we’ll be a second-rate city.

TNC2

Categories
Letters To The Editor Opinion

What They Said (February 12, 2015) …

Greg Cravens

About Jackson Baker’s post, “Haslam’s Medicaid Expansion Bill “Hanging by a Thread” …

Kelsey is a fool, a traitor, and a moron! The trifecta, as it were.

Tennessee Waltzer

The majority of people opposed to Insure Tennessee are the Tea Partiers in our legislature. Most Tennesseeans favor the program. And Brian Kelsey should hang his head in shame for being part of the taxpayer-funded state health insurance program while denying the same to the working poor of Tennessee.

Jenna Sais Quoi

It’s dangerous having someone with Kelsey’s mindset — more loyal to his narrow ideology than to the well-being of the people of Tennessee.

Concerned in Shelby County

We have someone as president who is 100 times more dangerous with his own narrow ideology and use of executive orders to bypass Congress.

Firefox

You couldn’t be talking about the current president, who has signed fewer executive orders than all presidents since Grover Cleveland and uses Republican ideas like the ACA.

Concerned in Shelby County

I’ll just put this here: “Six of seven senators who shot down Insure Tennessee have state health care.” Hint: three of them are in this article, and the fourth one is our local idiot.

Charley Eppes

About Chris Davis’ Viewpoint, “‘Night, Darlin'” …

Poetic touching tribute. You paint a picture of a moment that many of us shared in our own way. Thanks for a beautiful private look into the way a kind soul can make a difference in many lives. Larger than life. Thank God.

Peter Ceren

To be inside the P&H after last call and the doors were locked was a cross between a return to the womb and breakfast at Valhalla.

CL Mullins

About Wendi C. Thomas’ column, “Thanks, Obama!”

I’m a Democrat who pays the Halls tax and federal taxes. Insuring others keeps my own personal health care less expensive because I’m not paying for anyone else’s unpaid bills.

I also have a pre-existing medical condition that prevented me from ever getting health care outside of an employer. Without insurance, I would be spending upwards of $15,000 a year staying alive and healthy. Since the health-care exchange opened, I have had a peace of mind that I have never enjoyed before in my adult life, because I have choices that extend beyond finding a job with top-notch insurance and going broke trying to stay alive.

CSH

Rural hospitals are closing all over Tennessee. When good, God-fearing, country folk start dying on the two-hour trip to the nearest hospital, there’ll be hell to pay … for Democrats, of course. Republicans will blame Obamacare.

Jeff

I was a conservative Republican when I was laid-off from my job in 2000. The ever-increasing cost of maintaining insurance via COBRA convinced me that socialized medicine is the way to go. I don’t mind my tax dollars supporting such a system, even though Obamacare isn’t such a system and doesn’t go nearly far enough toward socialized medicine.

Republicans lose their jobs as frequently and as easily as anyone else. And I just want to laugh at retired Republicans with Medicare who oppose Obamacare.

Brunetto Latini

To those who can understand the plight of the uninsured and support medical insurance for the least of our brethren and don’t fear to speak up about it — my hat is off to you!

Truth Be Told

I hope others are joining all good Republicans like myself in leaving this country if Obamacare continues. We shall find a civilized country without socialized medicine, like … uh … uh. I’ll have to get back to you, brothers. Hold off on the packing.

tnRepublican